You can't force a love of reading.
By megamatt
@megamatt (14291)
United States
December 29, 2010 11:42am CST
I hear all about how children do not like to read. So in school, teachers are pretty much stepping up efforts to get children to read. Given that this in most cases will just make a child just dislike it even more. It has soured them. I like reading but when I was forced to read something, I didn't really like it all that much. Imagine if someone who doesn't like to like reading, was forced. Reading is something that is a taste that is acquired. I can imagine that all attempts to force this natural like is just leading to many adults never picking up a book after school.
5 people like this
23 responses
@Liliac26 (557)
• Romania
29 Dec 10
I've loved reading from a very young age. It was probably my favorite thing to do when I was a child, and all my friends thought I was reading way too much (I've been called a bookworm more than once). But I still hated reading what was required at school. I think the teachers ruined for me a few books that I would have otherwise enjoyed by forcing me to read them when I didn't want to. I felt like they were interfering with my personal space.
But I don't really know what to think about this matter. Some kids wouldn't read at all if they weren't forced to, and sometimes they grow up to regret it. I have a friend who always tells me that she wished she had read more as a child. I think in the end the matter lays with parents and teachers who should know how to attract children to books, and at the same tame allow them more freedom in what they choose to read (or accept that some kids just aren't inclined that way).
@megamatt (14291)
• United States
30 Dec 10
Well said indeed. Yes, I noticed something about a lot of books that I was forced to read in school. I might have liked them otherwise if I had not been forced. And when I read them outside of being forced in a couple of instances, I did. Thank you for your response. It is much appreciated and it contributed to the topic well. Have a nice day and thanks.
@hardworkinggurl (37063)
• United States
29 Dec 10
Reading is like any other interest whereas you either enjoy it or don't. Some people outright loath to read so the children are people also, so it has to be understood that just like any other adult it cannot be forced.
Unfortunately they will have to, to get through the course of learning. I am sure those who do not enjoy it are so glad they no longer have to after schooling years.
@hora_fugit (5862)
• India
29 Dec 10
To my old eyes, internet seems a temptation I should better keep off from...
@hardworkinggurl (37063)
• United States
29 Dec 10
You know what I have noticed they will like post retirement, the internet.
1 person likes this
@Angelwriter (1954)
• United States
30 Dec 10
Oh, I agree. What you have to do is rarely something you like to do. But, even though I don't think you can force a love of reading, I do think you can and should encourage it. Some kids may not know how much fun reading can be if they're left on their own. But, turning it into a chore isn't the right way.
I don't know if I'm the right example, because I already did like reading. But, in sixth grade, our English teacher read to us. To me, that was a good way to encourage reading. It introduced kids to the story (who doesn't like a good story) but there wasn't any pressure. We didn't have to do quizzes or reports. And since it happened during class time it wasn't like reading was stopping us from playing, because if we weren't listening to the book, we'd be doing school work. My mom also had a good way to introduce reading. She simply bought books that she thought my brother and I would like. (I usually ended up reading my brother's books, because he's not much of a reader. I mean a reader for fun, although I think he reads more as an adult than he did as a kid) Not for any special occasion. Just maybe once or twice a week, she'd buy a book for us. And then she'd leave it up to us if we wanted to read. So we weren't forced to do it. But, it was available if we wanted.
Also, I don't think this doesn't come under force, but one of the worst things I saw when I worked at a library was when parents vetoed what books kids picked for themselves. I don't mean books that went against their morals or anything. I mean parents telling kids that the books were too easy and they had to pick something more up to their level. These weren't books they had to read for school. These were books the kids wanted to read. Wanted to read for fun. And they were told that their choice wasn't good enough. I always thought that was a good way to turn a child against reading. They'd think this was supposed to be fun, and they still had to pass some kind of test. (Sorry for going off topic, but that always bothered me)
1 person likes this
@megamatt (14291)
• United States
30 Dec 10
Reading should be about choices. Therefore, when you eliminate the choices, it is going to make it seem like work. I mean, reading should be fun, not a chore and when something is a chore, like mowing the lawn or cleaning the bathroom, people tend to dread it. Thank you for your response. It is much appreciated and it contributed to the topic well. Have a nice day and thanks.
