Mr. McBean... You Are Not The Father!!!
By tjades
@tjades (3591)
Jamaica
November 16, 2010 9:01pm CST
It seems that the passing off of an illegitimate child to the wrong man is an increasing practice among the females. At least that is how some men seem to see it. I am curious though. There are a few questions to which I seek some mylot answers.
Is this practice really on the increase?
Do you think that women who are found to knowingly pass on an illegitimate child (Jacket) to the wrong man should face criminal charges?
Before you answer this please bear in mind the stress that the man and the child face after forming a bond only to learn later in life that they were living a lie.
Men who father a child and refuse to give support and are hauled before the court are charged and forced to pay child support.
Should the women in question here be hauled before the court and made to assume liability for emotional damages and financial fraud or something of that nature?
If some measures are put in place to hold women who engage in this practice responsible would the practice itself decrease?
2 people like this
5 responses
@sid556 (30960)
• United States
17 Nov 10
Hi tjades,
I think it would be very difficult to prove the deceit part of this equation. People move from relationship to relationship so quickly and they have multiple partners. It is not limited to the single people either. Married women cheat also. Somewhere along the way, these men have to be responsible too. Maybe a DNA test before signing the birth certificate? These days the testing can be done even before the birth. I don't see punishing the mother as a solution to this problem. What punishment would you suggest that wouldn't ultimately even further hurt the child?
@sid556 (30960)
• United States
8 Dec 10
While accidents do happen, they are both adults and should share equal responsibility. It's not ALL on the women. Woman always tend to take the brunt of the encounter. They are the one that gets pregnant, have to figure out the father and I do agree that it should not be such a puzzle but in reality...it can be, they raise the child and even if the father is determined and actually pays child support...9 out of 10 instances, it is the woman whose world is changed up to care for the child. More often and surely not always the man sees the children or child on his terms and when it fits conveniently into his schedule. While there are women that do deliberatley claim a man is the dad when he is not, I have to say that in most cases she doesn't have a clue. She is as irresponsible as the guy and just going after who she wishes it was or thinks will be the best dad. And often she might really think it is the guy she names. If the guy she names as the dad doesn't KNOW then he is as irresponsible as she is.
@tjades (3591)
• Jamaica
20 Nov 10
Hi Sid . Thanks for responding.
I actually know of one or two cases where the child was knowingly passed on to another man in a bid to hide the real paternity of the child or where the woman wanted to somehow get back at the real father. There are cases where the real father is sure (or strongly felt) his girlfriend was bearing his child but she denies it is his child.
I agree it might be hard to prove but it would not be impossible. The effects the punishment to the mother would have on the child is important to bear in consideration but I do feel that some measures should be put in place to catch women who wantonly do this. The fact is that when a woman knowingly pass on a child to the wrong man by trickery that is where the first hurt is inflicted on the child. The truth has a way of coming out even after years of being hidden.
It would be at the discretion of the court and the offended man but I think if the man so desires then he should be financially compensated. Each case would have its own level of sensitivity so a blanket cure is not applicable.
@rovered777 (649)
• United States
17 Nov 10
The world has to focus more responsibility onto the female, because there careless practices are what bring such a situation. If a man was married to someone for a long time, and the baby came from another person's DNA, it is inconceivably ill respect that is happening. Court testimonies and child support allocation will target the father and mother, but I think emotional damages are necessary to exploit such a practice. Like you said, this is not a easy and deliberate result made by accident, and the Male partner will become the butt of all anger and regret when such things happen. Life should not be lived so recklessly and shamefully, as these individuals are liars by faith.
@tjades (3591)
• Jamaica
20 Nov 10
I agree with you. We cant just ignore the hurt and misery that such a situation created for the man. He was tricked into emotionally bonding with a child which was not his while the woman is there observing all this knowing that they were living a lie.
It is a royal mess that she should not be able to just escape from because she knows the law will favor her for the sake of the child.
@RONDOLAWE (774)
• Indonesia
17 Nov 10
it is immoral if we say a child was illegitimate and the food is not forbidden to us, why be in say an illegitimate child, her actions caused by adults who can not resist his passion that can surely, it planted seeds that would bear fruit and result does not want to say such a b son of a b what does it mean if people do not realize it too and always enjoy their treatment and do not say it anymore because the children born to never want a forbade him because the Lord brought him to an adult who knew everything
@forumtank (43)
• Philippines
17 Nov 10
when i read your message there are many answer in your question but we are not the same answer to your question,
actually base on i hear to my friends, many reason why they didn't not accept there responsibility as a father to there child,
there are many reason, one reason there are scared to there parent or they did not love the girl, or they are both young and they think, it is not time to do that responsibility
ms tjades, right now mr mcbean is not ready for that kind of responsibility, give them time,
may be in the future he will realize that he has a responsibility to his child.
tjades, if i where you, talk to your parents regarding your problem, because your parents will understand you a lot in that kind of situation.
@tjades (3591)
• Jamaica
20 Nov 10
I sorry but I nearly keeled over with laughter when I realized you think I was talking about myself. SMH
I actually have not even had my first child yet and have never been pregnant. Its OK though. No hard feelings about that mistake. I brought the subject up here because a friend of mine emailed me an article on this topic.
Thanks for sharing your thoughts forumtank.
@karillions (7)
•
17 Nov 10
I think you are right! I do believe this is on the up - as someone who works with pregnant mothers i have many girls ask me if i can work out for them who the father would be from a variety of men - one girl had a choice of 5. What does this mean about society today? if children believe the wrong man is their father isnt it possible that in the future they may try to have relations with someone who is actually related to them by blood?