think before you donate - eye opener
By ketybhagat
@ketybhagat (4123)
India
December 1, 2010 1:13am CST
As you open your purses/wallets when "donating" for another natural disaster, keep the following facts in mind; we have listed them from the highest to the lowest (paid offender).
UNICEF - CEO
The worst offender was yet again for the 11th year in a row is, UNICEF - CEO, receives $1,200,000. per year, (plus use of a Royal Royce for his exclusive use where ever he goes, and an expense account that is rumoured to be well over $150,000.) Only pennies from the actual donations goes to the UNICEF cause (less than $0.14 per dollar of income).
American Red Cross President and CEO
The second worst offender this year is Marsha J. Evans, President and CEO of the American Red Cross...for her salary for the year ending in 2009 was $651,957 plus expenses. Enjoys 6 weeks - fully paid holidays including all related expenses during the holiday trip for her and her husband and kids. including 100% fully paid health & dental plan for her and her family, for life. This means out of every dollar they bring in, about $0.39 goes to related charity causes.
Ready for this... I think you might be surprised...
It is, none other than...
The Salvation Army's Commissioner
Todd Bassett, The Salvation Army's Commissioner receives a salary of only $13,000 per year (plus housing) for managing this $2 Billion dollar organization. Which means about $0.93 per dollar earned, is readily available and goes back out to local charity causes... truly amazing... and well done
No further comment is necessary..."Think Twice" before you give to your charity of choice as to which one really does the best for the most - or the least for the most, for that matter.
8 people like this
16 responses
@Rainbowliselle (498)
• Philippines
1 Dec 10
We are just a group of friends who bridge the donors to their recipients. We don't raise funds so as to not to make complex charity works. When a sponsor sends money for one charity, we right away execute the charity based on his/her budget and email him/her the scanned receipts. In this way, everything is clear... as to how their money is being spent by the group. Besides, ours is all voluntary services. No incentive nor any salary received. The only benefit we get is going to remote areas of the city where we haven't been before. We have made a number of less-fortunate children happy for more than two years now. We give slippers, school bags with some school supplies in them, feeding program, cash education assistance and toys when christmas comes. we also donate paints to some public schools and whiteboard to the deaf and mute class in one public school. As much as possible, we don't accumulate the money that are sent to us. We right away execute individual's charity work. :)
1 person likes this
@ketybhagat (4123)
• India
9 Dec 10
Heu rainbow, this is a wonderful way of charity work. I too believe that what we do with our own hands not only gives us the satisfaction, but also the knowledge that the money for charity goes to charity alone. You are doing a wonderful job and I really know you must be having a lot of blessings from the less fortunate. Hats off to you guys. I know it takes a lot of work and time and when you give this to charity, you are blessed. Many thanks for sharing with us. Makes me still feel the warmth of human kindness.
@Rainbowliselle (498)
• Philippines
9 Dec 10
Hi Ketybhagat and Flagaz, THANKS! Sand in the Wind site is linked at my MyLot homepage. The latest we witnessed the smiles of more than a hundred less-fortunate kids were students of the last village of the city in the west coast. We had never been there before since many are scared to step that place because of talks about bad elements. The place is beautiful in terms of nature. Was I glad as well that another friend from another school donated whiteboard for the deaf and mute of one public school through us. The fact that he wanted us to do his charity is already one big blessing for me.
As to the tax exemption, honestly, i don't mind getting one. As I have said, when one does charity works, he/she no longer thinks what he/she will benefit in return. What blessings that come one's way is truly from above. Thus, when my group and I do charity works of friends, we set aside our basin and cooking utensil for just a half of the morning of Saturday and think not much of ourselves but those of the recipients.
@owlwings (43910)
• Cambridge, England
1 Dec 10
It would have been very helpful if you had quoted your source for this information (and MyLot's Guidelines say that you should ALWAYS link to information like this rather than quote it).
By just doing some simple searches using the MyLot Search bar (earned 19 cents!), I found plenty of sites which give factual information about how much of your donation goes to the cause itself. One is Charity Navigator, which claims to be America's largest charity evaluator and gives a state-by-state breakdown of 'local' charities: http://www.charitynavigator.org/
If you are thinking of giving to a charity this season, beware of emails and telemarketers soliciting for charities you have never heard of. The following tips are from the National Consumers League's Internet Fraud Watch:
"[i]If you're approached by an unfamiliar charity, check it out. Most states require charities to register with them and file annual reports showing how they use donations.
Ask your state or local consumer protection agency how to get this information. The Better Business Bureau Wise Giving Alliance also offers information about national charities. Call (703) 276-0100 or go to www.give.org
Be cautious about e-mails seeking charitable contributions. Many unsolicited e-mail messages are fraudulent.
Beware of sound-alikes. Some crooks try to fool people by using names that are very similar to those of well-known charities.
Ask how donations are used. One of the most important things to consider is how much of your money goes to fundraising and administrative costs, rather than to the charitable work itself.
