Language
By 6precious102
@6precious102 (4043)
United States
September 8, 2010 10:06am CST
For those of you who do not believe in God, can you explain to me where language came from? Also, why are there so many different languages? The differences in skin color I can understand, but if we all started the same way in the same area of the world, why are the many languages so different from each other?
2 people like this
11 responses
@dark_joev (3034)
• United States
8 Sep 10
The Bible talks of the tower of bable(sp?) and that is the story way of explaining it the difference of languages.
But in RL the reason for the difference in language has come from 1000's of years of Human evolution not only in our bodies but also in the mind. Also Humans originating from the modern day Middle East it is believed that over many years we as a species moved to the different parts of the world and as we moved farther away from the point of origin we adapted the root language to new forms of language. That had some common sounds or things in common with this root language. That's it in a nutshell.
I don't see why people seem to think that God couldn't be smart enough to create Evolution and the "Big Bang". I mean really if God is really smart it would be easier for him/her to watch and not have to micromanage everything on the planet and well we have already proven evolution. Hence the survivability in Bactria in the form of super bugs. They have done this through changes in there structure at both the DNA and RNA levels
1 person likes this
@dark_joev (3034)
• United States
9 Sep 10
I personally think god (if god exist) was created during the 11th dimension collision that happened several (100+) billion years ago.
I never was able to get a good answer from Christians on how creation made logical since but to be fair to them. I am in the top 1% of Oregon for Science out of High School. I scored as high as some people who are in there 2nd year of College going into there third scored when they set up the test. I have always had a mind that could handle the Scientific method really well.
@6precious102 (4043)
• United States
9 Sep 10
I keep hearing that evolution has been proven, but I have yet to hear anyone explain how it's been proven. Since you are obviously a scholar, can you explain it to me? The super bug is not a sufficient explanation for me. Was there once absolutely nothing, not even darkness, or has there always been something? If there was once nothing, how could anything come into being? If there was something, where did it come from? I believe in God, but I confess I have a hard time getting my head around "eternal." Maybe it's because I live in a 4 dimensional world.
@jupitercrashing (635)
• Canada
8 Sep 10
I don't think anyone argues that god isn't smart enough to do such things, only that evolution and the big bang contradict the creation myths of many religions. I personally don't see why people think a middle man is necessary to explain things like evolution and the big bang. They must consider this: If god created the universe, who created god? Your answer is likely that god 'just is,' has always existed, or somehow managed to create himself. If you can believe this, why can you not believe that the universe 'just is,' has always existed, or managed to create itself?
1 person likes this
@balan385 (7)
• Malaysia
9 Sep 10
hai dear..
i dun no about where language came from..but i knew tamil, english, malay and mandrin languages...i think there many language because the world is bigger and the oldest days, people cant travel so far..so they didn't communicate with other..the people in some area, communicate with their own language that they create...because no communication with out of the world...they just use that language that they know..like this was increase many language in this world..after the world modernize then only people realize of many language..
@6precious102 (4043)
• United States
9 Sep 10
As far as most of us are concerned, language has always been. I suppose that's why the origin of language is a subject few have thought about.
@balan385 (7)
• Malaysia
10 Sep 10
The language is related to the community...if the community is large then the language will be popular in the world...like English is although is famous language but not number one language in the world but its was mandarin..the origin of the language will not keep as old one and will be modify little bit as grow of world...
@Galena (9110)
•
9 Sep 10
well it's easy enough to see.
innumerable animals have vocal communication. which probably started out as a simple way of spreading signals that there is danger, or to attract mates.
and gradually, vocalisation has become more complex to pass on more complex messages.
I expect you'd be quite surprised if you listened in on rats talking to each other at ultrasonic pitches.
I know I was. since I got my bat detector I spend a lot of time listening to the rats, and it's amazing how you get to know what different sounds they make mean. and there's a lot of different sounds with different meanings.
this is how language developed.
@6precious102 (4043)
• United States
9 Sep 10
I'm not trying to say that language proves any particular religion. I trying to find out from nonbelievers how they thing language came into being. Giving evolution as the answer to questions like this seems like a cop out to me. It doesn't really answer the question, particularly since language isn't something tangible.
@Pose123 (21635)
• Canada
9 Sep 10
Hi 6precious,I don't think that languages have anything to do with believing in God. Languages change over time, we would not be able to read or speak the English of 8 or 9 hundred years ago. Whether a person believes in God or not, he/she should know how things work in the world. We discover what's already here. Electricity was here before we found a way to use it. The telephone could have been invented a thousand years earlier if someone had been smart enough. The same is true for the computer etc. It is the same with languages. Blessings.
@Pose123 (21635)
• Canada
9 Sep 10
Hi 6precious, I think the problem here is that we understand so little about the origin of all things. I'm not denying the existence of God but I'm saying that in our present form and with our limited knowledge we can't understand these mysteries. I agree that language as well as the others I've mentioned was always here, but we had to come to learn how to put it into use. Remember God didn't one day make a cell phone and toss it to the earth, someone had to come up with the idea and develop it. The same goes for language but further than that we are not able to understand or explain. Blessings.
