How to make someone take the medicines for acute depression?
By mimpi
@mimpi1911 (25464)
India
December 16, 2010 2:03am CST
Hi! How have you been? I am keeping good.
I am here, however, for a serious health issue that has been troubling my friend for some months now. My friend is suffering from acute depression which makes her feel that everyone is out to kill her with the medication that she is supposed to take. Obviously, it difficult to make her take the regular medicines. Taking her to the psycho-analyst for regular consultation is a thing that they have just about managed. Of late, this has aggravated and she is NOT taking any medicines. Her parents and husband have tried every means but she just would not eat anything from anyone's hand.
Asking for your advice and suggestions that might help her and the family to cope with the crisis.
Thanks.
3 people like this
13 responses
@drannhh (15219)
• United States
17 Dec 10
Where you been? I cannot help with making someone take meds because I do not believe in Western medicine or in taking meds, so I wouldn't be a good one for making other people take them. Does she become violent if people just leave her alone?
1 person likes this
@mimpi1911 (25464)
• India
17 Dec 10
Nice to see you dear. I am good and hope that you are too.
Does she get violent? Not really. But leaving her alone would mean that she would step out of the house, disillusioned and clueless, which could lead to accidents. Locking the doors is even worse, for she gets violent when she finds the doors locked. She is not eating at all. She is not sleeping, eating, doing normal routine stuffs. The meds include sedative, but how to help her take it!
1 person likes this
@mimpi1911 (25464)
• India
19 Dec 10
That is why we are worried. However, she has taken the meds yesterday, after much ado. Keeping our fingers crossed..
@mimpi1911 (25464)
• India
19 Dec 10
That could be a possibility. But in her case this started even before she visited the consultant. Thanks for your prayers jd, really appreciate.
@sreevasu (2717)
• India
5 Jan 11
Mou,
After reading your (friend's) issue and its responses, I've some simple suggestions.
Your friend is undergoing some sort of mental distractions (for we who think we are normal by all means).
If there is someone who is interested in her betterment, I would suggest them to take her away to a calm and cool ambiance for sometime and behave to her as if nothing is wrong with her. A person in depression (as what we analyze it) need self confidence and care. And the right 'medicine' for that should come from those who really wish her betterment. Of course, it's a task, which now a days no one want to give a try. But here, now, I assure you that if, everyone permits, and no one else come forward to do that, I am ready to cure her. And I know, what is to her is not a disease, but a state of mind, which need to be normalized (to our standards of course, as we must say)
Write back, even if I am Yes or No.
@mimpi1911 (25464)
• India
16 Jan 11
Hi Sreevasu,
your suggestions means a lot, as always. Nice to see you after long.
You are right. She requires lot of time and attention which the husband understands. He is trying to give in his best, spending time with her. And this eventually made her take her meds regularly after which she is much better.
Thanks a lot Sreevasu.
@sick4muzick (816)
• Philippines
21 Dec 10
Hello Mimpi. It has been ages since I last have been here. I am glad you are still around. I have been reading the responses to your problem and they all sound good. I hope and pray by this post that your friend has taken a step forward towards getting well. I've been around a very good psychiatrist and all I can say is choosing one is very crucial. I think gaining the trust of your friend would go a long way to making her well. She would open up and start taking that first step if she knows, realizes and believes she's not all alone in her problem. I wish you were nearer to me so I could at least help. Lots of prayers and hugs for you and your friend and do please keep us posted. Thank you.
@mimpi1911 (25464)
• India
15 Jan 11
Hi dear!
I am so glad to see you here. Even though, I am not getting much time to hang on here but it feels great to see the old friends. Thanks for dropping in.
Thanks for your wishes. Ever since she has been taking medicines, she is keeping much better, if not completely recovered. It would take time and we are are there around her giving her as much love as possible. Thanks for your prayers, it means a lot to me.
@paula27661 (15811)
• Australia
21 Dec 10
It’s funny I came across your discussion because just today I asked my husband how he was feeling and he said that he felt depressed. He suffers from bipolar and that is part of his condition; he does get down and, thankfully, because he takes his meds it is usually short lived. I did tell him that when the depression is of a clinical nature there is nothing I can do to help whereas if the cause of the depression is a circumstantial there may be a chance I may be able to assist. Although bipolar has made our life very difficult at times I am very thankful that my husband takes the meds as required.
I have no idea how to convince someone to medicate themselves. The only way would be to disguise the tablet somehow like crushing them or something. A chat to the doctor would be advisable.
@mimpi1911 (25464)
• India
16 Jan 11
Hi Paula,
You are a great person who is a healing force for many and your words are comforting as always. The family of the friend was at loss when she declined to take meds. Thankfully, she is now better with meds.
1 person likes this
@JenInTN (27514)
• United States
17 Dec 10
Heyya mimpi! Great to see you on.
I don't know if there is anyway to force your friend to take her meds but maybe instead of them handing them to her...they can remind her to go and get them....follow her to make sure she does. It's hard when you have someone that really needs medicine that refuses to take it. Good luck.
1 person likes this
@mimpi1911 (25464)
• India
19 Dec 10
Thanks Jenin. No rhyme and reason working for her at this point. It's tugh making her understand. She would listen with good intent but then she will do her mind. I guess, nothing is seeping inside her. She needs help and if things do not work she has to be hospitalised.
@alokn99 (5717)
• India
16 Dec 10
Hi Mimpi,
It's great to see you active here after a long time.
