Whats the thing in west of going away from parents as u grow ?
By tutul0045
@tutul0045 (2630)
India
June 29, 2010 11:57am CST
Hey friends,
I have seen in a lot of movies and have also talked to a lot of westerner's thats, its quite a shameful thing for them to live with their parents after a certain age.
In our culture it's just the opposite. We tend to live with out parents forever and when they are young they take care of us and when we grow its like reciprocating the favor.
This difference in culture is very difficult to understand as what's the harm in staying with yr parents under one roof and enjoy life to the fullest.
Some people whom i have talked to say that it gives them the freedom to live the way they like to and make them mature to take their own decisions. I don't really agree with that. Though in India also people are more inclined in that type of lifestyle now a days.
I'm sure both has its advantages and disadvantages. But lets hear from you all!
Cheers,
Tutul
4 people like this
12 responses
@animegirl334 (3263)
• United States
30 Jun 10
I remember in a movie where a man was in his thirties and still living with his parents and people thought he was either a coward or mentally ill. I grew up in America and here, I guess people value independence so they want children to separate from their parents after a certain age. I would want to live with my mother and care for her after I grow up. Hopefully she would feel the same way.
@tutul0045 (2630)
• India
30 Jun 10
Do that anime. Its lot petter to stay together than to live alone. I hope she will understand it as well. When yr parents grow old thats the time they need u most!
Good luck!
Cheers,
Tutul
@wongchoiyee (7413)
• Malaysia
29 Jun 10
Hi tutul,
I was previously urge to move out in my early 20's but as soon as I find job and work and experiencing difficulties, I realized that what the joy of being with my parents.
I mean to take care of them when they are old and they are a good listerner. I always share my problems with them. I m glad I did not move out last time.
If I was, then I don't think I will be able to say such things to you.
@sid556 (30959)
• United States
30 Jun 10
Hi tutuloo,
I live in the states and here it is normal for kids to grow up and want to be out on their own. I moved out of my parents house as soon as I turned 18. When the kids are grown and moved out to start families of their own then the parents can have the privacy and freedom to re-connect and enjoy each other. I don't think there is any shame in the kids staying on longer with the parents as long as they are working and actually helping out. I don't agree with them bringing girlfriends/boyfriends to live with the parents.
@kiran8 (15348)
• Mangalore, India
29 Jun 10
Hi tutul, I know it is difficult for us to come to terms with what is supposedly normal in the western society.But one can take the best of both the cultures and make it suit our own life style.I see many Indians taking care or rather living with their parents, but there is hardly any happiness for the older people .Some of them are ill treated and do not receive any kind of emotional support, so what is the use of living together.I feel it is better for the parents to live by themselves wit dignity and peace instead of being humiliated by their children all the time...
@tutul0045 (2630)
• India
30 Jun 10
Hi kiran,
You made a very valid point here. But u know i have a lot of cousins who are settled in USA. Their parents are all over 60 now and live a very hard life. They have money but not the peace.
They raised their kids, educated them and now when they are old they have no one to take care of them. I see them going out to buy their own medicines, groccery and also pay their bills on their own. Very recently one of them had to get operated and i was there to assist them instead of their own kids.
Life is indeed very strange and there are so many things which are beyond control. I would rather stay with my parents whole life or if i have to move i would love to take them with me. Living alone is no living at all in my opinion.
Cheers,
Tutul
@kiran8 (15348)
• Mangalore, India
30 Jun 10
I agree tutul...I somehow feel that this relationship and feelings should be mutual and not come out of fear or forced upon you.We have to appreciate without being told and also realise that our parents need us in their old age for more reasons than money alone.they need security and an emotional anchor which they expect from their children...But if that kind of mutual trust and love is not possible then it is better that they live by themselves..
@tutul0045 (2630)
• India
30 Jun 10
Hey Kiran,
Yes u r right. Love and respect should come from within and shouldn't be forced. What i feel though is that in the modern times people tend to have a nuclear family and its hurting us big time. Also the compromising power of people has gone down like anything and it can be seen in the number of divorce cases we see in the big cities.
It reminds me of the saying.. "United we are strong. Divided we fall".
Cheers,
Tutul
@Cutie18f (9546)
• Philippines
30 Jun 10
In our country, family is very important. Our parents stay with children especially when the parents are already old. I see nothing wrong with living with your parents. They are our family. Some children work in other countries and bigger cities but the communication is alive 24/7 and there is always get-together during special occasions like Christmas, birthdays, etc.
@tutul0045 (2630)
• India
30 Jun 10
Hey,
In every country family is very important cutie. That's something which is a gift from god to us and we need to respect that. Family is more than communicating. We need to be there in happy as well as in sad days.
