Is education is a business? Do it is supposed to be?

India
August 20, 2010 1:11am CST
Like a continuation to an earlier post, don’t you think education is a business now? It is a pure business aiming profit as the motivation, instead of providing better and quality education? How do you agree with this? Basic education to be provided free of cost or subsidized upto a certain standard. How is educational system working in your country? Would like to know more on this from you. Thank-s
4 people like this
11 responses
• United States
21 Aug 10
Well, I think that degrees are not what they used to be. In the U.S.A., private schools like Harvard and Yale are still the top schools, followed by the state universities, and then trade schools or schools like "American Career College" or "University of Phoenix". To me, it's like anyone can get a degree nowadays. Anyone can go to college and get an education, but the thing is who recognizes your degree, and who will higher what degree? I am going to a state college that has a high ranking, and people would love to higher people with my degree, but if I went to any other college, like University of Phoenix, I don't think anyone would recognize my degree.
• United States
30 Aug 10
Again, this is how it is. A college such as "Devry Univerisity" is looked down upon, but universities such as "University of California, Irvine", "Cal Tech", "Stanford" or my personal favorite "University of Southern California" or "USC" are all reputable universities. A lot of places will discriminate against "Devry" and "American Career College" because they feel that they aren't real institutions, and that you don't have to work as hard you to do coming from university such as "Cal Tech". I am going to a university that is very known, I won't say where in case there are any other students on from that university, but this university have been around for 100 years, and it is known as one of the best Agricultural Schools in America and one of the best Engineering Schools as well. This is a university that everyone recognizes and knows that you have to work hard hell to get out of. It has that kind of reputation. It really all comes down to reputation. If your university has a great reputation and you have a degree from there, anyone will hire you. If you university has an "iffy" or "not-so-good" reputation, then no one will want to hire you. That is just how it is.
• India
30 Aug 10
Hi dear, If this is the case, then what the point in providing the degrees by the colleges. If they have the authority, it should be approved and recognized by all the universities. Everyone cannot go to higher colleges because they may not accommodate all who are seeking admission over there. So, on a priority basis with merit, they will get admission. All those who are going out to depend on some other colleges. In such cases, the authorities should recognize all the degree qualification, regardless of who is issued it. Such discrimination is prevailing all over the places and not only in education, but all areas wherever we goes. As education is an essential and fundamental criteria of the country, the authorities have to adopt necessary steps to standardize the same. Thank you for your update. Regards, Thank-s
1 person likes this
@jpso138 (7851)
• Philippines
20 Aug 10
Well it is obvious that most of the schools and universities were opened with the intention to teach and of course to gain money. That is what business is all about. I rarely here or know of some institution that teaches which does not consider profit in return. Although there are some. Well, our government does provide education. Usually its free on public schools but most of those who can afford tend to go to private schools since they offer better facilities and better programs.
@jpso138 (7851)
• Philippines
6 Sep 10
Thank you for the BR award. Well, I think we can summarize it this way.. Better education then there is a price to pay. But this does not mean that public schools or those free schools are not good. It entirely depends on the student as well as the teacher and the program being used.
• India
28 Aug 10
Hi dear, Thanks for your valid comments. Regards, Thank-s
• China
20 Aug 10
eh... the motivation the educational system in my countory, I think, can be thought to be OK, Because his aiming is still to provide better and quality education. But the burden given by the school and the family is too heavy to be beared for the children.
• India
20 Aug 10
Hi dear, Thanks for your comments and the points noted. You are correct and we need to be more attention on the burden that has given to the children in the name of learning. The burden they carry (in both - say study and carrying books and notes) is heavy. The increased level of syllabus and the portion that to be completed is very much and beyond their limit. Also, the method adopted to teach the children also to be modified and adopt time tested techniques. The pressure from the school teachers as well as the parents also a nightmare to the children. The psychology of the child to understand by the guardian and motivate them in a healthy way of treatment. Regards, Thank-s
@sjlskl (3382)
• Singapore
20 Aug 10
I have no problem if a private school aims to make a profit out of educating people. At the end of the day, it is still a business and the owner need to make a living out of it. But if a government-funded school is looking to make a profit, then I have a big issue with it. One of the basic thing that a government should be is to provide education for its people.
• India
20 Aug 10
Hi dear, We know that the education is offered by the respective governments and the government has given approval to start educational institutions to private ownership also. The private management is providing more quality education if compared with the government schools or colleges provides. As the private sector education is more on profit in mind, they could offer a better or quality (systematic) education. Many cases, the syllabus is provided by the central board or as per the recognized authority. The undertakings are low in all levels and only unaffordable students are getting admissions in those schools/colleges. As the private management schools are charging higher fees, the governments also trying to increase the base accordingly. A combined and change of system is required. Because the changes in the modern life and practice is changed a lot. But the conventional and outdated system of education will be far behind meet the present requirements. Regards, Thank-s
@aaronfyzeon (1920)
• Philippines
20 Aug 10
Thank you for this nice topic. Yes I actually admire the education system here in our country. I have been a part of it because I experienced it all. In high school, I have studied in a private school wherein the education is so expensive but it's worth it. I have been in a Science curriculum. and the kind of education in private schools most of them are really that good compared to public or government schools. We can say that the tuition fee that we have is very well-spent because I get a great level of education with it compared to the public ones. During college, I have entered the top State University here in the Philippines wherein it is funded by the government. It is a convergence of the top and brainy students from all over the country and is being mold and developed there in our university. There is a real world class kind of teaching as well. But I will still have to say that the facilities that we have is still poor compared to the Private school ones. But it is up to us on how to manage all these insufficient facilities. The ones in private schools which has a great amount of tuition fee and definitely a business are the ones having the great facilities that we always long for. Still there is a balance. All we have to do is just to learn from ourselves which is a great thing. I would just like to add that there are levels of scholarships that we have. from the full scholarship, being a half paid tuition fee scholar and the ones that will pay out the full tuition fee of the university. if you are not a scholar in our university, you will be paying like half of the tuition fee of the private ones.
