Poor as well as rich men’s food

roti making in indian homes - roti making in an indian home
India
August 30, 2010 6:18am CST
Friends here in my city and throughout India, you can find potato and onion in each and every kitchen, irrespective of status, rich or poor. For middle class people like me, the lunch and dinner may consist of cooked rice, ‘roti ‘(A traditional flat Indian bread, normally cooked on a griddle’), ‘dal’(Indian dish made with stewed legumes (esp. lentils), onion and spices ; a curry with gravy, and may be salad. The curry may be non-veg like meat, fish, egg, chicken or purely veggie, I mean seasonal vegetables and greens. Very few can afford non-veg daily. For lower middle class and poor, potato and onion is a must as curry, or fried. I have seen people eating rice, roti with onion and green chilli only. These potato and onion are available in shops, malls; vegetable market everywhere, the present cost is just ten rupees for one kilogram. It is cheaper, because cost of meat (usually goat meat ) is 275 per kilogram, dressed chicken meat 150 per kilogram, fish 150 per kilogram, an egg costs 3 rupees. Vegetables cost 40 to 50 rupees per kilogram, green leafs 25 rupees per kilogram. You may wonder, why I am telling all these. Last night I was chatting to a friend in Davao, Philippines, where I was for some time. I told about potato, as poor’s mans food. She said, no Professor, here it is rich man’s food. The cost is almost 60% of that of meat which is 175-200 peso per kilogram; this means potato costs around 100 pesos a kilogram, almost 100 rupees a kilogram, ten times our price. Fish was said to be the cheapest, about 80 to 100 pesos per kilogram. What about your place? Is onion, potato common men’s food? If not what it is the common food and what is its cost? Professor
2 people like this
15 responses
@dawnald (85146)
• Shingle Springs, California
31 Aug 10
Onion and potato is very common here for rich and poor both. But what is very common for poor people, less so for rich, is fast food and processed food. Not so much fresh food...
1 person likes this
• India
1 Sep 10
Hello is not fast food costlier? I wonder.. Thanks for response. Welcome always. Cheers. Professor
@agv0419 (3022)
• Philippines
31 Aug 10
The poor's man food here in the Philippines is noodles cost around 6-7 pesos. The price of food now a days is not stable that's why many poor people can't afford to buy meat or vegetables.
1 person likes this
• India
31 Aug 10
Thanks for response. Welcome always. Cheers. Professor
@salonga (27775)
• Philippines
31 Aug 10
Poor or rich people alike eat rice as staple food here in our country. The difference lies on the kind of rice they buy. While the rich can buy the fragrant and high-grade rice, the poor just content themselves with the NFA rice which is not really bad but cheaper and does not taste as good as the high grade rice that only rich people can afford. Also while the poor can only afford dried fish or sometimes just plain salt to add taste to their rice, the rich feast on various dishes depending on their choice.
1 person likes this
• India
31 Aug 10
Hello salonga You are right friend, by the way, may i know, what is NFA rice? Thanks for sharing your views. Welcome always. Cheers. Professor
@kreasa03 (54)
• Philippines
31 Aug 10
The price varies according to season,if the harvest is abundant the price is affordable nevertheless, i think tomato is the cheapest among all its a common food that both rich and poor enjoy
1 person likes this
• India
31 Aug 10
Welcome to mylot Here tomato is cheapest in winter, say december , it may drop to five rupees a kg, but now it is around 25.. Thanks for sharing. Welcome always. Cheers. Professor
@priyayogi (222)
• India
31 Aug 10
hi friends,poor people food is differ from rich people food because the rich people having a so mor money to get them.poor peoople get money low.so the food id differ both the sides.but the poor people take halthy food in nature.the rich people take their junk foods mor.but little amount they get halyhy food like vegetables,fruits and many things.the poor people get only healthy food like vegetables,and bellary more and more and then they work more difficulty works they have done in their namture.
1 person likes this
• India
31 Aug 10
More money, costly food they enjoy. Thanks . Welcome always. Cheers. Professor
@qsccsq (32)
• China
31 Aug 10
hi,professor,in my area,the onion and potato is the major food of our diet ,but the price of the onion is very expensive at this time ,it almost exceed the meat .because of the disaster season.what a bad season!
1 person likes this
• India
31 Aug 10
Welcome to mylot Yes i agree a chinese friend told me this.. Thanks for sharing. Welcome always. Cheers. Professor
@GardenGerty (160952)
• United States
30 Aug 10
Potatoes and onions can be very reasonably priced. Of the things you mentioned, dried legumes would probably be the cheapest. Eggs are very reasonable for the amount of nutrition in them. We often lament that vegetables are pretty expensive when they are fresh.
1 person likes this
• India
31 Aug 10
Thanks for sharing about your place. Welcome always. Cheers. Professor
@kalav56 (11464)
• India
30 Aug 10
Hullo Professor! As you know I am an Indian and all the prices that you have mentioned are valid here in my case too though potato is not that cheap in my place.It is more than 10 rupees and it ranges between 12 and 16. Potato and onion are two things thAt woud always be foud in a kitchen for the one simple reason that they can be kept for more than 4 days. Other fresh vegetables would get spoilt faster than these two. Have a nice evening!