Be wary of requests to support police or firefighters. Some fraudulent fundraisers claim that donations will benefit police or firefighters, when in fact little or no money goes to them. Contact your local police or fire department to find out if the claims are true and what percentage of donations, if any, they will receive.[/i]"
( http://www.onlinecardonation.org/charity-news/check-out-charity.htm )
Here is a page with some useful tips on how to choose a charity: http://www.ehow.com/how_2060556_pick-charity.html
Two good sites for the UK are:
The official (government) Charity Commission website: http://www.charity-commission.gov.uk/
Charity Choice: http://www.charitychoice.co.uk/charitysearch.asp
The Charity Awards site is also a useful guide to the top performing charities: http://www.charityawards.co.uk/home/winners.php?pg=1&yr=14
1 person likes this
@ketybhagat (4123)
• India
3 Dec 10
Wow owlwings, that is really doing your homework and thanks for sharing all this info with us. Yes, we people open up our hearts and weep for the affected. We open up our purses so that we may bring a little ray of hope to the needy. That is us, common men who believe in charity. It is the big CEOs of big orgs. who dont care a damn for the needy, so long as their needs are met. As you say, we should be careful of fakes who take us guillible people for a ride. It is better to donate directly if we can in cash and kind. Thanks,
@MsTickle (25180)
• Australia
13 Dec 10
Hi there...you haven't named a source...would you mind telling me where you found your information please.
I've always been against charities for the reason that most of the money goes toward administering the charity, rather than to the charity itself.
I'd really like to dig up the info for my own country.
@ketybhagat (4123)
• India
14 Dec 10
Well, this info was given to me by my friend, so I feel it should be ok. As you say, most of the money goes to others and very less to the needy. Its better to do charity by our own hands as much as we can. However, when calamity falls, we feel sad and do a lot of charity through organisations, because we cannot do it ourselves. This is our drawback and our money, hard earned and ill afforded goes to others, rather than the needy. Thanks.
@picjim (3002)
• India
1 Dec 10
Thanks for opening my eyes.I accept my ignorance in this matter and will think many times before donating to the reputed organisations.From your discussion i can glean that a minuscule amount reaches those in need.It boggles the mind that in such reputed organisations personal comfort is more important than the needy for whom they ought to provide aid.
1 person likes this
@ketybhagat (4123)
• India
3 Dec 10
Yes picjim, it is really sad that such reputed organisations and NGOs can stoop so low as to pocket money for the needy. I agree with flagaz that government politicians also pocket the money, and when humanity donates for disasters, they do so with an open heart. When money pours in, the greed increases. It is always better to donate to poor personally, help them out with their basic needs like food, clothing, etc. directly. Thanks.
@Chiniona (327)
• China
12 Dec 10
Oh,my God! Is it true? It sounds bad. However, what would you do for vulnerable groups? By the way, does the news come from the Wikileaks website?
@ketybhagat (4123)
• India
14 Dec 10
I really dont know how much is true, but Im sure quite a bit must be, for I got this info from a friend of mine. Life is really sad for some people and we hope to help them through these agencies, but you live and learn. No, this does not come from the Wikileaks website.
@fightfan_since_one (43)
• Philippines
1 Dec 10
A great eye opener information thank you very much. I hope people still hope to donate more but not to this big organizations but rather to small ones most probably charities run by the churches. People affected still need help to rebuilt their lives. Keep charity forward.
1 person likes this
@ketybhagat (4123)
• India
3 Dec 10
Hi, these days I have heard that even fathers of churches pocket money in the name of charity. I really dont know whom to trust these days. I feel it is much better to go personally and help the needy if possible with cash and kind. If not, we donate and leave the rest to the conscious of the person or organisation. Yes, when people need help, we open our hearts and pockets for them. As you say, Charity must go on. Thanks.
@mtdewgurl74 (18151)
• United States
2 Dec 10
Wow!.. I guess we just don't know who to trust anymore. I was always wary of the ones I seen on television asking for money and sponsors, But I wouldn't have thought that of the Red Cross..And that is great to know that what is given to the Salvation Army goes back into the community to be given where and when it is needed. Thanks for the information.
@ketybhagat (4123)
• India
9 Dec 10
It is any eyeopener, to know that our hard earned money goes for the frills of the CEOs and not to charity as we want it to. I feel it is better to do charity by ourselves, no matter how little, so that the money spent is used for the right purpose. I was shocked myself and thought it best to let as many people know as I can. This way we can stop our hard earned money going for the benefit of the CEOs and not the poor and needy.
@derek_a (10873)
•
2 Dec 10
Yes, I have learned this about some charities too that I have donated to in the past. I read an article lately that many of them use agencies who charge them large fees for promoting and then collecting donations. Sometimes the fees are so large that the charity ends up with little or nothing. There are some good ones out there and I appreciate the research that you have done on this. My problem is that I know people have to earn a living, but some of them appear to be on huge salaries.. _Derek
@ketybhagat (4123)
• India
9 Dec 10
The problem here is that people have forgotten what it is to be honestly kind and generous with other people's money. What they have, they want for themselves and to hell with the poor for whom the charity began. Its a sad world and yet there are people in the world who go out of the way to help the less fortunate. Blessed are those who care for the others too. Every body has a right to earn salaries for work done, but this is preposterous. Hardly anything goes to charity. We live and learn.