@rajaiv0810 (1012)
• Philippines
30 Dec 10
When I was younger I was really a voracious reader. I would also like my children to develop this. My daughter at the beginning refused to read. But when she started to learn how to read and she got interested to Disney princesses, she would ask me to buy books about these. My little boy is more interested into reading although he couldn't read on his own yet but he would often request me to read something for him. I hope when he would grow up he would be a wide reader too.
1 person likes this
@megamatt (14291)
• United States
30 Dec 10
If children request that they be read to, then that's a start in the right direction. Hopefully that will bloom into something better after a while. Only you can hope. Thank you for your response. It is much appreciated and it contributed to the topic well. Have a nice day and thanks.
@macdingolinger (10386)
• United States
30 Dec 10
this is true. I started my kids early with trips to the library and billed it all as "fun"! For a while they didn't like to read anyway but eventually they both became very avid readers in their own areas of interest! I have a friend who really does not like to read at all. But not long ago someone gave her an ereader. She loves it! I think she looks at a book and is intimidated and this way it stays "small" no matter what! Now she reads all the time!
@megamatt (14291)
• United States
30 Dec 10
I think that whatever works, as long as it allows someone a chance to love reading. Different people discover their love for different ways. There are many paths that can lead to reading. Thank you for your response. It is much appreciated and it contributed to the topic well. Have a nice day and thanks.
@ren1982 (341)
•
29 Dec 10
i have a 12 year old daughter and she hates to read. her dad is always going on about it to me when i talk with him. i try to tell him to just let her find her kind of book then she will love to read.
i was about 11 when i started getting into reading. before that i wasnt that bothered until i picked that one book up it was a great book call the man who loved clowns, sad story made me cry even at 11! but from there i was always reading and still do today alot!
so i think yes you should try to get kids to read but dont force it on them. just should them all different kind of books out there i am sure something will get them reading and loving it!
not only that kids do alot more reading in there free time then before, now adays kids are always online playing games searching for things and even using sites like facebook. so for them to be online doing all this stuff they are always reading!
1 person likes this
@megamatt (14291)
• United States
29 Dec 10
Very true, it is a matter of finding the right book. Most people really do need to find something that they enjoy. For some, they find it early. For some it takes a little longer. Still, hopefully they will. Thank you for your response. It is much appreciated and it contributed to the topic well. Have a nice day and thanks.
1 person likes this
@ren1982 (341)
•
29 Dec 10
i think thats the point the schools miss out on that each kid is different so when they are in a class and all get told to read the same book you will find its not what they are into. so i think its more about showing them whats out there to read and not just giving them a book and telling them to read it.
1 person likes this
@rajaiv0810 (1012)
• Philippines
30 Dec 10
I agree with you. It is just a matter of finding the right book or material for them to start it all out. After that they would try to find more.
1 person likes this
@jwfarrimond (4473)
•
29 Dec 10
My father used to read to me and that is how I learned to read before I even went to school through just following the words on the page as he spoke them. As a result, I've been a reader from at least the age of 5 and I'm a convinced advocate of reading to children as early as possible in such a way that they are also able to follow the story on the page as well. Learning this way instilled in my a livelong love of books and reading and it's not an exaggeration to say that I'm a compulsive reader - if I see something printed, I have to read it - I do it automatically.
1 person likes this
@megamatt (14291)
• United States
30 Dec 10
That is a great way to learn how to read. Your parents reading to you. That's how I learned how to read as well. It got to the point where my mother read to me and if she ever accidentally skipped a world, I was sure to make her know. That is when I knew that I was on my way to a lifetime of great reading. Thank you for your response. It is much appreciated and it contributed to the topic well. Have a nice day and thanks.
@hora_fugit (5862)
• India
29 Dec 10
I don't even remember when I started reading books with all that interest... But I love it!
