Do other countries have a holiday like Thanksgirving in their culture
By sharone74
@sharone74 (4837)
United States
November 20, 2010 10:20am CST
In the past I have had cause to call businesses outsiee the US and to recieve such calls on Thanksgiving and I have discoverred that for most cultures if they do celebrate Thanksgiving or the start of the winter months celebration simply does no coincide with our own holidays. Thanksgiving in America is the commemoration of a holiday get together between our native American peoples and the new white settlers. The settlers where dying of starvation and it looked like the Plymoth colony would fail again just as the Jametown colony failed before it. Thje natives thought that it would be bad luck to let another group of people die there and so they decided to help them. The point of the dinner was not only to feed these first Amricans but to establish the idea that there was plenty of things to eat out there, and the content of the meal was what the men had taught the men to hunt and what the women folk had shown them could be gathered and eaten. Were it not for the help of the indian people which was commemorated and which is celebrated as the day that the colony became viable and from which emerged all of American society and colonization Without their help the second colony of early Americans should have died also.
5 responses
@sharone74 (4837)
• United States
27 Nov 10
That is interesting it is also something that I did not know. Thanks for your reply.
@louievill (28851)
• Philippines
20 Nov 10
Thanks giving is purely an American thing and we respect that very much, the Great country would not be if not for thanks giving, my country being a former colony use to celebrate thanks giving but after our independence we have come to call it Fil-American Friendship day ( not so sure if it is a non-working holiday), we honor that especially America's contribution to our educatioon and democratic system.
@sharone74 (4837)
• United States
27 Nov 10
Thanksgiving is still an American holiday and it is not one that can be grafted onto another culture just because they associate with us.
@oldchem1 (8132)
•
21 Nov 10
We do not have anything like this in the UK.
Our only autumn celebration is not a holiday and is not celebrated by everyone and that is the traditional Harvest Festivals held in churches, country villages and schools etc; this is traditionally held on the nearest Sunday to the Harvest Moon in October.
This actually started in the UK before Christianity but in 1843a vicar in Cornwall invited his parishioners to a special thanksgiving service at his church and it was this that started the tradition of decorating churches with home-grown produce for the Harvest Festival services in churches.
Nowadays, children also take gifts of fruit and vegetables to church and present them during the harvest service whilst the harvest hymn 'We plough the fields and scatter the good seed on the land, But it is fed and watered by God's almighty hand' is sung. After the service, these gifts are distributed to the elderly and needy people of the community, although some years are church held auctions for the goods and then sent the money to the third world.
Many schools also have a Harvest Festival assembly and the gifts of fruit and vegetables are distributed in the local community.
@rovered777 (649)
• United States
20 Nov 10
No, I really think there is no holiday like Thanksgiving in India. There are other festivals like Diwali and Puja that do take on a thankful approach, but the parties and entertainment are different compared to U.S. thanksgiving. Over here in the U.S., people celebrate by sitting down with family and friends to eat a Turkey and may watch TV or sit it out for entertainment. In India, people will dance and throw powder everywhere for Diwali, and after there activity has reached a high point, they will sit down for dinner. Indians usually talk more about the family and how they are faring in life as opposed to Americans.
@sharone74 (4837)
• United States
27 Nov 10
Americans tend to be more nomadic than indians who live in much tighter knit groups than do American families.
@muchmoremoola (33)
• Canada
20 Nov 10
We celebrate Thanksgiving in Canada. It is celebrated on the 2nd Monday of every October. It is to give thanks for a successful harvest and is celebrated earlier than the Thanksgiving holiday because we are further North. An English explorer settled in Newfoundland in 1578 and had a celebration for his long journey. This was considered the first Thanksgiving. He was later Knighted and had the inlet Frobisher Bay named after him. Around the same time French settlers arrived in Canada and also celebrated with huge feasts and shared with the native people. During the American Revolution, Americans who remained loyal to England moved to Canada and brought with them their custom and practices of Thanksgiving. So the two holidays are closely related between the two countries. In Canada everyone has the day off and they have a big turkey dinner either on the Mon., or quite often on the Sunday.
Where I live we are very multi cultural so we also celebrate Diwali, Chinese New Year etc.