Kumara Dharmasena - The 'Steve Buckner' of Sri Lanka?
@crazycrazyguy (139)
India
August 22, 2010 9:04am CST
No indian cricket fan ever forgets Kumara Dharmasena giving Sachin out 3 times consecutively even if they were not-outs. And in today's match against Sri Lanka he's given Sehwag and Raina out even if they were not-outs. I feel he is the 'Steve Buckner' of Sri Lanka. Why should ICC not take action against this guy even if he repeats it. He's been doing it many times. What do you feel?
12 responses
@ramaswamyvtkv (2879)
• India
22 Aug 10
I think the cricket should use technology for deciding LBW.
Atleast some review system should be adopted.
Kumara Dharmasena is making mistakes many time.
ICC should avoid him from umpiring panel
1 person likes this
@grvdubey11 (1879)
• India
22 Aug 10
With this technology and tv replays available such people cant be umpire for long in international matches, Its been a while since Kumara Dharamsena is umpring in international cricket but he never got much matches except in srilanka .There is a system in which match referee sends a report to ICC and that includes wrong decisions given or misconduct on field..I dont think Kumara Dharamsena will ever get to ICC's panel of international umpires.I wonder a player like Dharamsena who was banned by ICC because of suspected bowling action is now umpiring in international matches.How can a person who is a cheater himself can be allowed to umpire in international matches.He gave a wrong decision of giving Murali vijay caught of Jayawardhane when it was totally doubtful and benefit of doubt should have been given to batsman.Today also he gave three wrong decisions of 3 out of 4 top players in Indian team.But there is nothing to worry he can only help Srilanka win matches in this small tournament of very less importance.Moreover three extremely bad decisions today will surely halt his umpiring career .
@madhuvamsi (1185)
• India
22 Aug 10
well Sri lankan board might bribe the match refree, it can happen. Once upon time Asad Rauf(Pakistan umpire) use to be very hopless umpire. But still ICC has taken him as International umpire. Now, today, he was the man who gave Yuvaraj Singh out. So, it is not only Dharmasena but there are lot of other umpires who are not doing umpiring with perfection. These mistakes do happen with any umpire that is why ICC should introduce technology in the game. ICC can now even should think of imposing ban or suspension on Umpires as well. This will make umpires stand on their toes and they will think twice before giving a bad decision.
@madhuvamsi (1185)
• India
22 Aug 10
I remember Rauf giving these biased decisions against India when we are playing against Pakistan. what I observe is that Dharmasena is somewhat nervous guy but his umpire career was with lot of mistakes and we feel that he is supporting Sri Lanka because he is from Sri Lanka but these bad decisions were given by many umpires like Steve Bucknor, Darl Harper (he gave Sachin LBW when Sachin was ducking down to low bouncer of Mc Grath), Rudi Kurson in South Africa. So, these local umpires do commit mistakes but ICC is helpless because the respective country will send these umpires names to ICC. So, these things do happen nothing can be done, Indian team creates revenue to many like Bangladesh, Sri Lanka and Pakistan, no doubt but BCCI is more in making tournamnents and earning profits, do not care about these poor umpiring, they leave it to ICC to decide, what BCCI has done when Sachin was accused of ball tampering in South Africa, nothing, Sachin has to face humilitation. BCCI is keen in making money, nothing else. In India too there are umpires who are of the standard of Dharmasena. So, when a person is doing umpiring he should forget that he belongs to certain country. See that no bad decisions are given, once in a while ok but if these errors do happen every now and then that umpire must be banned.
@grvdubey11 (1879)
• India
22 Aug 10
I agree mate that Asad Rauf gives wrong decisions a lot but its not biased in favor of just one team.Dharamsena being home umpire and giving wrong decision in favor of home team makes it more controversial.Making mistake is human nature but favoring a team by umpire is totally different team and its unacceptable.about bribing if they will behave like they are in this tour just to win anyhow at home then they will lose good friend BCCI and Indian team touring Srilanka every year which is main source of income of Srilanka board, then they will not be left with any money to bribe.
@gunjandubey (512)
• India
22 Aug 10
Kumara Dharmasena once was a cricketer of srilanka.
But due to his illegal bowling action he was thrown out of international cricket.
Now after some years he started to do empiring,
then also he has not got rid of his cheating talent.