Sorry to hear about your friend. The little information or advice that I can share with you is based on the experience of a friend whose son has been going through depression for many years, although it may not have been as serious as this. In her case, when her son refused to take the medicines, she would conceal it in the food and give it. The son soon figured this out and got very suspicious of what he was given to eat.
But what really worked in his case, was that he slowly gained confidence in his counsellor and got close to him. The counsellor convinced him from all angles on how the medicines would benefit him. This happened after many sessions with different counsellors and after a couple of years. This is what worked and he is continously taking the medicines and has seen a dramatic improvement since then. It's not easy to gain the persons confidence, especially when the person can be very suspicious of everyones intentions. This may work too in your friends case, provided she can gain the trust and confidence of someone close to her or a good counsellor who can spend time with her.
@mimpi1911 (25464)
• India
17 Dec 10
Alok,
Smetimes things are more difficult than we can imagine and this friend of mine, who was like a beautiful little girl until some months back, has now gotten into a dreadful life. We all are prating for her well being. Taking her to the counselor has been another dreadful task, and when someone doesnot understand, you cannot force her to do things. She has virtually stopped eating and started to cook her own. It is a sad thing.
@kalav56 (11464)
• India
16 Dec 10
Hullo mimpi!
How are you? I could only think of one thing which is similar to what Alok has suggested.THe medicine can be powdered , mixed with honey concealed ina piece of cake or sweet or Barfi and given to her. But, children [with whom we normally adopt thsi strategy] are different from a suspecting adult. THen there is no other choice except to take her to a doctor , tell her that she has some internal disease and has the medicine injected .I cannot think of anything else. Is there noone in the world that she really likes? Not even her mother or child?
@mimpi1911 (25464)
• India
19 Dec 10
Kala, it has been a pain going through the ordeal. The family is just shattered. Even though, she has taken the meds yesterday, the task of making her take it is a continuous process. Unless she understands that it is for her well being, it's tough and in that case she has to be hospitalised.
@dpk262006 (58678)
• Delhi, India
20 Dec 10
Hi Mimpi!
It is really a difficult situation and when one is not ready to take medicines, it gets all the more complicated. I think best course of action is to get her treated through a 'psychiatric'. She needs to be taken to a psychiatric by any means and once she is under treatment, she will start improving gradually. She needs to be taken care by her near and dear ones and needs to be attended constantly by someone close to her, who could instill confidence in her.
(Sometimes I feel that our mind is too complicated to understand for someone and even psychiatrists fail to solve the complex riddles).
Best of luck to your friend.
@mimpi1911 (25464)
• India
20 Dec 10
Thanks deepak. That is what they are planning. even though, she's been under a psycho therapy, she needs inhouse treatment since she is getting violent and unmanageable. Indeed it's too complicated and the reason? Hard to understand.
@mylesnarvaez (5451)
• Philippines
16 Dec 10
hi mimpi!
i'm sorry to hear of your friend's dilemma. acute depression is a clinical ailment that is often brought on by stress, a personal loss, health crisis, physical disability, insomia, and even sadness... i would like to find out which is the probable cause for her condition. medicines can help only up to a certain extent like calming nerves, helping her sleep better, help her increase appetite in eating... but not a direct cure. knowledge of what caused her condition can help her family understand her better and help her cope up. they would also be advised how best to approach her condition without aggravating it further.
one of the hardest things to do for a sick person is have him/her take his/her medicines. frankly, the patient's probable dislike of medicine is due to denying the fact that he/she is sick. so sometimes we find alternatives to these tablets and capsules. if it's to calm nerves and help her sleep better, we advise herbal tea... etc. depending on the cause of her acute depression, different ways of overcoming it can be applied like talking to her a lot more, having friends and family around more, taking long walks, vacations, creating hobbies that can both be physical or something to occupy her thoughts.
i do hope your friend gets better soon. tc
@Hatley (163776)
• Garden Grove, California
18 Dec 10
hi mimpi i am confused is depression that much of a mental illness that the person is really acting a bit psycho? I would insist
that she go to a top psychiatrist and get professional help as she sounds as if there is a lot more going on that just depression
to me.I mean thinking people are out to kill her is not something' have ever heard of in a mere depression.could she be becoming a schizophrenic?
She definitely needs more than just medication for depression she needs a real psychiatrist.
@mimpi1911 (25464)
• India
19 Dec 10
She is under a psychiatrist. However, what you have said there makes much sense. She indeed shows symptoms of split-personality, something which we never considered. Another thing, Hatley, it was a task convincing the parents to take her to the therapist. They were initially in denial and the possibility of schizophrenia will blow them off. But they have to understand. I will tell her husband about this today and let you know. Thanks dear for the help. Hope you and you son are doing good and your computer is working fine now.
@dawnald (85146)
• Shingle Springs, California
16 Dec 10
You can't make her do anything she doesn't want to. You can just let her know you care, and that you are there for her, and hope that she starts caring enough to help herself.
@mimpi1911 (25464)
• India
17 Dec 10
I wish the family could do that. However, she is in such depressive bout that she has but to take medicines in order to survive, and she doesn't understand that.
@dorannmwin (36392)
• United States
18 Dec 10
Unfortunately, unless there is some way tha your friend's family is able to get her to be deemed medically incompetent, there is no way that anyone can force her to take her medications. If they are able to get her deemed medically incompetent then they may commit her to a psychiatric hospital where she really won't have any control over anything in her life, but she would be getting the medications that she so despirately needs.
@mimpi1911 (25464)
• India
19 Dec 10
That's the plan Dora. Atleast she would take her meds regularly. She has taken it yesterday but will she today? Do not now. Thanks for your time and suggestions and happy shopping with sister. Will keep you updated.