I hear some Indians hate hindi is this true or is it a rare few ?
By hari1111
@hari1111 (238)
New Zealand
August 21, 2010 9:12pm CST
I am half Indian, but I do not speak any indian language at all. I have a few indian friends and I asked a few of them and they say they hate hindi for this that and another reason.
I don't see why Indians would hate their national language. I don't know what my mother tongue is but it would be fun to learn an indian language so I can embrace my cultural heritage.
Though it would also be fun to learn the bhangra (this is the most awesome dance I have ever seen)
Thanks
*note i do not intend to offend any one I am merely asking a question*
1 person likes this
3 responses
@ram_cv (16513)
• India
22 Aug 10
Hi Hari,
A lot of indian states especially some south indian states where there have been anti-Hindi movements. But off late all these movements have subsided. These days Hindi is accepted as the mother tongue and all schools in India cover Hindi.
Cheers!
Ram
@sudiptacallingu (10879)
• India
25 Aug 10
Hindi is the national language and NOT the mother tongue…each Indian state has its own mother tongue. Most schools teach three languages…vernacular or mother tongue, English and Hindi (as the national language).
1 person likes this
@hari1111 (238)
• New Zealand
22 Aug 10
I hear that not everyone speaks or understands hindi, don't quote me but I read from someone elses posts that 30% of Indians cant speak hindi. If india has 1 billion then thats 300 million that can't speak or understand hindi.
I think many people do understand hindi, but what I dont understand is do they actually dislike hindi or is it just a select few who don't like it?
@sudiptacallingu (10879)
• India
25 Aug 10
Yes, there are many many Indians who hate the idea of learning Hindi simply coz it’s the national language. If you look at how the Indian nation was created and carved into states, you’ll see that the states were created on a language basis…each state of India has its own robust language and the people take immense pride in speaking, nurturing and propagating their own language. Each of the languages are akin to classic in themselves i.e. they are quite old and very rich in literary work. Hindi too, is spoken naturally as a language by a few states of north India. It also happens that our first PM was from one of these states where Hindi is naturally spoken. So you see, after independence, when Hindi was imposed as a national language, naturally people of other states took umbrage and protested…their pride was slighted by the fact that the language spoken by a few states in the north would now become the national language of the entire nation overriding their own languages in importance. So you see the problem? Hindi was never the national language in the entire Indian sub-continent…it was only after independence and after the birth of the Indian nation that Hindi was made the national language as because most of the influential people during those days of formation were Hindi speaking.
Personally I feel English should have been the national language…it’s a neutral language which would have bonded the nation better.
@hari1111 (238)
• New Zealand
25 Aug 10
Thanks these are really insightful comments!
I wish i could study a bit of my heritage and a bit of India's history. I know based on experience that India is rich, culturally aswell as naturally. India is one of the most fascinating countries. From its food down to its traditions.
Having english as the neutral language would have probably saved india from alot of strife. But I guess it is a bit too late now isnt it?
But I think people should not really be upset. Their individuality or cultural uniqueness is not taken away by learning hindi. It only enriches them as people ( this is my own opinion ). I find it great to be able to learn other languages!