Do you think Tobey Maguire fails to keep the aura of spiderman?

The third movie was junk! Don't you read the comic books? Whoever wrote the third movie didn't seem to care anymore. It was as bad as watching "Star Wars Episode 3: Return of the Sith". Compared to the first two films, it did not compare. Tobey Maguire, to me, and to a great majority of people, was the perfect Peter Parker and we can't really see anyone else playing that role. It's like J. Jonah Jameson, the E.I.C. of the "Daily Bugle". J.K. Simmons did such great job playing that character, and he was so perfect for that character that no one can see anyone else playing that character. Again, you all need to read the comics.

Hi rogue13xmen13 Opinions vary and I accept your point - of late I am not reading the comics... I cannot afford them as they are beyond my reach - maybe I would buy those when I have my own kid and then... I can reply to this one better. I was speaking my view without the Comics things. The story in the second just didnt look amazing to me... However the Negative shade for Spidey did make an appeal to me. Cheers, theSids.

Hi guys!! I think u failed to get the question. I am not taking about the storyline, I am talking about how the character was played. Look, though u may not agree (every people have right to have different opinions) there are some movies which bcome a blockbuster but the actors/actresses fails to b as good as the story, picturization, background score, costume and various other stuffs connected with the film. So, they get framed as "one movie miracle". There are some movies which gets FLOP but we like some characters and the persons who play the character. We hear reviews that "character was weak, there was not much scope but the actor did brilliant, no one cud have pulled the role like him". So, a role or a movie will get box-office hit or not doesn't depend only upon the storyline. I have a huge collection of Phantom series by Lee Falk. I am a die-hard fan of him. But when I watched the movie I think (solely my opinion) actor billy zane failed to portray the character. Mr. walker's strength, his emotions towards Diana feelings for the jungle... Bottomline is I just don't like Mr. Maguire for the spiderman role. I have watched some of his other movies and I appreciate those characters. I think every one has his/her own opinion. that's why someone like Tom Cruise and some go for Brad Pitt. Does, it mean those people who like Tom is not smart enough or does that make Tom silly? No way!! Its just how u perceive things in life. To Sid - Sony Pictures Selects New 'Spider-Man'; He's 26-Yr-Old British Actor Andrew Garfield. :-) To rogue13xmen13 - Srry 4 d speling mistak. I juz hav a weird way of writin. I lik d short-cut 1s. U knw dat nw; I gss OR may b I din knw dat its "spider-man" n not "spiderman". Thnkz anyways :-) Kip commenting guys!! Regards Paul