Harry Potter or LOTR?

Philippines
September 24, 2010 1:05am CST
I am both a fan of Harry Potter and The Lord of The Ring. When I got hold of these books, i got hooked. Can't put them down - I had to bring the books to my work to read during breaktimes. But, if were to choose one, I would probably choose Harry Potter because it is more humorous.
6 responses
• United States
24 Sep 10
This is SUCH a hard question. I don't even know if I can answer it, to be honest... I mean, I guess if I had to answer it, I would say Harry Potter, only because it was written in my generation, so it's what I grew up with, but LOTR is so good. I haven't read the books, though... and that might make all the difference!
• Philippines
24 Sep 10
I am in the same state as you are. Really hard to choose.
• United States
24 Sep 10
It really is! I think that comparing movies, I would go with LOTR, but comparing books I just can't say because I haven't read the LOTR books.... shame!!!
• Australia
7 Nov 10
I like Harry Potter better than Lord of the Rings because its a lot easier to read. I have a complete 3 in 1 volume of Lord of the Rings but I have never read all of it.I just read the parts I like.Love the parts about the White Lady of Rohan.
@freymind (1351)
• Philippines
24 Sep 10
I don't watch nor read the books of LOTR I don't know why but it doesn't have a pull on me. I love Harry Potter. Its not just making me hook at watching it more and more... I don't have a favorite character in that movie but its just great to watch... I've also read the book and i can say i'm hooked on it as well.
• India
24 Sep 10
I would choose Harry Potter more because ever since i was a kid i watched the movie like a 1000 times and i am still not bored of it now. I would love to watch the movie again and again. I have always been enchanted by the spells, the magic and fun. I still read the books even though i know most of them by heart. Cheers!
• Indonesia
24 Sep 10
I have to say LOTR, because harry potter is to childish, I like heavier stuff, and there is so much more to LOTR, like the Hobbit and Books of the lost tales, both are related to LOTR and also have read both.
10 Oct 10
I choose "The Lord of the Rings" because it is really great book. It is the best book I ever read. And "Harry Potter" is for children.