• India
20 Aug 10
Hi dear, It is called a discussion. Well worded and disciplined language. It shows your standard and level of education as well. It is getting a better feeling that there is somewhere education is considered as a way to modernization. There are countries providing so much amount of money in the name of education. Like scholarships, fee concessions and providing other facilities for studies etc. In the modern world, there are various levels of education and lots of field of education. As per the taste and carrier, people would select the higher education also. But the fundamental education ie student upto the age of 12-13 should be provided by a centralized platform and all the basic amenities are to be provided to the children upto this age. Here the disparity among class and economic levels also can be eliminated. If this is adopted the basis will remain and if scientifically manage this system of education upto this age, a uniform growth and development can be achieved globally. However, all these are depends on every country's view and opinion only. Regards and thank you for your valid opinion. Regards, Thank-s
1 person likes this
• Philippines
20 Aug 10
You really never cease to amaze me. My nose just really started bleeding as I read your response. hehehehe. Thank you so much for noticing. I am not in the field of communication wherein we use English Language and practice most of the time writing or speaking in English though. I am in the field of Chemical Engineering and I am having a review now to take my board exam. Instead of nibbling all the complexities of my technical subjects i.e. Chemicals and it's compositions, here I am responding to some mind twisting topics here in myLot. I really agree with you that during these formative years of mental development intellectually there should be a certain standard of education throughout the country. The government or the Department that is in charge of that should make sure that the level of the education should be within the standards of what is really being imposed. Your opinion eventhough it is just being stated is really realistic. You should not say it is "only my opinion" but say It is my opinion!! This should really be heard! because it really makes sense!
@cjsalas (109)
• Philippines
20 Aug 10
Most of the time, private schools become a business. Very for the schools who have high tuition fees but they could still maintain quality education. While unfortunate for the students who are studying in an expensive school but doesn't give quality education. I do agree that some schools aim to profit to motivate more their teachers, however, it becomes unfair to those who can't even afford the education yet willing to learn.
• India
20 Aug 10
Hi dear, As we can assure that the business of education will never meet a loss. Because as the population is increasing, the line of business also increasing and many are considered this area is a ever ending profit making business. Even from a nursery child classes to the top level education is aimed with a higher level of profit and earning. Above all, the students who are studying should be obedient and sufferable to all the treatment they are providing. The heavy burden on the parents are the other important factor. A great amount of money should be kept apart of higher education and expenses as fees. Above all, if the child gets failed, what is the net result... So our system need a reformatting and restructure. Unless this is not happened, the improvement on the respective areas will be 'O'. A group of our own country's tomorrow’s promises is being destroyed. Regards, Thank-s
• China
20 Aug 10
eh... the motivation the educational system in my countory, I think, can be thought to be OK, Because his aiming is still to provide better and quality education. But the burden given by the school and the family is too heavy to be beared for the children.
@knicnax (2233)
• Philippines
20 Aug 10
sad to say that there are some educational institutions who'd rather have a bad rep as educators and earn a lot that have a good rep as educators but earn enough. I used to teach in a popular IT school, During my stay, I made it a point to pass everything I know with my students, I don't hold back. I want to give quality education even if I have a low salary, but it seems to me that the management is more concerned in earning more money than providing quality education. It was an IT school but computers were always malfunctioning, always slow. It's a sad thought, but yes, education is a business now. And the worse part is a lot of selfish business men are operating.
• India
20 Aug 10
Hi dear, Thanks for you comments. Many are of the opinion is same as what you have. Some educational institutions are keeping a very good standard in their teaching and keeping a decent standard of education. All these are affordable only to highly placed and wealthy class people only. Their motivation itself is providing good quality by earning higher returns. But in general, the case is so pathetic and the quality of education itself is so poor. There are lots of areas to be improved in the whole education system. From the student’s level, teaching/faculty, management etc. are to be modified. A moderate and well planned system is mandatory. Step by step implementation only possible, because we cannot stop all at a point and restart as a fresh beginning. The syllabus, the training to the faculty, the compensation to the staff and teachers and a lots of real things are to be noticed and only after can expect any major changes in this area. Regards, Thank-s
• Philippines
21 Aug 10
Hi! I believe it is. Nowadays most schools are money making schools. Just like in this school I know, they asked students to buy a year book amounting to 3,500p or else you can't graduate, and 1 1/2 year later, there is still no year book. Imagine that??? It's really sad.
@sinaj292 (602)
• India
21 Aug 10
i think now education become a business..... person who is willing to pay more is only getting good education..... others are need to be with what they are getting... i think this is not a good sign to our education system...... there need some serious action to prevent this ..... nowadays there are agencies in almost all the towns to contact for our education..... govt not playing any role in the matter of student's future..... they are only the spectator .....
@rcdhakal (34)
• Nepal
21 Aug 10
Never, Education is right. Education should not be used as business. There are many perons who are using erning plate to the eduction. Eduction is going to be expesive that is very wrong.