He is definitely "Steve Buckner" for india atleast
when they are playing against srilanka,
india should prefer not to play along with
him even if he is the third empire....
@dollar3235 (2062)
• India
22 Aug 10
Yes, you are "absolutely" correct!!!
Remember when he was a third umpire in test match, how did he declare "Murali Vijay" out?
No one could see even one action replay and he was declared out, can someone tell me how can a umpire make a mistake when he has all the latest technologies available in front of him and he can take his time?
He is not making mistakes, he is making sure that when he comes to India, he can get some good greetings from Indian public...I am sure if BCCI does not look into this matter, Indian fans will do something to him
@sharikh (43)
• India
22 Aug 10
absolutely...the ICC should take action against him..very poor decisions by the veteran player of sri lanka that made india in a worst condition...dharmasena repeating his mistakes...i think he is unfit and inexperience for international matches...indians must complain to authorities...it would not be allowed...
@dollar3235 (2062)
• India
22 Aug 10
Oops their is a misunderstanding, something that you feel as a mistake is absolutely not. Mistake is something that you do once or twice and with everyone, how come, his decisions are good against his country and bad against India only?
These repetitions prove that he is doing it purposefully, and please do not hope that ICC will take any action against it. Actually, people like Kumara are helping ICC motives to make sure that their will be less nominations from India team for next awards and that means, more nominations from England and Australia.
BCCI should look into this matter and make sure that this immature guy is terminated from this post otherwise they should boycott srilanka as they did for Pakistan due to political issues.
@sami00 (891)
• India
22 Aug 10
Hello CRAZY,
Yes ,KUMARA DHAMASENA is the STEVE BUCKNOR of Srilanka.What a worst decisions made by him.I think he was supporting the Srilankan team or He is blind.He is one of the worst umpire in the cricket.He doesn't makes some good decisions.I wonder how ICC has made him as a umpire.He don't deserve it.He has given out for Shewag and Raina which was really unfair.He should be banned or fined or whatever he deserves some punishment.I don't know why some of the umpires are against the INDIAN team.
@crazycrazyguy (139)
• India
22 Aug 10
That's right sami. There should be some rules on umpiring like the umpires should be from the countries other than the ones participating in the series.
@baluiyer (1)
• India
21 Mar 11
Absolutely.
He was a mediocre cricketer and even more mediocre unpire.
it is difficult to fathom this guys judgements in declaring out.
Umpitr can not be always right.being human.
But kumara has a great distinction for being more often than not being wrong.
Maybe no umpire can be so stupid.Maybe deliberately he declares a batsmen out .
I do not understand Mr Bishop when he claims Kumara is a great umpire like Buckner.
BUckner was a country speciic umpire.When INdia Plays I dont why he gets it wrong.
@ram_cv (16513)
• India
23 Aug 10
I consider Kumara Dharmasena to be one of the worst of the current set of ICC panel of umpires. Time and again his LBW decisions have been sub standard. He also seems to be too lenient to the bowling sides for most of the stuff.
I think he should be removed from the ICC Panel for a year or so and given time to develop himself and then only he should be re-instated.
Cheers!
Ram
@madhuvamsi (1185)
• India
22 Aug 10
Well BCCI is against referral system, so, all the umpires wanted to show Indian team the advantage of using the 3rd umpire. Whatever, I did not like Dharmasena umpire since he made his debut as umpire, I know that one day he will do these mistakes. It is unfortunate but I do not think technology predicts the bounce that correctly and on field umpire is best judge of the bounce of ball. Yes Dharmasena need to be warned or take some action on him. Apart frm these poor decisions, Indian team batting was poor in my view today. What happened to the other batsmen, are they napping or what.
@dollar3235 (2062)
• India
22 Aug 10
Decisions made by "Kumara Dharmasena" shows the attitude of srilanka cricket, how they think of their opposition and how they are jealous of the other teams and their records.
I feel that kumara has not grown up as an umpire, he still thinks the same way and used to think when he was a bowler of srilanka team, the only difference is that time he used to dream of takin sachin's wicket now he has it in his hand. I am sure, if you appeal on a wide bowl against sachin, kumara will say "Yes".
And you know as an Indian how does it feel, actually what I feel, I or rather I should say, all Indian cricket fans will not be able to express their feelings here.
I have all the "Very" "Good" words ready for him but this is not the right place where I can praise someone with those awesome adjectives!!!