As you say, and as someone already said, forcing children to read some sort of book is not appropriate. They must get different types, and surely they'll pick on one. In my case too, all my siblings have soft spot for classic novels (I'm crossing limits to say so, but let it be for now XD), but I hate them! The novels I mean Had they forced me to read those classics, God knows if I ever cared to read again!
Encourage children to read, force them not
@megamatt (14291)
• United States
30 Dec 10
Encouragement is in fact the key with reading I think. Finding things that they enjoy and perhaps giving them as gifts every now and again. The best books however are the one's that I discovered on my own. Still once you discover that thing that you enjoy, you are well on your way to enjoying a nice good round of reading. Thank you for your response. It is much appreciated and it contributed to the topic well. Have a nice day and thanks.
@hardworkinggurl (37063)
• United States
29 Dec 10
I agree with this as if parents would find books in the areas where children enjoy they would increase their interest overall.
1 person likes this
@ArmyChick (488)
• United States
31 Dec 10
I completely agree with you. If you force a child to do something, they will later hate doing it because they were forced to do it at one time. Personally i have always loved to read. I remember when i was younger and i got in trouble and was placed on punishment, I got all of my books taken away and wasnt allowed to read. I hated that. lol
@megamatt (14291)
• United States
1 Jan 11
Well for a child that loved to read, that would be a punishment that would be bad. That happened to be one time, where all of my books was taken away. It was one night but it seemed like forever. Needless to say, I have learned my lesson. Thank you for your response. It is much appreciated and it contributed to the topic well. Have a nice day and thanks.
@sminut13 (1783)
• Singapore
30 Dec 10
i agree that forcing is not the way to go, encouraging is. many have given their opinions on this which i agree too. i've been reading since young but it's always been the same type of books then and now, it's the same genres too. but my husband tells me that novels and all(books that i read) are like not much use for me, it's better to read general knowledge books that are helpful and useful to me. i know that but still, i can't help but want reading my own preferred books and when he tells me that, i get irritated because i know they are good for me but i just don't feel like reading them as i'm not interested.
so i'm guessing that's how children feels too, that's why i encourage my tutees and my children to read any books they like and my son has turned out nearly like me. -_- he just wants to read books on planets mostly hehehe i agree with you that reading is a taste that is acquired. children should always be encouraged. there could be one or two books that we might buy or borrow, something that would pique their interest, like maybe ufos, our body, etc. a book with pictures but thick enough with tons of information that when they're bored, they would want to pick it up and look through. i used to have one on ufos, myths and legends and it used to fascinate me sometimes when i didn't have anything to do or when my friends talked about ghosts or something. that book definitely gave me some knowledge but unfortunately, it's lost as someone borrowed it from me and never returned it back. it cost a lot too:( oh well, have a good day
@sminut13 (1783)
• Singapore
2 Jan 11
oh you said it right, knowledge books are fun and definitely useful for improving our knowledge but when you're not that interested, it is dry and mechanical, just the right words. thanks so much for understanding and i'm glad that i was able to contribute to the topic even in a small way. thanks so much too and have a good day
@megamatt (14291)
• United States
1 Jan 11
I find that enjoyment is rather useful for me all things considered. Really when you think about it, it does give me some enjoyment and helps keep me insane. I think that knowledge books can be fun but they can also be dry and mechanical. Therefore, it can kill your interest. Thank you for your response. It is much appreciated and it contributed to the topic well. Have a nice day and thanks.
@sender621 (14893)
• United States
29 Dec 10
No matter how hard you may try, you can not make another person enjoy what you do about reading. You can show someone what reading and books mean to you. Still, it is up to their own hearts and judgments what they will feel about reading.
@megamatt (14291)
• United States
30 Dec 10
Very well say. It is just like with anything in life. If reading is not something that they will enjoy, then they just will not enjoy me. It does sadden me but that fact is very true. Still any attempts to force it will lead to half hearted attempts to like it but failure at best and utter hatred at worst. Thank you for your response. It is much appreciated and it contributed to the topic well. Have a nice day and thanks.
