Could you forgive?

United States
September 3, 2010 9:37pm CST
Let's say that your only daughter was murdered days before her high school graduation by another teen girl over some boy. Now the girl who killed your girl is on trial and publicly apologizes to you and your family. Could you forgive her? I ask this because I was listening to the news and heard an update of a trial where this actually occurred. A young woman is on trial and sentenced for the murder of another girl over some boy who I'm sure has moved on to his next conquest. I discussed this case in an earlier discussion, but today I saw a clip of what occurred in court and the defendant turned to the victim's parents and apologized to them during her plea to the court. I know it must be so hard for them to have to look at the girl who stabbed and killed their child. I know they say its best to forgive, but I wonder if I could if I was in their position. Could I at that moment? Could I later on? Or could I ever?
7 people like this
22 responses
@Absinto (2385)
• Portugal
4 Sep 10
THat must of been horiible for the parents. Not only having their daughter killed but having to go to court and listen to the person that killed her apologize. I would never forgive them. Most things in the world are forgivable but murder over a boy is definitly a NO.
1 person likes this
• United States
4 Sep 10
Thank you for your honesty. I have to admit to me the fact that this all happened for some boy is like adding insult to injury.
• Philippines
4 Sep 10
Forgiving is not the art of forgetting the pain, rather, it is the willingness to be hurt once again. hello vjenkins86! it must have been a very difficult ordeal for the parents at that moment, looking at the girl who took away their only daughter pleading for their forgiveness. But how could they? at that moment? it was a very unimaginable pain for the parents. and no matter how good the parents must be, they might find it in their heart to forgive, but not at that moment, not the next months or years, but in the long future. i would forgive her, in time, if i were in their shoes. But not this time, i could not find it in my heart to just accept her forgiveness for taking away someone i dearly love. maybe when the scars would fade a little, after some time, maybe i would find the courage to be able to look or think about that girl, without hatred and with forgiveness in my heart. maybe then, i would forgive her.
1 person likes this
• United States
4 Sep 10
I think you're right. No matter how good you are, it would be beyond difficult to forgive in that moment.
@laydee (12798)
• Philippines
4 Sep 10
That is a horrific situation to be in. I don't think someone could forgive that fast most especially that we're talking about someone getting killed over something very petty. If I were the family, I don't think I could just brush off the situation that fast, I am only human and I'm pretty sure that I'd be leaning over 'revenge' for a year or two. I guess time could only heal a broken heart.
1 person likes this
• United States
4 Sep 10
That is very true because it is your heart that has been broken and for a very petty reason as you said.
@sender621 (14893)
• United States
4 Sep 10
Such a situation would be heartbreaking to go through. I can't imagine the thought of loosing a child so tragically. As a christian, i know in my heart i should forgive this girl. if God can forgive her of this sin, I should too. I just don't know that i could give my forgiveness to someone for taking away the life of my child. It would be a terrible burden to bear.
1 person likes this
• United States
4 Sep 10
I understand that because I was wrestling with that idea myself when posting this question. I've been taught that I should forgive others, as God forgives us for all of our sins, but could I really do it in this situation? I don't know and hopefully we'll never find out.
@jennbart (1330)
• Philippines
4 Sep 10
Its hard to say yes. Maybe it will take years. I do not know. Maybe not at all. But if that happend to me, I will not rush into forgiving. Only time will really tell.
1 person likes this
• United States
4 Sep 10
Very true. only time will tell.
• China
4 Sep 10
Every body should be responsible for what he or she did. This is not noly for the justice of the society, but also for the victims. Apology is so slight that cannot fill the vacancy of the parents' feelings. It takes such a long time and a punishment to the criminal to cure the wound. Perhaps after that, we can consider whether we will show the forgiveness to the criminal who really hurt you.
1 person likes this
• United States
4 Sep 10
Responsibility is key and I guess I kind of wonder if the girl does truly understand what her actions have done not only to her but to the family. I mean, this is the same girl who held up the court proceedings at the beginning because she wanted to do her makeup. I only hope her apology wasn't lip service. I do hope she is sincere and after she's done her time in jail, she understands completely what she had done.
• Romania
12 Sep 10
I can't give a clear answer to this, because it depends on that person. If she's really sincere, probably I would forgive her.
@ruperto (1552)
• Philippines
4 Sep 10
It seems in the final analysis, forgiveness is the only acceptable option. To stay bitter and angry and resentful only kills one's self slowly (but surely). Perhaps the important thing to internalize is that we best hold on to what no one can take from us - perhaps that is the connection to the Invisible, Intelligent and All-powerful Energy - God, if you will." What do you think?
