Should you have an only child?

Canada
January 17, 2011 10:39pm CST
This is a question that has risen several times in my household. I was raised in a family with another sibling...an older sister. At 3 years apart, during our earlier years, we never fought too much, but didn't really ever hang out or spend too much time with one another. As we've both grown older, we definitely don't have the connection that we should. Now that I have a baby daughter, my wife and pretty much everyone else around here say that it's cruel not to have a second child. REALLY? If I feel that having one child is fine, and she's my world (that perfect little angel), why should I be forced to have a second child and make things double hectic and add stress, especially financially, not to mention that I get very little sleep working evening shifts as it is, but through in a second baby and I might not get any! What do you think? If one person doesn't want a second child, but his/her spouse does, who wins?
5 people like this
20 responses
@ybong007 (6643)
• Philippines
19 Jan 11
Don't let what others want dictate you on how to raise a family. If you think that you're better off with only one child then by all means adhere to it. I would have liked to have only one child but things didn't go as planned, thanks to the withdrawal method. It turned out that things would have been better if you only have to focus on one child against two or more, as you've said it's less stressful with everything. I would have settled for two but the wife got control of the womb so we ended up with three.
1 person likes this
@ybong007 (6643)
• Philippines
19 Jan 11
Yeah, some got sucked in and it turn out to be a disaster . But yes those three brats could be a pain in the neck but they're all adorable, they're a test to my patience and now I'm beginning to feel the test in my wallet. Better have a birth control that's proven since old school method don't work most of the time.
• Canada
20 Jan 11
Do both of you work full time or does your wife stay home to look after the kids?
• Canada
19 Jan 11
LOL Sounds like you got sucked in...but you probably love all 3 just as much as the other. That won't (fingers crossed) happen to me, 2 maybe, but 3's a crowd.
@eurekafemme (5876)
• Philippines
18 Jan 11
It is ok to have another child that is, if you can afford to. But, if you are financially limited then it is better to give it another thought. Though the physical and emotional sacrifices and considerations can be overcome, the thought of giving both children a comfortable life and everything best that they deserve is a really great factor to think of. Your spouse must try to understand if you do not have the confidence to give all kids the life they deserve. however, setting aside the financial consideration, it is very lonesome for the child to be growing up alone, a sibling, even one, would make a great difference in her social development. When another child is born, though, you need to accept her/him into your life just like the way you accepted your first born because treating them differently will create one to be feeling superior over another while another could be resenting the other. And, that's where the problem comes.
1 person likes this
• Canada
18 Jan 11
That's so true. I often wish my daughter had more friends her age that she could play with so that she could develop that social aspect. For me, it really is a money issue, as opposed to an emotional one. If I do decide to bring another life into this world, I would love him/her unconditionally. I know that as a fact in my heart, but I just don't feel that I'm ready for a second, and feel there is pressure being put on me already to have another. My daughter isn't even 1 yet....
1 person likes this
@GardenGerty (160949)
• United States
19 Jan 11
At one year old your daughter is not old enough to play "with" other children. Developmentally that happens at about three years old. If you are concerned that she have social experiences, go to the public library. Most of them have parent child story hours and other free experiences. I know of people who have had only children and the children did well. I have known of people who had their own softball team. It is up to a couple together. It is really no one else's business except for you and your wife. I had a neighbor pushing me to have another child when my son was barely one or not quite even. If you let your kids get a little older, having another child is somewhat easier. One of the pitfalls of having them as close as you guys are talking about is that the parents tend to treat the children as twins. Either they treat the first one like a baby or they expect the baby to act like the older child. It is not fair to either of them.
1 person likes this
• Canada
22 Jan 11
I could totally see the treatment of the 2 children as twins happening. I don't think that it would be a conscious decision on the parents part, but it would definitely have impacts, either negative or positive, in the developmental growth of each child. The younger would be treated as more of a grown baby and the older one would be treated as a young baby. Really, it wouldn't be fair. Thanks for the great response.
1 person likes this
@thaMARKER (2503)
• Philippines
20 Jan 11
i definitely want more than one kid. i would love to see them play together, take care of each other, hear a lot of giggles around the house, and laugh at their father's jokes. i want a merry family and am determined to have four kids when i reach 40+ years of age. i can't picture out how an child's life would be. i don't want it for sure. but maybe i'll put 3 years gap between my kids so i can enjoy and focus taking care of them while they're infant.
1 person likes this
• Canada
20 Jan 11
I can completely see your point on having a happy and merry household. Heck, I want that too, but I think you're right about leaving that gap of 3 or 4 years. Maybe after that length of time, I might change my mind and WANT another, but that will be left up to my feelings to decide. If I WANT...I'll HAVE, but if I'm PUSHED...I'll PUSH BACK. People shouldn't insist on others having a baby.
