LeBron the Victim?
By matersfish
@matersfish (6306)
United States
October 1, 2010 1:27pm CST
I'm sure NBA fans are well aware of LeBron James' interview with CNN in which he played the race card, stating that he believes a lot of the backlash--criticism--he's received over his decision to jump ship and head to Miami is tinged with racism.
First off, what a ridiculous question to ask an athlete. Talk about giving them an out! Soledad O'Brien brings up race for every single topic on the planet. There's zero factual basis here. Zero.
But never mind all that. How do white NBA fans feel to know that, if you begrudge a black athlete due to his or her choices, it goes beyond the pale in terms of basic passion for the game and becomes racist?
How does it feel to know you can't come down on LeBron James like you come down on Brett Farve, because you're a racist if you act FANatical about a black athlete?
Is this fair of someone in LeBron's position to do?
I'm writing this while asserting little to no reaction LeBron has received has been based on his skin color.
Why? Well, Babe Ruth wasn't black and, per the era, was under far, far, far more scrutiny than James for his jump from Boston to New York. And this is in an era where racism was running rampant and media was not.
Johnny Damon caught enormous flak for the same move.
Brett Favre, another white athlete, has been habitually torn apart by media for the past four years due to his on-again, off-again love affair with retirement.
Roger Clemens, after the steroid controvery, is baseball's ubervillain keeping Barry Bonds company. Am I racist for saying Bonds did it but just a conclusion-hopper for saying Clemens did it?
Of course, it's absolutely absurb to suggest racism plays a role in any white athlete getting his or her a$$ chewed for a decision. But when a black athlete says it, the entire sports media world--white reporters specifically--put on the kid gloves and bend over backwards to placate sensitivities. While Josh what's-his-face was interviewing Jalen Rose on the subject, the poor guy could barely get a sentence out. I don't know if he was embarrassed or scared, but it was uncomfortable.
Here's the reality, as I see it. Feel free to disagree.
LeBron James was handed the keys to the world while still in high school due to his undeniable talent. He never, ever balked at the idea of being America's basketball sweetheart - the next Michael Jordan. In fact, he embraced it so much that he enjoyed calling himself the "King," enjoyed shooting commercials, signing endorsements, plastering his face on billboards and making more money than 99.9% of all Americans regardless of race.
LeBron James did all this. LeBron. Not some suddenly black guy. "Black" isn't who he is. He's LeBron first - a charismatic basketball player whom America and the rest of the world fell head over heels in love with.
So, when he shows that he's not what everyone thought, and broke Cleveland's heart and made it all about him and his winning legacy in the process, of course people are going to turn on him.
You mean to tell me that, even though he's always been "black," people loved him then but suddenly decided they don't like a black man having "power" now? He's had the power since he was 16.
That's absolutely absurd. Absolutely.
James is trying to find a scapegoat here. And with the racial climate we live in today, simply saying that it's racism will get some people off his back.
LeBron is doing a great disservice to every man, woman and child in the world who's ever faced real racism. By playing the race card so media stops crucifying him for his brat level of selfishness, he's attempting to turn it around on the public at large.
This is horrible for his image, and even more horrible that a nation comprised of 66% whites, many of which promoted James to stardom, is blamed when he can't take the heat for a personal decision.
4 responses
@FRANCISCOANDLEE (750)
• United States
22 Mar 11
Hey look...I can actually agree with you after-all!!
Living in Cleveland my whole life, not far from Akron...and having friends who know LeBron...I can give you at least a little more insight.
When LeBron was a nobody kid in school, people started noticing the talent he has, and the more people said, "..you gotta see this kid!" More and more local people, people from his neighborhood and beyond, supported LeBron and promoted LeBron.
Fans promoted and supported him while he was just a kid from the neighborhood. He didn't acquire the name King by himself.
The more popular he became, and the more celebrity he became, the bigger his ego grew. He started replacing neighborhood and school friends with famous friends. The larger his world became, the smaller his roots.
He eventually became the person he despised...
Cleveland and Akron loved him...LeBron could do no wrong.
Until the ultimate betrayal. If LeBron wanted to leave, fine, that is his choice and his right, but it's the way he did it! "The Decision" was THE ultimate betrayal. He could have been a man about it, he could have been respectful to those who have been by his side before ANYONE else knew who he was.
Then to add insult to injury, he uses the "Race" card! He spits in our face in betrayal, and because he gets booed, he says it's a racial motivational thing?
People would have continued to be a fan of his whether he stayed in Cleveland or not...but his Prime-Time Drama of the ESPN The Decision, and the way he acted afterwards....I hope he falls on his face. Cavs ownership gave him everything, every decision was either accepted or rejected based on LeBron. This city gave him everything.
Personally, I could care less..as I'm not that big of a basketball fan...I only saw LeBron play a few times...so none of this affects me, BUT...I have empathy towards others.
