Assistance from Strangers, or the Bystander Effect
By Qaeyious
@Qaeyious (2357)
United States
November 15, 2010 11:47pm CST
A personal experience today led me to YouTube that eventually led me to the "Bystander Effect.". Statistics show that if you get in trouble by yourself in public, no one will help you if you get in trouble, either by criminal action or medical emergency. And especially if there aree many people around.
Go figure.
What betters your chances? Being in the same social strata as most people in the area, having a nominal relationship with others in the area (like if you lie down on a blanket on a beach; make small talk with your neighbors and they will more likely report any theft of your items if you walk someplace else) and shockingly being a child was not one of them.
Now for my personal experiences, one that happened today, about four hours before I was inspired to write this.
Fights I won't involve myself in until it is over. If the victim needs medical assistance afterword, fine, but I don't have the power to stop fights. Most likely if I try to stop a fight I will be a victim as well, and that does no one any good.
Besides, statistically, no one would help me anyway.
So today I was sitting on a bench at the bus stop, by a shopping area that was on raised ground, so that there was a meter high wall. Suddenly something flew over our heads, and there was a form in the bus pull in area.
It was a boy who couldn't have been over thirteen, my first instinct was to look in the parking area to see if he was attacked or shoved, but I was not able to determine that. A man on the other bench asked him if he was all right, and the boy was starting to attempt to stand. He was able, but his movements were unsteady, so I got up and helped him to the bench I was on.
The thing is it wasn't until a minute or two after the actual incident before I determined what needed to be done. I still wonder if I should have done more, asking the boy if he needed help going home, or telling him to put ice on whatever starts swelling. But our ways have parted already. I could only hope for the best.
So have you ever helped a stranger in need? Have you ever passed one by (which is the greater statiscal possibility.)
3 responses
@frontvisions101 (16043)
• Philippines
16 Nov 10
I was stabbed in public before with a broad sword and a samurai. Literally. No one helped me. I had a broad sword stabbed on my chest and a samurai on my back. No one even looked my way.
@NoWayRo (1061)
• Romania
16 Nov 10
There are various factors in determining whether or not I help a complete stranger, and the first is my personal safety. I'm sorry to say, but if I feel threatened in any way, I just walk away without a second thought.
Just a couple of days ago I saw a woman being beaten in the street by two guys. I stopped and took my cell phone out to call the police, when I realized the woman wasn't crying for help. She was protesting with a soft voice, but not screaming or asking the passers by to intervene, so I decided it was none of my business and kept going.
@natnickeep (2336)
• United States
16 Nov 10
I have saw something similar to this with the show "What would you do". It is a hard fact to face, most people say they would step in, but when the situation happens they are very unsure of what to do. I want to say I would try to stop it, but if my kids were with me I would just call the police. If it was a medical emergency I would help for sure. At least I think so. Psychology is a tricky thing.
@Qaeyious (2357)
• United States
16 Nov 10
That it is. I am glad I verified with myself I will eventually help, even if it takes a while.
Come to think of it, one of the experiments on YouTube showed a person standing around, watching the other people go by, while an actress played unconscious. She finally started helping after another person started to help. Perhaps if you made it known to the other bystanders you are doing something that more will follow.