@Catana (735)
• United States
29 Dec 10
If children grow up in a household where they don't see adults reading regularly, and where there are few or no books, the chances are that being forced to read a few books in school isn't going to do anything to make them enjoy reading. And that's even truer if they've grown up spending most of their free time watching TV or playing computer games. Teachers would probably do better taking the time to actually read to the students. When I was young, most of the teachers would take at least half an hour a day and read to us. My favorite time of day in school when I got to find out what came next in the book. My parents also had a large library and I always had plenty of books. Children learn more from what's around them than by attempts to add a little bit of a good thing to their lives.
1 person likes this
@megamatt (14291)
• United States
29 Dec 10
I remember my teachers, well some of them at least, reading to us. It really did strike a cord with me at the right age in many ways. Plus it is a nice break from the intense learning and the sometimes rather boring educational process. Thank you for your response. It is much appreciated and it contributed to the topic well. Have a nice day and thanks.
1 person likes this
@commonground (367)
• United States
29 Dec 10
I always loved to read, even as a small child. My mother loved to read, as did my older brother and sister. My father and his brothers all loved reading. I guess I just thought of it as something that you were born with. Or maybe because it was all around me I just naturally took it up too.
I don't think you can make a child like reading if the seed is not already planted in them. You may force them to read but you may not force them to like it. Sometimes they might grow to enjoy it once they are older, when the choice is all theirs. They may rebel against it when it is required of them but later find they like it when they choose it.
1 person likes this
@megamatt (14291)
• United States
30 Dec 10
Indeed, there has to be a love of reading planted at an earlier enough age. You can shove the book in their hand, but once they are no longer in the position to be forced, they will not be able to enjoy reading. A lot of people dislike reading. I think that is great when people love to read as a child. I was like that from as long as I can remember. Thank you for your response. It is much appreciated and it contributed to the topic well. Have a nice day and thanks.
@leefox7 (4)
• India
29 Dec 10
I hated reading during my school/college days.
But one day i came across a book on a famous individual in history, and i could not stop reading it till the end.
What i mean to say is that every child loves some topic. So we should find out what the child loves and give him the books related to his liking. He is obviously read it from cover to cover, thus inculcating in him/her the beautiful habit of reading...! :)
@megamatt (14291)
• United States
30 Dec 10
You hit the nail right on the head. If someone finds a book of something that interest them, then they can get the ball rolling. They will read the book. They might be inspired to seek out even more books on the topic. Thus their love for reading will only increase and that can be a good thing. Thank you for your response. It is much appreciated and it contributed to the topic well. Have a nice day and thanks.
@Wanderlaugh (1622)
• Australia
30 Dec 10
I dread to think what kids are being given to read. The usual story is that they give them the dullest, most "acceptable" books and then wonder why kids are bored to tears, quite literally in some cases.
The fact is if it's not fun, it can't be interesting, and kids can't learn because they don't see why they should be inflicted with something boring simply because someone says so. The results are obvious. I've met talented kids who can barely stick a sentence together. Natural reading has to start with something the kids are genuinely interested in, then it's a logical thing to want to read. Doing it the other way is teaching them to read at gunpoint.
If people can't read, they're seriously handicapped in their careers and in their personal life, like finance, etc. This is a truly lousy situation, where people are turned off reading by lack of imagination and lack of "acceptable" choices. Dr. Seuss may not be Tolstoy, but he probably got more kids interested in reading than these horrific educational bores ever will.
@megamatt (14291)
• United States
30 Dec 10
You know, that's a good point. The dullest books and the acceptable books, that is really boring. Given that people want to censor books that are the least bit outside of the box, this is going to lead to a society that is emotionally and mentally stunted and fewer people who want to read. Dr. Seuss is how I started and it is really a great springboard because he made reading fun. Thank you for your response. It is much appreciated and it contributed to the topic well. Have a nice day and thanks.
@Neriz69 (1093)
• Philippines
30 Dec 10
It's true you can't force the love of reading. You have to start early on a child, exposing them on reading materials at a very young age, even before school age. Love for reading starts at home, you have to introduce reading little by little, buying them books with lots of pictures long before they can read. Exposure to these materials will enhance their love of it in the future. By the age of 3 or 4 the child's mind is pretty much made up for what it want and like so it's really going to be a problem forcing them to read when it's not their top of mind.
