Do you think this judgement is too extreme?

For us, that is harsh since it is not based on our norms. For them, that is already a usual thing. What I wonder is since they already know that law, how come there are still people who won't obey and complain if they are getting punished. If only they had followed the law and did the right thing in the first place, then everybody happy! No punishment!

different country has different laws ,since it can exist ,definitely has its own reason ,for me ,i am from different country ,i can not give you any idea about this issue ,depend on the serious extent ,give the correspond punishment ,i think this maybe the right way

I know most would say it's inhumane, but I am a believer of punishment. I know it seems harsh, but if they get off an act that easily then soon a lot would follow. Just like how movie stars and actresses feel that they can get out of anything. Just a few days in jail or paying some sort of fine just won't cut it anymore. However, I am just appalled by the thought that it's only her who is being punished. I would have gone with their decision if the partner (who is also committing adultery) should be punished and humiliated in the same way. After all, you cannot sin or commit adultery alone.

To those who are not Muslim, yes, it is indeed extreme. This is punishment according to the Islam extremist. In such believe, it is the rule. It is meant to be harsh so that people can be deterred from getting oneself into such act. I think even moderate Muslim will view this as extreme but then again, I am in no position to comment because I am not Muslim. As a human being (a moderate one in thinking), yes, it is indeed extreme. If I were the judge, I will judge whether she perform the act or not. No one is guilty until proven. Then, if she did it, send her for counselling. Follow up with therapy sessions and probations.

wtf? they must put the woman to jail and not torture him.. but we cant do anything because it is their culture.. just pray for the woman..

ya,the judgement is very difficult for our life.because every one should do any illegal activities but they don't know it is correct or not.that is the proble for human life.so every one take care herselt to take over our life.when the judgement is too extreme level theat time everyone don't like it.it shoud not affect the humans.