1 person likes this
• India
30 Aug 10
Hi kalav you are right the price variation is slight only.. Thanks for sharing your opinion. Welcome always. Cheers. Professor
@jwfarrimond (4473)
30 Aug 10
Hi Professor Well, I'm English, so Potatos and onions are staples of out diet. Just checking the exchange rate, (£1 = 72 Rupees) to get an idea of comparitive values, it seems that your veg are much cheaper than ours. Especially the potatos. which is surprising considering we grow thousands of tons of them every year.
1 person likes this
• India
31 Aug 10
Yes potato is cheapest.. Thanks for the response. Welcome always. Cheers. Professor
• Philippines
30 Aug 10
It is true that in the Philippines, the prices of onions and potatoes are really much more expensive compared to the Indian Market, why? it's because of the production, our country is always visited by typhoons so the costs of veggies are always increasing. I was really happy to see the prices of commodities when I stayed in India, particularly in Mumbai and Goa to where we live. It was three years ago when I used to remember one kilo of chicken costs only Rs 60 in Goa, and for P120 pesos i could already buy 2 kilos of chicken. I also commend on the prices of beef and mutton which is also cheaper. But now, they did increased the price, well that is reasonable because of the global crisis and such. India is a big country and most states produces fruits and veggies, unlike in our country Philippines, most of the production of veggies comes from the North, particularly in Baguio City. But with regards to the prices of fish, it depends on what kind of fish, but till now, most fishes in Mumbai cost about Rs400 plus above which is way far expensive than the prices of fishes in Philippines, of course, as I have said, it depends on the type of fish. In India they sell baby sharks while in Philippines, we don't eat sharks. In India, you can see most foods fresh, meaning they don't put much in cans. In the Philippines, most sardines and mackerels you can also buy in canned goods. Canned goods in India are very costly,a can of sardine (imported only) is costing Rs 65, wherein my country Philippines, one can of ordinary sardine would cost around Rs 11 to Rs15. We do have stocks of canned goods for emergency usage and easy preparations for home makers who don't have much time to cook, but just open a can, and presto.. lunch or dinner is served.
1 person likes this
• India
30 Aug 10
Hello because you have lived at both places you know things better. Thanks for sharing in details. I don't like canned foods. Welcome always. Cheers. Professor
@tigeraunt (6326)
• Philippines
30 Aug 10
hi professor, potato not being our staple food gets a very high price in this country. but other vegies especially the leafy ones are much more affordable. it is true that families usually stock up canned goods like mackerel and sardines. it is a lot cheaper than buying fresh meat but of course,we do want meat once in a while, don't we? i substitute meat sometimes with beans for protein purposes. so you said it correctly, it is poor as well as rich men's food, depending on the location. have a very nice day. ann
1 person likes this
• India
30 Aug 10
Hi Anny dear I don't like canned goods at all, i buy fresh always, almost daily.. Thanks for sharing situation at your place. Welcome always. Cheers. Professor
@jaiho2009 (39141)
• Philippines
30 Aug 10
hello Prof, I lived in a place called "The Salad Bowl of the Philippines" or the "Summer Capital" it is Baguio City. The vegetables such as potatoes are not too high,it costs 20-25 per kilo,but once it is sold or been into barter change to Manila,then the price gets higher. So,i guess it depends on each place. Like the fish in Manila maybe costs around 80-150 or even as high as 300 esp with special variety of fish. But in Cebu, or fish producing places,the fish is much cheaper,but in Baguio City fish costs too much. Same thing with onions and garlic where in,in the northern part of Luzon called La Union onions and garlic were very cheap compared to Manila. I can say that,prices changes as where the product came from. Have a good weekdays dear bhai
1 person likes this
• India
30 Aug 10
Yes sister price of commodity depends upon several factors no doubt, transportation cost is one of them.. Thanks for the detailed response. Welcome always. Cheers. Professor
@chayapathys (2111)
• India
30 Aug 10
Food is the source of energy for living.About food there is so much to discuss. Rich food poor food. The important aspect is whether one can sustain on what type of food. Again there is vegetarian food and non vegetarian food like meat fish etc.The energy value of food also varies.Of late the theory is that vegetarian is the best suited for human beings.It is also comparatively cheap.There is another angle that is regularity in taking food.What is cheap in one place may be expensive in another place depending upon the availability. The common ingredient in all foods is onions the price of which has considerably affected the political fate of parties in the last before election. so....
1 person likes this
• India
30 Aug 10
Hello chaya welcome to mylot Thanks for sharing your views. Welcome always. Cheers. Professor
• India
30 Aug 10
i think vada paav is the most common food in western parts in india like in mumbai and maharashtra...!!if you go to south you ll find idli and dosa is the common food,and if you go to north you ll find bhalla and chat is the common food..!! so india is full of differences in the common food..!! enjoy all these foods and be happy...!!:)
1 person likes this
• India
31 Aug 10
Yes we have so many kinds of foods, dresses, but still we are one nation.. Thanks for sharing. Welcome always. Cheers. Professor
@dorannmwin (36392)
• United States
2 Sep 10
I would say that here potatoes and onions are things that you will find in most every kitchen. They really are inexpensive and something that everyone can afford. Initially I wasn't able to think of something that I would consider to be just a poor man's food, but then I thought a little bit more about it and I realize that probably bean soup is something that most rich people won't eat (or will very rarely eat) while a rich person is more likely to enjoy steak dinners on a regular basis. As for my family, we are middle class and we determine what we eat based on our income at the given time. There are times that we will have steak for dinner, but it is just as frequently that we will enjoy a meal of soup beans and corn bread for dinner.