@shaggin (72240)
• United States
1 Dec 10
The Salvation army is a great oraganization I think. They do a lot for the community. I like to shop at the salvation army thats the best part and part of the proceeds goes to the programs that give back to the community. It seems that for doing all that work though that Todd Bassett isnt receiving that much money. My ex made more then that doing plumbing and heating locally. It seems someone running a huge thing like the salvation army should be making more then that. $13,000 a year really isnt that much to live off if you have medical expenses and rent and car payments or house payments.
@ketybhagat (4123)
• India
9 Dec 10
Yes shaggin, it just shows that the Salvation Army is doing a good job and the charity work done by Todd Bassett is to be appreciated. What can one do in this age for a sum of $13000/- per year. It just shows his goodwill towards the poor and he is doing the work more for charity than anything else. Keep up the good work and shop at the salvation army , just our way of doing charity. Thanks.
@bunnybon7 (50973)
• Holiday, Florida
1 Dec 10
i have always known about the salvation army being the best. ive read a lot about them and they know and live by what our savior meant when it comes to charity. they always have been for doing more for others then profiting for themselves.
@ketybhagat (4123)
• India
9 Dec 10
Yes bunnybon, the Salvation Army isdoing a good job and we now have proof of it. God Bless Todd for all the work he is dong for a measly sarlary. Money given for charity must reach charity, or we sin in the eyes of the Lord. Better still, do charity with our own hands, this way we know for sure the money is now being used by the poor and needy. Thanks.
@6precious102 (4043)
• United States
2 Dec 10
I knew UNICEF was not worth giving to, but I didn't know that about Red Cross. For disaster relief I give to an organization called IDES. I hope they're all right. I was glad to hear that money given to the Salvation Army mostly goes to charitable causes. I don't give to them, but I think my mother and brother do. Thanks for the information.
@ketybhagat (4123)
• India
9 Dec 10
We live and learn, and now we know where to donate. I would feel scared to use charity money for myself. Its like committing a big sin. Im glad your mother and brother are doing the right thing, and hopefully now you too will do the same. I have not idea about IDES but look it up before you donate. Better to do what little charity we do by ourselves or through Salvation Army or through one of our mylotters here Rainbowliselle who goes out of the way to help the less fortunate. Thanks.
@ketybhagat (4123)
• India
9 Dec 10
Hi bhanu, yes its been a long time. Sometimes the work load is so much, I just dont get time, other times Im lazy. Yes the UNICEF, Red Cross etc. are all big in names and not in the work they do. Every penny that we earn, we need it ourselves, but when there is a calamity, our heart goes out to the unfortunates and we dip our hands into our pockets, hoping to help them, but alas how much goes to them is now a question. Better to do charity ourselves. Thanks.
@gracetreyes (529)
• Philippines
1 Dec 10
since am here in the Philippines, I donated to reputable institution that really helps the needy and really extend all their resources to help those people in need.I choose World Vision and the CBN-Asia 700 Club. I believe they do wonders for all our donations and they also bring blessings to us donors. Since I believe that every child has the right to schooling, World Vision is the right institution. And extending help to poor Families by giving them jobs or small business that will improve their way of living, 700 club delivers it amazingly. so give a try, and give to these reputable institution and Our Good Lord will surely bless us.
@ketybhagat (4123)
• India
9 Dec 10
Thank you grace for the info, Im sure it will help a lot of people reading this post. You are doing right by donating to people whom we know will surely reach our money to the poor and needy. Yes, in charity work, though we may not do it ourselves, this little act of kindness will go a long way in the eyes of the Lord.
@mysticmaggie (2498)
• United States
2 Dec 10
I usually give only to the Salvation Army and veterans charities. The Salvation Army does a phenomenal job of urging volunteers to help and puts so much toward actually helping people. I have never seen any other organization that is able to do what they do.
@ketybhagat (4123)
• India
9 Dec 10
When an organisation does charity work, it shows. Thats what the Salvation Army is doing and its head, Todd has to be appreciated. There are still people in the world like Rainbowliselle here on mylot who go out of their way to help the needy. Hats off to such people who make time and energy to help the less fortunate and are downright honest about it.
@ketybhagat (4123)
• India
9 Dec 10
Yes iwrite, it is a sorry state of affairs. What is meant for the poor and charity must go to charity, a very small percent should go for the salaries. These salaries are ridiculous ! Just shows its better to do charity ourselves.
!
@tomitomi (5429)
• Singapore
1 Dec 10
This is a real eye opener. It should be shared and made known to many. Thanks for the info.
@ketybhagat (4123)
• India
9 Dec 10
I was shocked when I read it and decided to let as many people know as I could. Imagine when we ourselves need every extra bit of cash, yet in times of trouble, we dip into our savings for the needy and this is how it is spent. Better to do a little of charity work ourselves or donating to honest people who will go out of the way to help the needy.