@6precious102 (4043)
• United States
9 Sep 10
But didn't all of those things already in the world, things that we take for granted, have a beginning? I really don't think the origin of language can be pin pointed. As far as we're concerned, it's always been.
@alilin28 (1527)
• Uruguay
28 Dec 10
hi 6precious102, how are you?
beein honest, i believe in God, and i know the biblic story about the languages, but i have never stopped and though from a rational explanation about this. Its to difficult to explain. good discussion and good point!
have a nice day!
@6precious102 (4043)
• United States
29 Dec 10
I'm doing well, alilin. How are you? I know the Bible story, also; but I've often wondered how language, or speech, got started. It doesn't seem like something that would evolve from nothing to a gradual forming of words. I think of language or speech as something that has been in existence as long as man has been.
@TheMetallion (1834)
• United States
8 Sep 10
Languages develop over time, which is why speaking English doesn't mean you'll understand Old English. Once people started migrating, different groups of people developed languages differently. We recreate a similar process in a kindergarten game called "telephone"
@6precious102 (4043)
• United States
9 Sep 10
I understand that language changes as time goes by. The "World Book Encyclopedia Year Book" use to have a Dictionary Supplement for new words or phrases each year. What I'm curious about is the origin of language or the spoken word. Did it evolve as some believe humans evolved? If man's beginning was in one part of the world, did language also begin in that one part of the world or did humans migrate and then begin their particular language?
I'm not sure these are questions that can ever be answered from a human perspective. I know humans can be clever and I realize language is a necessity, but it's difficult for me to believe that we're that smart on our own. Since I believe in God, I also believe that language came from God and has always been.
@TheMetallion (1834)
• United States
9 Sep 10
Whether language was invented once or multiple independent times, I don't know, but neither would surprise me. We evolved with rather flexible vocal capabilities, and it takes little effort to see that being able to coordinate efforts between individuals increases the likelyhood that those individuals will survive to procreate. From an evolutionary perspective, there's no reason not to believe we're that smart on our own.
@rogue13xmen13 (14402)
• United States
9 Sep 10
We all speak different languages because we scattered to different parts of the Earth and language evolved as people evolved in different ways.
@6precious102 (4043)
• United States
9 Sep 10
So, is language just part of the evolutionary development? Did language come into being because it was necessary for survival? I wonder how our evolving bodies knew we'd need the things that help us survive.
@Margajoe (4747)
• Germany
9 Sep 10
You see that in Europe more than in America and Canada.
Holland for example is a very small country. In Rotterdam they speak slightly different than in Den Haag. The same with Amsterdam, they also have there own tong fall. When you go outside of the cities, into the towns, you would not be able to understand these dutch people. They have a dialect , not even the dutch understand each other.
What I am trying to get at here, is that languages are never totally the same. Even in the same country. As time goes by the language use changes too.
Threw the years this has happened as well. Then later on there were more and more different dialects. They became new languages. It is that simple.
In the Caribbean, there are three islands not to far apart.
There is a bird that lives on all of these islands. But on each island there is a different tree, with different fruits. The same bird, on each island they have a different beak. On one island it is rounded, on the other it is small,and on the other it is long. Same bird, different beaks. Sorry I don't remember the names.
But, you see everything does have a logical explanation.
@6precious102 (4043)
• United States
9 Sep 10
I understand what you mean about not being able to understand people in your own area. That's true where I live. There are some whose pronunciation of particular words is so different than mine that I have to ask them to spell the word so I'll know what they're saying.
@Adoniah (7513)
• United States
8 Sep 10
As people migrated to different areas their languages changed. Even English changes. American English is different in many ways from British English and it has not been so many years since we have been British. The same Goes for the Islands in the Caribbean and Canada. It does not take long for people to forget their "roots" and adapt to a new area. If you look at the root forms of Latin, you will see that all of the "Romance Languages" have the same roots. That is why when you learn one, it is easy to learn another.
You do not have to believe in HaShem to understand how languages can change....
Shalom~Adoniah
@madteaparty (2748)
• Japan
9 Sep 10
The different languages were created by the human beings, like the gods and the different religions were created by humans too.
@6precious102 (4043)
• United States
9 Sep 10
Do you really think humans are clever enough to come up with so many words in so many different languages? What caused these brains, which supposedly came from the same source, to come up with so many different languages? I think the origin of language is like trying to prove or disprove the existence of God. It's doubtful we'll ever get 100% agreement.
@soloandi23 (21)
•
8 Sep 10
I believe if God, but I dont believe that God explains the reason for different languages. Humans migrated to different regions, and found different ways of commutication and taught it to their decendants. Just like people of today move to different areas and learn the native language so that they can survive there. There is also no law that says we all started in the same area of the world, not that I am aware of. I see no religious or spiritual base to your question at all. Human intelligence is responsible for the different communication styles.
@6precious102 (4043)
• United States
9 Sep 10
I confess I know little about the evolution of man. We studied neither evolution nor creation in the general science I had in school. So, are you saying that God had no part in either the beginning of language or it's future changes or developments?