I understand that a lot of people has to go foreign nations for better pay etc. But they must not forget that they have equal responsibilities for their parents too.
People need to find the right balance in life.
Cheers,
Tutul
@SkylerD (85)
• United States
30 Jun 10
To me its just a natural learning experiance. When kids turn into teenagers they usualy wan't more and more freedoms. This incldes driving a car, staying out late and getting a job to pay for your own things. It involves independence winthin people that are turning into adults. For the moast part we are a do it yourself culture. If you can't learn to do it yourself, chances are good that your not going to make it very far. Wanting to move out is the first step of starting your own life. In my opinion parents arn't supposed to hold your hand for you your whole life, their supposed to teach you as your growing up how to live on your own and how to be successful.
@Mitraa (3184)
• India
30 Jun 10
In my opinion, youth is the stage of life that is supprted by knowledge and action only! Wisdom has a little meaning in this period of life in most of the cases! As a person grows older and enters into the old-age, that stage of life is supported by culture and wisdom alongwith rules of actions. So, I must say that in western style of living, they are more material focused and less relation focused. Hence the relation between old parents and their young children is outdated in their view of life. By this, they not only ignore wisdom from the old parents but also loose their cultural aspect of life that develops in their old age!
But in my country India, we honour knowledge, action, experience, wisdom and culture in all the ages and stages of life. That is why we always take care of the younger ones as well as the older ones with due responsibility!
Thanks for this nice discussion and let's hope for a change in western way of life!!
@tutul0045 (2630)
• India
30 Jun 10
Hi,
I agree with you completely. I met a person in my office and he was american from Ohio and we were discussing about their life style and family setups etc.
A friend of mine asked about his parents and he replied " I have met my biological father only twice in my life! "
How tragic is that for a kid emotionally. U know yr father is alive and u cant even go and see him. I wonder how can u even live when u know u have a kid and you are not taking any interest in his well being. And thats called as developed nations!!! Goodness me!
The basic concept of living is missing and no wonder we are living in a world where there is no trust amongst people!
Cheers,
Tutul
@Porcospino (31366)
• Denmark
29 Jun 10
I live in a western country and in my country most people move away from their parents' home when they are 18 or in their early 20's. Independence is considered very important, and in my culture it is important to learn to live on your own and to learn to handle things on your own. People who live with their parents when they are in their late 20's or older are considered a little strange and immature. You used the word "shameful" and I think that decribes the attitude pretty well, and some people will think that there is something "wrong" with you if you don't leave your parents' home and they will think you are very immature.
I grew up in this culture and the ideas about independence are normal to me, I have learned to think that way, but my friends from other countries don't think that way, and in many countries it is normal to live with your parents. I think there are advantages about this lifestyle (living with your parents), and I like the idea about helping eachother, but in my country where few people live that way today.
@tutul0045 (2630)
• India
30 Jun 10
Hi porcos,
Very well said. And this culture in my opinion is hurting a lot of people in the west. If i look back in my life at the age of 18 -19 i made so many mistakes. And thats when u need the parental support. If u throw them out at that age then u r exposing yr own children to some very awful situations.
Also if u have caring parents u think about them while committing anything sinful or any kind of bad thing.
I personally believe that its a beautiful thing to actually live along with yr parents. No matter what age you are u get their advices in life and then take the right decision.
I get a feeling if this culture is implemented in the west a lot of their problems will be solved.
Cheers,
Tutul
@bounce58 (17385)
• Canada
29 Jun 10
I think it is part of learning for kids. As they move away from home they become more independent. And they would be free to make their own choices in life. Even free to make their own mistakes and learn from them. As parents we should support these. If as parents you did your part well, the kids would reciprocate the favor and take care of you as you grow older, even if they don't live with you.
@mjcookie (2271)
• Philippines
30 Jun 10
I know what you're talking about. I am from the Philippines, and our culture is just like yours--we live with our family even when we already have our own families. It's in our culture to love being connected to people. I guess we just value connectivity more than independence. I love it this way. Of course I'd love to have my own family and career someday, but i don't wanna lose contact with my loved ones.
@tutul0045 (2630)
• India
30 Jun 10
Thats the spirit mj. Even i want to live with my parents as long as i can.
Cheers,
Tutul
@umbrelatc (78)
• Mexico
30 Jun 10
Hello, since I´m going to stop being children up to 99 years, if I have to show mature to desert situations, I do not care to live alone or with my parents, I just want to live well and comfortable with the world.
@tutul0045 (2630)
• India
30 Jun 10
Hmm.. with all due respect .. don't u think thats one of the reason why many westerners have a filthy life.