Polygamy/open relationships vs Monogamy

Canada
July 13, 2010 3:07pm CST
I am curious who would rather be in a polygamous or open relationship as opposed to a monogsmous relationship. I started a topic about cheating which got a wee bit derailed when someone stated that only 3% of the population would be in favor of a monogamous relationship. So dear mylot, I have come to you to see what your views are. I am curious if I am old fanshioned in my want for a loving monogamous relationship and if open/pologamy is the way to go. For him to be correct in his 3% estimate I need 40 replies in which only 1 can be FOR momogamy. For each reply in favor of Monogamy I will recalculate how many more Polygamy/open relationship replies I need to keep the percentage at 3.
1 person likes this
10 responses
@pastigger (612)
• United States
13 Jul 10
I prefer Monogamy as I don't want to have to share my spouse with someone else. I would be really hurt. I have watched a few programs on TV and thought to my self wouldn't it be great though to have someone else help with house work or kids or earning money, but I guess you could get that with a nanny or a roomate neither that I want. Because a 2nd wife would not work for me. This is my family and my husband so no I would not be open to an open/pologamy relationship I am very protective of my family and not willing to share.
2 people like this
• Canada
13 Jul 10
I agree! It would be nice to have someone to share the housework or kids with. But a nanny would work just as well and hopefully she's not sleeping with my husband! Update: need 39 pologamy responses for the 3% estimate to be correct.
1 person likes this
@alaskanray (4636)
• United States
14 Jul 10
Preferences vs necessities, hmmm? Well, I would have to weigh in on the monogamy side, as well. I have never even been tempted to stray when I was in relationships. But that is a preference for me. As for necessity, I would marry a widowed or divorced man and accept his wife (sainted or ex) as a part of my family. I could also see myself in a polygamous marriage should that ever become what was necessary. I'm not so selfish as to insist on monogamy if the necessity of polygamy ever arose. I'm a member of the LDS church and we have a history of polygamy in our church but it was never done willy-nilly. A man had to be called to it by the church leaders and his wife had to give her permission. i.e. Wife #1 had to approve wife #2 and wife #s 1&2 had to approve wife #3, etc. The entire purpose of marriage is to build a family and that required total commitment to the family as a whole. Cheating on a spouse is not polygamy, it is adultery. My mother was a second wife, my father a widower. Sharing a husband wasn't exactly a factor there but in a way it still was because my mother had to raise my father's first wife's children. When I married a divorced man I found myself in a tough position and learned some hard lessons. One thing that I came to decide was that if I ever found myself in another relationship with a divorced man (particularly when children were involved), I would insist on a relationship with the ex-wife, as well...and before the wedding! I see an ex-wife as extended family and would insist on including her in discussions about the children and consider her in any family decisions. This is similar to how a polygamous marriage would have to work, as well. Years ago I went on a "Polygamy date" with my girlfriend and the gentleman she later ended up marrying. It was a lot of fun. We used to hang together and he would introduce us as his "wives". When they started dating seriously, I was thrilled and I even drove up to Montana for their wedding reception when they got married. Fond memories.
1 person likes this
• Canada
14 Jul 10
Forigve me for asking but what is LDS? I agree with what you said about having a relationship with someone's ex wife or ex husband. They will forever be in the children's lives and should be treated with respect. You never want to cause a wedge between a child and either of their parents. I wouldn't mind a "polygamy date" it sounds kind of fun, as long as all parties were aware of exactly what it was and the third person did not have any misconceptions. update: 100% monogamy.
1 person likes this
• Canada
14 Jul 10
That's what I thought it meant but I figured I would ask before asuming anything! I see the comercials on tv all the time :p
1 person likes this
• United States
14 Jul 10
LDS="Mormon". The name of the church is the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Days Saints. "LDS" = "Latter-Days Saints". The term "Mormon" comes from one of our books of scripture called the Book of Mormon and was coined by non-members in the early days of the church as a derogatory term.
@twoey68 (13627)
• United States
14 Jul 10
I could never do an "open relationship"...I'm just too possessive to do that. When I'm with someone I want to know that I'm the only one for him and he's only with me. Personally, I think if someone wants to have multiple partners then they should just stay single and free and not enter into any committed relationships. [b]**AT PEACE WITHIN** ~~STAND STRONG IN YOUR BELIEFS~~[/b]
• Canada
15 Jul 10
I am also way too possessive to have an open relationship. I think that people should stay single if they should happen to want to sleep with more than one lady as well.
@nympha687 (940)
• United States
13 Jul 10
Everybody prefers monogamy for peace of mind. No one wants their partners sneaking out on them nor do people want hassles caused by being polygamous. But if polygamy is legal and morally upright, I bet everybody would want to try.
1 person likes this
• Canada
13 Jul 10
But what would the fun be in that? People seem to like to do what is dangerous! update: now need 68 more pologamy only replies to make the 3% for monogamy mark.
1 person likes this
@jennyze (7028)
• Indonesia
14 Jul 10
Only 3% want monogamous relationship? Where did that someone got the fact from? I bet most of them are teenagers, want as many partners as possible so they can boast to their friends. I am an old fashion one where one man is destined for one woman and vice versa.
• Canada
14 Jul 10
He said that it is from his own experiences... and girls online. I am old fashioned as well.
@jennyze (7028)
• Indonesia
15 Jul 10
I bet there is no woman wanted him to be a husband, so that's why he said it. And the girls....?
• Philippines
13 Jul 10
I think no one prefers polygamous relationship because we don't. As for me, I would prefer it as well. I would be focused in just one person in a relationship. I am totally against polygamy but I don't condemn those who are into it.
• Canada
13 Jul 10
Oh I am not condeming it either, I believe that htere are people who are just unable to remain faithful to one person. I am just curious if this person's 3% of people would prefer monogamy over polygamy or an open relationship. update: now need 97 openrelationship/polygamy answers to remain at 3%
1 person likes this
@Andyvil (793)
• Philippines
14 Jul 10
I prefer monogamy over polygamy. I think that being polygamous is only good if you are the one committing it. It would be a different thing if you were on the other side of the fence. So thats why I prefer monogamy over polygamy.
@Bhadine (594)
• Philippines
14 Jul 10
Polygamy might be exciting for some, but as for me I do prefer to have only one spouse. What is the use of having many partners if all you need is one? I mean, one spouse is more than enough to satisfy and make us happy. One is perfect for an ideal relationship filled with love and loyalty. One spouse is the best if we have CONTENTMENT.
• Portugal
15 Jul 10
monogamous^^ i just need a guy in my life not many ones^^ we must dedicate our love to one person and that person to us too^^ why do we need so many lovers? we just need one that give us all we need^^ all the love we need to be happy^^ poligamy is for those that dont want nothing serious and just want fun for the rest of their lives^^ just s e x and s e x.
@vhings_88 (294)
• Philippines
14 Jul 10
I'm a one man woman. I don't want to have another man in my life except my husband. We're happy together. As a Christian, I do believe that marriage is sacred and you should have only one spouse. Here in our country, divorce is not applicable but we could file annulment if we want to end marriage.
• Canada
14 Jul 10
I don't agree with the "still being married after divorce" thing. I mean I can understand it, but I don't believe it. It is not like if you marry the wrong person (which does happen!) God is going to smite you down on the altar and push you out to find the right one. I can understand why it is seen in the eyes of God as "still being married" but I don't necessarily agree with it. update: Still at 100% monogamy and 0% open relationship