ur brother ask u to have a baby for him and his wife bcs they cant. would u?^^

You should really make this discussion about if "a friend had asked you to carry their baby in your belly" or something. Cause, that's just plan wrong to have a sibling's genes mixed with your genepool, it can actually create huge problems for the baby. If you are talking about the scientific version, I do not feel it is right to ask your own sibling for that. It's wrong, just plain out wrong to have a sibling carry a sibling's baby. Instead, I would tell them to adopt a child because there are so many children in this world that need a home. They need love too, and maybe those who cannot have children of their own, should adopt an orphan.

For me I Don't because the baby would get mad in you they want to have the original mother and father.

i would have to say yes as i have been in a similar situation but the situation was in reverse, i was the one wanting the baby (but everything ended up working out and we didnt need anyone helping us) but if i was asked to help someone out and i could, i would as i know what it feels like to be on the end of asking someone such a life changing decisions.

I wonder what's your point of starting such a kind of topic. Don't you think it ridiculous? Can a brother seriously asks his sister to have a baby for him? However illiterate a person is, he/she can't be so ignorant of the consequence of incest. You said you would do it for your sisters if they asked you, but have you ever considered about the result? What will you do if you give birth to a deformed baby only because you and your sister have similar genes?

I would never allow my wife to do this, and I think it would be pretty selfish of her family members to ask her to do this for them. That is like trying to get someone else to buy the car for you so you won't have to go through the hassle of getting the loan in your name. All the risk would be on my wife, not to mention we would have to go through a pregnancy for a kid that wasn't even ours. Also, using her brother's sperm to impregnate her would be the same as her getting pregnant through incest, which could cause some serious health problems for the baby, so it probably wouldn't be advised by medical staff anyway. However, even if she got the sperm from another donor, I still would not allow it...

I don't think I will go for that. It is against nature and I do not want any complications in the future. The baby will still be my baby even if I was only used as a surrogate mother. No, I don't think I will do it.

Hi, In this kind of situation, I must have everyone agreement to do it before making the full commitment. It is about a life of someone and everyone must really agree to it,then I can go ahead and do it. In the first place, to get myself pregnant,it means I need a help from my partner and I have to get an agreement from my partner to do so. It is not a small issue and of course, if everyone has agreed to it, for sure I will help up since I am able to get pregnant.

Hello Sweet, I am a guy and if such situations happened and my brother asked me to do such. am afraid i may have to be honest, YEAH, I'll do it alright. but Artificial Insemination is way too expensive for us. so, i think am gonna do RAW(if you get what am thinking) otherwise, they should go find some one else to seed "sister in law" Sure a lot of people here being hypocrite, thinking it's immoral here and there. give me a BREAK! this is a situation where not only they need kids, but the family line needs to be continue. the only immoral thing is if the Sister asked his younger brother to impregnate her in secret. so that she and her hubby can have a baby. pure and simple.

Bringing a child into this world is a miracle of life. if i could something to make my sibling's life more beautiful, than I would. It might seem strange and awkward to have a child for someone else, but I would definitely be up for the challenge.

if i was a girl and i was asked to conceive for my brother and sister i would definately do it. There is nothing more than sharing love with your brother or sister. But definately it will be a mutual understanding with me and my husband.

I'll bring up Phoebe from sitcom friends, just remind me about that, I love that series. I don't think I would. It's such a big thing and if he couldn't have I am pro of adoption. Even those who can have kids should adopt I think. I know I won't have kids because they are all souls and there are so many orfans around the World that when my time comes or $$$ I surely find my kid. Maybe two, but hopefuly 3 kids. :D

well adopting is really good if you can't born a child you can adopt one ya if my brother would have asked me I would have give him even in my family my there are four brothers including my father so only my mom can born a child so there were three brother one we gave it to my uncle...

A little bit confuse about your topic - is this like for example me I have brother's wife to something with the consent of my brother in the purpose of children. This kind of situation unable to do because for me it is un-decent action for both.