• United States
4 Sep 10
I think you're right. Being bitter and angry really hurts you the most. This would be the time to hold on to your faith and believe you can get through this.
@bloemart (222)
• Philippines
4 Sep 10
I think i can't forgive them. But I must. If I don't do that I would be forever bitter and won't move on. I only need the proper justice for my daughter. I only pray God to my early recovery of my grief. I know it is really hard to forgive but I think this is the only way to be peaceful. However, don't ask me for forgiveness at once. Please give me time. Anyway, healing wounds come at the right time.
• United States
4 Sep 10
Yeah, I agree with you. I think forgiving the person is best for yourself and it cannot be rushed.
@deve_annrn (1856)
• Philippines
4 Sep 10
It must have been a horrible experience for the parents.., every time they look at the teenage murderer's face.., asking for forgiveness of what she had done to their daughter.., I know it's best to forgive but it's easier said than done when you are in the situation.., I couldn't forgive anyone who took away someone who means a lot to me.., especially if it's a family.., she deserve to be forgiven but she will have to pay for what she had done..in jail..
1 person likes this
• United States
4 Sep 10
You're right. It is easier said than done and it'll probably be easier to forgive eventually once the girl has done her time in jail.
• India
4 Sep 10
I think it is impossible for them to forgive the girl. I don't think anyone could have forgiven the girl but they should forgive the girl at least in the court. The victim's parents should forgive the girl as they know the pain of losing a child. They should accept the plea of the girl and forgive her lately, as she would be really guilty of her sin. I wouldn't have forgiven the girl at the moment but after some time i would have forgiven her. She destroyed my life does not mean we should destroy hers.What do you say?
1 person likes this
@jhyan007 (467)
• Philippines
4 Sep 10
...in cases like this, it is not that easy to forgive or heal the wounds..it takes time..the fact that the suspect said that she is sorry does not change anything..she is still needs to be punished with the mistake she made..
• United States
4 Sep 10
I think many of us agree that it would take time to forgive.
• Philippines
4 Sep 10
I'd be called a hypocrite if i would say i'll forgive that girl. I think her apologies are a little too late since the harm has been done and she can't do anything to bring back the life of that other girl. Maybe in time i could forgive that girl but at the moment? i just couldn't. Who knows, i may pity her and forgive but she left a stain that could never be erased so the treatment would rather be cold, its because i think is never easy to forgive and forget those kind of tragic experiences... Good day!
1 person likes this
• United States
4 Sep 10
Thank you for your honesty. I can understand and agree with you. It's not like she broke your television or wreck your car. This would be very hard to forgive and I hardly think you can ever forget. Good day to you too
• India
4 Sep 10
Yes,I forgive just because not that I am super human being,just because I cant be like killer.
• United States
4 Sep 10
That's a good point because this all started with anger and hate. Don't want the cycle to continue.
@ANTIQUELADY (36440)
• United States
5 Sep 10
NO, i could not forgive anyone that harmed or killed one of my children. I really don't know how i would sit in the courtromm w/them w/out wanting to harm them. I guess will soundreally bad to alot of people but that's just the way i feel.
@Lore2009 (7378)
• United States
5 Sep 10
I doubt I could.. it would take me a looooong time if not forever.
@amybrezik (2118)
• United States
5 Sep 10
It would take a lot of courage to forgive her but I would try. I would still want to see her punnished for what she did, but I wgo outould also hate to have 2 girls lives out the window. It would be hard to forgive for sure, but I would try to.
@nancy0618 (477)
• Philippines
5 Sep 10
i know it is hard to forgive some, specially with this case but i know in time she will be able to forgive that person, we are humans. i know GOD will be able to understand if ever we could not accept what had happened, we may forgive the suspect but one thing for sure we will never forget
@nicole00 (141)
• United States
5 Sep 10
I saw this same thing on he news. This is crazy! You want to cry over your daughter but then again you know that your supposed to forgive. this puts the family in a tight spot. If it was me I would be very very angry I would forgive but God knows I wont forget. But hating the young girl will not bring their daughter back but I know their angry and you cant really blame them.
@xtmlove (402)
• China
5 Sep 10
As a onlooker, I would the family to forgive her. But if this thing happen to my family, it will be hard to say yes. I know it's best to forgive, but it easier to said than done when you are in the situation. I love my family very much, so I don't want to lose anyone of them. It will be a horrible experience in all of life,I don't know it will take how many years that I could recover for it. So I hope this thing don't happen to me forever.