Strays and rejects
By TigerSpirit
@TigerSpirit (320)
Australia
December 28, 2010 6:39am CST
We can't deny it, we all know that majority of councils have a high death rate when it comes to stray dogs and cats. As much as we like to think that the majority of cats and dogs end up in animal rescue shelters that have a no kill or low kill policy, thousands more cats and dogs, end up in council pounds on a 5 - 15 day waiting period (depending on where you are) before those cats/dogs are euthanised.
Yet in many of the colleges and universities where people study veterinary scients so as to become future vets, often work on cadavers no doubt sent to them by some councils.
Speaking to a friend of mine who runs an animal rescue shelter, she was telling me how she can't understand how, if the dogs are going to be destroyed anyway, why can't they be sent 'still alive' to the universities so the vets could have practical training on the care and handling of dogs and cats before having to humanely euthanise them.
Who knows, if they did this, perhaps the occasional student would fall for one of the condemned and take them home to keep as their own pet, so that animal has had that final chance to have their live saved.
I initially used to think it would be cruel, but I see her point. Trainee vets do need to do practical lessons, and they can't learn this from reading a book, or the computer, just working with cadavers or some plastic dummy isn't really going to help them when they go out in the field.
And the benefits of practicing on a live animal whilst still in class would mean the transition to field work would be smoother, the trainee vets would have had to learn how to harden their heart to the cases they'll eventually have to deal with. (Every animal lover who has become a vet has realised that to deal with their job on a daily basis, as much as you want to keep that loving heart, it'd break every time you had to euthanise an animal for whatever reason.
So just wondering, what are your thoughts, do you think if a cat or dog is going to be euthanised anyway, should they be sent to the universities? And if you are a vet, what were your learning experiences? What's the worst memory you have re courses? What's the best?
2 people like this
3 responses
@gabs8513 (48686)
• United Kingdom
28 Dec 10
Well Tiger to be honest, I do not agree with it at all but I know that it has to be done eventually because they run out of room, what I do not get to this Day is why do People do this, why get a Dog/Cat and then well let them go it makes me mad
I do think though that they should get a second Chance specially if they are still young
So I really do not know what to reply to your Question
@TigerSpirit (320)
• Australia
29 Dec 10
Gabs, I agree with you, it bugs the hell out of me that people will take in pets, then let them go stray, or they take in pets, then don't get them desexed, spayed or neutered, so their pets kids become strays.
But it also upsets me the high turn over of council pounds where I don't think 5 days is enough time for any animal to find a home.
1 person likes this
@alottodo (3056)
• Australia
29 Dec 10
I just found a kitten in a car park 2 days before Christmas, took it to the vet to see if it was microchipped and it was not the vet said to take it to the pound as he informed me it's against the law to keep an astray animal I completely refused to do so, so now the kitten is very much at home and full of mischif, I could not part with him. I can't understand how people can be so cruel and get rid of their pet when they don't like them any more! As to future vets studying on live animals?[ if the animal is not hurt in any way] I don't see why not. They will be put down eventually and this way some of them might have a chance.
@TigerSpirit (320)
• Australia
29 Dec 10
I'm so glad you rescued the kitten and gave it a chance at life, and not listen to the vet.
You're right, I can't understand how people can be so cruel either. I know a lot of it is ignorance, but to me, that's not an excuse.
Heaven knows there's been enough education put out for people as to how to take care of their pets, how to treat them, and take responsibility... guess some people are just more dense than you'd expect.
@dawnald (85146)
• Shingle Springs, California
29 Dec 10
I'd imagine students can practice on actual animals at a veterinary clinic. There must be clinics that take students, just like there are teaching hospitals. I see your point about this possibly being a way to find some of these animals a home, but on the other hand it seems cruel to do something that might hurt an animal in the interest of studying it. There may also be laws against that in some places.
@TigerSpirit (320)
• Australia
29 Dec 10
Hi Dawn, they do also get practical training at a vets or vet hospital, but we also get the training while still in the class (I know from my memory of the animal technician course).
There was no harm done to the animals. We were taught how to examine them from a distance, then how to examine them close up. Then we were taught on the humane way of making a muzzle, and the humane way of securing a cat or dog using just our arms and hands if the need arise, (so as not to hurt them, but to stop them hurting us also). There were a lot of things we were taught using live animals.
The one thing we weren't taught was to how to inject them with needles, we used cadavers for that,and that was fine for the early courses, but it would have been good to learn practical on a live so we learn the best way of how to give needles without hurting the animals.
1 person likes this