His recent rant, throwing the KARMA card at the Cleveland fans...
LeBron James...King James...perhaps he should have paid more attention in history class...Every Kingdom will fall..as it always has.
@matersfish (6306)
• United States
22 Mar 11
I wrote this months ago, and what I predicted would happen has happened. Media has toned down their criticisms of James.
They're no longer speaking so negatively about his primetime faux Presidential ESPN spot; now they're sticking with on-the-court critiques.
One might say that's the natural evolution of it all and James' pulling the card out has nothing to do with it. But not all popular athletes have the dogs called off so quickly. Tiger is still dealing with it on a larger scale.
Cleveland will probably be hard pressed to take any revenge there. He crippled that team. I'm glad to see the fans are still loyal, but they simply aren't talented enough to compete in the East. But their time will certainly come. James has it coming.
@FRANCISCOANDLEE (750)
• United States
22 Mar 11
Hi matersfish...
This season was just so many things rolled into one big losing season.
I think the shock of LeBron leaving in the fashion that he did, may have contributed somewhat to the season..one man doesn't make a team, but I still think it may have been shock. Then you throw into this season a new GM, a new head coach, and about 6 or 7 new guys on the roster...it was all the ingredients for a chaotic season.
I believe Dan Gilbert won't let this go on past this season..Gilbert took a media beating after The Decision...he will right the ship. At least he knows just what he has and what he needs to do.
And you're right, matersfish...James has it coming.
@dragon54u (31634)
• United States
2 Oct 10
Ridiculous. Reporters should quit giving people the option of blaming racists, unless that's the subject of the report.
James made a business decision, pure and simple. He did what was best for him. If the fans are upset, they should shut up and accept that they can't run his life. Sports fans tend to blow everything out of proportion because of their unbridled enthusiasm and obsession with whatever game they love.
But, as a good businessman, I wouldn't James to stoop so low as to accuse fans of racism. All 3 sides at fault here--obsessive fans, player and sensationalist reporter.
@matersfish (6306)
• United States
2 Oct 10
It is ridiculous. A reporter's job isn't to give people an out.
If they're looking for real "news," then you ask him: "Why do you think people are criticising you more than other free agents?" And you let the guy answer what he's going to answer.
Don't bait them. Don't give them an out. That's something I would do. And that's why I don't work for CNN.
And I do agree that sports fans blow things way out of proportion. And they do so for every popular athlete.
I think some people in America need to face the fact that Tiger Woods wasn't bashed because he's "black." He was bashed because he turned out to be a habitual cheater, going against his image.
LeBron isn't criticized because he's "black."
Michael Phelps was criticized because he was white and not because he was smoking pot? A reporter would be laughed off the air for asking--asserting, more like it--that was the case.
And maybe it's wrong for the public to care so much about the private lives and business decisions of athletes, but "race" rarely, rarely comes into play in American sports these days. If reporters want racism, just see how black soccer players are treated in Europe.
@gewcew23 (8007)
• United States
2 Oct 10
If LeBron had just left Cleveland and went to Miami like most free agents do then I doubt that the outrage would be as ramped as it has become. In the NBA player move around just look at Shaq for instance. Instead of just signing a a contract with a new employer and having a basic press conference he has a hour long prime time show on ESPN where he made the famous line, "I will be taking my talents to South Beach." Does he not think that every minute of that show after he made that comment just racketed up the angry towards him? Oh and let us not even get started on that WWE entrance when Wade, Bosh, and James came up through the stage as if they were preparing to defend their tag team championship belts.
@matersfish (6306)
• United States
2 Oct 10
I think that's exactly right. If he decided to leave, was above board with his teammates about it not working, and didn't make it all about him, then it would have went over just like any other free agent. Well, maybe not exactly - but nothing like the fallout we're seeing today.
I also agree that his primetime me-me-me special and his hubris in the "my talents" line and the Miami Thrice squad showboating around does nothing but create anger.
The way I see it, if people were mad at LeBron because he's "black," then he never would have made it to fame in the first place.
I think Mr. James' head is too big for a man of his age.
No, LeBron. It's not because you're "black" that people are giving you a hard time. It's because you're YOU!
@matersfish (6306)
• United States
2 Oct 10
A lot of things in America are racially driven or, at least, have racial components. And maybe the 1970s NBA was like that, but today's NBA has an overwhelming majority of African-American players who make great money and meet great fame to simply play a sport.
Do any of us every hear any stories about these players having to suffer from racial discrimination? Maybe 1 fan out of 1 million decides to get drunk and throw a racial slur or something, but that's far from "racism" playing a role in the league.
CNN is always there to exploit the situation. And, more insulting, they approach LeBron James as the "black athlete" instead of simply an athlete. Someone needs to check CNN for racism, in my opinion.