Vague Question / Scenario
By SomeCowgirl
@SomeCowgirl (32191)
United States
August 6, 2010 1:44am CST
If you were told by another family member that someone in your family was supposedly doing something illegal that could potentially harm them, would you do something about it? If you couldn't do anything about it legally (as in through the law, or an outside organization) would you instead try to get the facts and then confront the person with it?
Would you confront someone else that should be doing something about it but isn't, even if this means possibly disrespecting (unintentionally) an elder? Also potentially making them really mad at you?
Right now I am stuck in a situation where it seems the only thing I can do is go to an elder in the family and ask them if what I've heard is true, and if it is, I have to or SHOULD tell them that they shouldn't allow what's happening to happen.
Any advice?
1 person likes this
9 responses
@parrot2010 (812)
•
6 Aug 10
I would have to confront them and warn them the dangers of ding whatever it is they're doing and would encourage them to quit whatever it is. I would also warn that if they get caught then I won't make up lies to reduce their punishment because I did warn them. I wouldn't tell on them myself though, I'd just be hoping they don't get caught.
2 people like this
@SomeCowgirl (32191)
• United States
6 Aug 10
The situation that is happening now wouldn't cause the person to go to jail, but could kill them, or hurt them. I am kind of nervous about confronting anyone with it, but I know it's the right thing to do. One thing I didn't mention is it could potentially get someone fired or terminated because of it.
@aliasgar_shah (9)
• India
6 Aug 10
Well, I think this is a very tricky situation to be in. On one side, you would wanna complain it to the legal authorities as it might distort your own family's name in the society. But on the other hand your sympathies go out with our own family member.
You should first and foremost try to personally as a friend and as a well wisher try to confront the suspected family member and warn him and advice him thoroughly about the wrong he or she is doing. If still this does not work, then seek help from someone elder in your family, you may also try counseling, even if u would have to consult a professional.
Lastly, if all these measures fail then we are only left with ceding to the legal bindings of the society we live in.
Peace to all
Ali
1 person likes this
@SomeCowgirl (32191)
• United States
6 Aug 10
I would not call the cops, when you say "legal authorities" It makes me think of that. It's my family, just not my family name (I am quite literal person). There is more then just one person who could be doing better in this situation, so confronting just one person might not work at all. I know I am very vague so no one really knows what I am talking about, I may start a discussion later with the specifics, but until then let's just say it's more complicated, and yet not so complicated as it looks.
@aliasgar_shah (9)
• India
6 Aug 10
Yeah, i can understand who tough it can get sometimes to come up with a decision. I think lets just cut out the legal authorities. You might want to bring in more than one person, get the elders and quite a few people of your family involved to discuss things over. Hope all gets well soon.
1 person likes this
@SomeCowgirl (32191)
• United States
6 Aug 10
Atleast two others then the one that is doing the wrong will need to be invovled as they are involved, but thanks so much for your advice, it's much appreciated.
@SomeCowgirl (32191)
• United States
6 Aug 10
Well even if I've found out early enough it might not help anything at all. I've got to call the "elder" today sometime, but I'm kind of afraid to at the same time because confronting him, even in a gentle discussion like way is scary!
@celticeagle (168171)
• Boise, Idaho
7 Aug 10
Getting the facts first would definitely be the thing to do. And then you have to ask yourself: What is more important here? A family member getting mad at me,OR, do you want to do what is right? I wouldn't tell the elder what they should do? I would ask them what they plan on doing, and, in accordance with what they say I would express to them what you HAVE TO DO!
1 person likes this
@SomeCowgirl (32191)
• United States
7 Aug 10
I called the elder yesterday and talked to them. One thing I wasn't certain about was whether it was true or not, atleast whether it was completely true. I did get the facts, and before I could ask what he was going to do, he told me what he had done, so I am glad atleast now that everything will be better.
@JenInTN (27514)
• United States
8 Aug 10
I would go to the elder and find out if the rumors are true. I would also ask the elder what they think should be done about it or how you can help. If that didn't work then you might have to take it into your own hands. I don't know how close this person is to you or what they are doing but it sounds like it is someone that you really care about. We both know that people do what they want to do and no amount of worrying or talking can change that if that's what they want. Do what you can but know that you tried if they don't come around to your way of thinking. You can't let another person's choices rule your life. You have a life too.