@megamatt (14291)
• United States
30 Dec 10
Reading to them at such a young age does help a great deal. They'll think that it is fun to do and after a while, they'll be reading on their own. Starting small and then throughout life. Plus, I think that it improves their grades in school a lot of the time, at least it did for me. Thank you for your response. It is much appreciated and it contributed to the topic well. Have a nice day and thanks.
@mysticmaggie (2498)
• United States
30 Dec 10
No, you can't force a love of reading, but you can encourage it. I began reading to my children during their first year of life. Whether they could understand the words didn't matter as much as the closeness we felt during reading time.
As they grew older, reading time continued until about age eight. By that time, they were reading simple books on their own and I made time to let them read to me, which they thoroughly enjoyed.
As the years passed, we continued to have reading time, moving from stories like Black Beauty and Flicka to the classics, with each of us taking turns.
Today, both children have a passion for reading - not because they were forced, but because they were shown the joy of it. They also look back on those times as special memories. Although neither of them have children of their own, they offer reading time to their neices. When the neices visit, that's one of the first things they ask - 'Will you read to us tonight?'. The older neice is now happy to have someone willing to listen while she reads one of her favorite stories.
@megamatt (14291)
• United States
30 Dec 10
Indeed there is a fine line between encouraging someone and forcing someone to do it. Therefore, we need to encourage. Children that have the passion are the ones that have discovered the joy. They discover the joy through different ways. And if they are read to at a young age, so much the better. Thank you for your response. It is much appreciated and it contributed to the topic well. Have a nice day and thanks.
@maezee (41988)
• United States
30 Dec 10
Even in High School teachers and admin. were really trying to push us to read. All of a sudden, in the beginning of high school, they created "Sustained Silent Reading" which is just a mandatory 30 minute "reading" time at school. You HAVE to be reading a book for LEISURE, can't read a magazine, etc - otherwise you'd get in trouble. I could never decide if it was a good or bad idea in high school. I was a really big 'crammer', as in, I would do a lot of my homework and reading DURING class so I wouldn't have to take it home and do it then. So it sucked that I couldn't read my school work, such as textbooks, books for class, and other reading material. But then again, I was really into reading in high school. I still kind of am, but in high school I LOVED reading books. I would have a new book every couple of days. So, for me, it wasn't terrible being forced to read (except when I wanted to get some school reading done and they wouldn't let me!) but at the same time, if I didn't like to read, I bet I would totally dislike reading more after trying to be forced to do it.
@megamatt (14291)
• United States
30 Dec 10
We had that sustained silent reading when I was in school. Half of the time, it was the teacher trying to fight with people to get them to read, which was kind of distracting to us that did read. I think that after about the third month, the teacher just gave up. I did love to read, so it was giving me a chance to read something. Thank you for your response it is much appreciated and it contributed to the topic well. Have a nice day and thanks.
@jenzai (388)
• Philippines
30 Dec 10
The love of reading is always been learned, by time. In that aspect parents had a vital role in guiding their children at a young age to develop this traits. Like bedtime stories is one of those, like parents should be a living example of reading. because young children tends to imitate their parents. I can attest to this because when i was 9 years old my parents love to read newspaper every morning, so i end up also reading it, but on the comic section, until it came in time that i love other reading materials.
@megamatt (14291)
• United States
30 Dec 10
Reading to your children before bed is always a good thing to do. I think that in the end, when I read before bed, that was what started my love. When I started to read I was doing it on my own. It was a great experience. Thank you for your response. It is much appreciated and it contributed to the topic well. Have a nice day and thanks.
@aeiou78 (3445)
• Malaysia
30 Dec 10
I am having the problem to read because of my impatient character.
I read a lot of books just because of the examination and the need in my work.
I shall fall asleep once I read my book.
ha! ha! ha!
I just pray so that my children will not be the same as their father.