Major 4th amendment issues in Pensilvania.

Tweet

I don't often start threads these days. But every so often, something comes up I feel is worthy and important enough to write about. This is one of those issues. First, the back story. A woman in Pennsylvania gives birth to a child in a hospital. With in a few days, she is visited by a social worker with a court order to remove the child. Apparently, state law in Pennsylvania state law now requires drug testing on new mothers in hospitals. The test had reportedly come back positive for opiates. It seems though that the woman has claimed the only source for the substance could be a bagel she ate the day prior, a bagel with everything including poppy seeds. Since 1998, it has been solid medical community consensus that poppy seeds, even in amounts as small as half a gram or less in some cases, can produce a positive result for opiates in a drug screening. The woman has had her child returned to her after this had been cleared up and she now plans on suing the state over this matter. But I want to address some much deeper issues that did not go away with the return of the child. First, it is one thing for an employer to require drug screening. I still think it is a privacy issue but it is still a bit of a gray area for the law. However, to mandate drug testing on new mothers goes so far beyond that gray area that there can be no question. The state has no probable cause and no warrants have been issued. The 4th amendment clearly states "The right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures, shall not be violated, and no Warrants shall issue, but upon probable cause, supported by Oath or affirmation, and particularly describing the place to be searched, and the persons or things to be seized." You cannot tell me that after every birth in that state, that hospitals are going to a judge and obtaining a warrant for such a "search". or that judges are handing them out arbitrarily like Halloween candy. And then there is the final and most glaring issue of all. the simple fact that this is probably one of the biggest examples of a police state mentality I have come across in a long time. Pennsylvania, I don't often interfere in the affairs of individual state law, but I am making an exception in this case. I would suggest unless you want more tyrannical laws such as this passed, I suggest you begin barbecuing your state legislators and governor until they bring an end to this practice. If this is allowed to stand unchallenged, who knows what nightmarish legislation could be next.