1 person likes this
@SomeCowgirl (32191)
• United States
8 Aug 10
I called the "elder" the other day (My grandfather) and talked to him, he said it was true but that he had taken care of it. Basically while it's not been confronted to the person directly (atleast not that I understood or am aware of now) they no longer can do what they were doing, not unless they bribe another person who I am pretty certain wouldn't be bought.
@SomeCowgirl (32191)
• United States
8 Aug 10
wow killed? No not killed, it was just what was being done was harmful to someone's help. That's been put to a stop though, as I've talked to the "elder" (which literally meant my grandfather)...
All is well now, or to my knowledge.
@gabs8513 (48686)
• United Kingdom
6 Aug 10
Hi Cowgirl as it is Family yes I would confront them and also the Person who knows about and should do something about it
I would talk to them and tell them straight and even it does mean being disrespectful, they are being disrespectful to specially the Person who knows about it as they are not stopping it or even trying to stop it
@SomeCowgirl (32191)
• United States
6 Aug 10
Actually a lot of people know about it I think, and the longer I wait I become no better then any of them. One person could get fired if I in fact could contact the outside organization, though I am not sure that even if I could I would want to. It's all a confusing mess but first I have to make sure it's true as the person who told me about it, though I love and trust, could have imagined things or exaggerated, or the person she got the info from could've been lying or exaggerating.
When I do find out if it is true or not I will have to say something to the elder who is in charge of the person who is doing the illegal thing, but well I do not like to be disrespectful and I feel also that even if I were to say something, nothing may be done about it. Either way I know I should try, and if nothing happens then I may have to go straight to the person who is doing the wrong.
The person who is doing the wrong thing also has a few diseases that could partially be causing the misjudgement but the fact that people are allowing her to do it anyway, when they could stop it, is wrong.
I don't want any of this on my conscious if something were to happen, especially if I knew I could do something about it, if at the very least just make the person think.
@moonchild117 (1987)
• Philippines
6 Aug 10
If the norm in your family is to tell your elder first, then I guess that's what you should do. If what you have heard is true, then tell your elder that he has the authority to stop that particular family member from doing what he/she's doing.
But -- and this is just my opinion -- if the elder fails to do so, then I guess you yourself can do something about the situation. I know you are concerned about that family member and is doing what is right to put him/her back on track. You are just acting out of concern, and if that person becomes mad for you "meddling" then that's just his opinion. Make him/her realize that you care for him/her that's why you are doing this. Good luck.
@SomeCowgirl (32191)
• United States
6 Aug 10
Well it's not necessarily the norm, that isn't to say that everyone in the family doesn't respect the elder, we do, but this situation is different because in a sense he is her caregiver.
The person to whom it would directly effect would be mad at me I am sure, but I am only looking out for her wellbeing. I know I am being terribly vague about everything. There is also another person who might be mad at me and now that I think about it other people who would be mad at me because I may cause the person to get fired.
I suppose if I were to disclose the relations it might help give people a better picture but I hope by saying Elder people figure out to whom I refer.
@PDBME2 (1014)
• United States
6 Aug 10
I tried to give advice to a niece of my husband once but it just ended up with me not being able to talk to her alone. I think the person who was her caretaker told her not to give me any information so she avoided me everytime I saw her. I heard later on that she got pregnant, was told to get an abortion, and now all the advice about her being careful was for nothing. The person who took care of her acts as if nothing happened but everyone knows. This is just a small case of what happens in this family, there is so much more, but it seems as if I am talking to a wall to anyone who is involved. Sometimes they listen then at times they take your advice as criticism as to how they are living their lives. I just keep quiet now and avoid visiting them anymore. I know all the things that are happening, even though we live so far away.
@SomeCowgirl (32191)
• United States
6 Aug 10
There has been a lot of things going on in my family too. This most recent thing has happened before I believe, but this time it is a little different because there are things that could be done to stop it from happening but yet nothing is getting done. Then again I am not quite sure if it's even true, but I believe it is.
I don't want to have to call and talk to the someone who could control it without it causing a confrontation with the person who is actually doing it, but it seems like I might have to because it's for the benefit of the person who might be doing something wrong.
I am also the youngest out of all involved and though I should have a right to say what I wish, I still have to respect the people. I maybe could go a different route and kind of behind everyone's backs but that might not work, and if it does might just make things worse, if not for people being mad at me, but for the end result which might cause the person who is doing wrong to be even less supervised.