@thaMARKER (2503)
• Philippines
19 Jan 11
i definitely want more than one. i want to see them play together, take care of each other, and laugh at corny jokes by their father. hahaha.. that's gonna be super cute looking family i'm going to have. hopefully, i'll have 4 when i get to 40+ years old..
1 person likes this
• Canada
20 Jan 11
4?!?! Oh my....that's a little too many for my taste. lol I'm still balancing on the fence about 2, but if 2 were to happen for me, that's it! Maybe if I lived in a house and didn't have so many payments to make each month, worked at a higher paying job and was able to have my wife stay home 24/7 to look after them so that the daycare costs were low, but that's not happening any time soon.
@nancypoh (54)
• Malaysia
19 Jan 11
It need inform consent from both i think..having a 2nd or 3rd child is something that need us to put a lot of things into consideration. Financially, time spend with family, jobs, just like what you said. It's good for you because you have plan for your family. For me, all i need is a full readiness to have another child..
1 person likes this
• Canada
19 Jan 11
That's kind of it too. Plans. A person plans their life out one way when they are younger. Then, they meet the person they fall in love with and set out new plans. In those plans, sometimes a child is planned, and sometimes not. In our case, we planned that right after our wedding, we would try for a baby...I didn't get to "try" very much because I'm a straight shooter and hit the bull's eye on the 2nd shot. I think that if I do ever decide that I WANT another baby, I'm not going to "try" as hard. lol
1 person likes this
• China
19 Jan 11
I would like one child to give him/her everything as possible as I can.I haven't planned to get married these two years,but I will get full ready to have one baby after getting married. I have one older sister and one younger brother in my family,and we had a colorful childhood.Now,we have grown up,we care about our family and get surport from each other.We often quarreled in the past,but nowadays we love each one deeply.Even so ,I have to admit that we should learn to share to lighten our parents' financial burden,we can't ask for what we want at random.SO I want to give my only baby what he/she like,and give him/her the best education and life environment.Lots of people will say one child will let him/her be selfish,but I don't agree.It is up to the parents and the environment to guide our children growing in the proper way. I will insist on my standpoint and no one can change my mind.
1 person likes this
• Canada
19 Jan 11
That's the way my wife talked about only having one child before she got pregnant. Even during the first couple of months after Farrah was born, she still said she only wanted one, but then the "wolves" (family/friends) attacked and suddenly her mind has changed. Since the "wolves" claimed one, now they're chasing me. lol
@cher913 (25782)
• Canada
18 Jan 11
i think most only children are somewhat lonely. i know i sure was, in fact, when my 13 year old was younger, she said that i was a lonely child, not an only child! as for my hubby and i, we have two daughters. we didnt want to be outnumbered by kids but we wanted more than one.
1 person likes this
• Canada
18 Jan 11
Was it that comment from your 13 year old that made you decide to have another? Or had you already?
@srganesh (6340)
• India
18 Jan 11
Even though you haven't spent much time with your sister in your childhood, I think you can't refuse that emotional or mental support that there is a soul to back you anywhere at any time. That is what we have with brothers and sisters even if we grew a sibling rivalry towards them. So, have another child if you can!
• Canada
18 Jan 11
Very true. I'm not saying that my sister and I fight or NEVER talk, but definitely not as much as we should. Plus, sometimes when we do, it feels a little fake or one sided. It's very hard to explain, but it happens sometimes.
@sender621 (14893)
• United States
18 Jan 11
There's no shame in having an only child. you can still have a strong family relationship. The only thing missing would be siblings. an only child never has that experience. the love of a family would be there for an only child, but having a brother or sister to confide in could make all the difference in your life.
• Canada
18 Jan 11
Yeah, that's very true. I am starting to see the points of having another child and would love to see my daughter interact with a little brother or sister....I guess time will have to tell. Knowing my luck, I'll end up wanting another child and then my wife will change her mind. lol
@lady1993 (27224)
• Philippines
18 Jan 11
For me, having two children is really good. Since you have a best friend already - it would be nice though if their gap is only one or two years. Based from my observation, an only child is either spoiled or lonely. He or she will always look for someone to play with.. But it's your decision.
1 person likes this
• Canada
18 Jan 11
I'd be lying if I said we didn't spoil her, but she's only 1 so she deserves it. lol But with the lonely point, I could definitely see how that could end up happening. I don't want her to grow up depressed and lonely, but a lot of friends would help too.....sort of. You see, right now, I'm more on the fence about it. I don't NOT want another child, I just DO NOT want another NOW! It just seems that my family and friends (most with 2 or more kids), are always pushing it and have heavily influenced my wife, whom before she was pregnant, said that she only wanted one and one only. Shouldn't this be my wife and my decision and not have so many people pushing it. I work with a 52 year old guy with an 18 year old daughter, and he always says, "Those people that are pushing you to have another, just want you to be in the same position as they are...with 2 kids!" He's a very happy guy and his daughter is apparently very smart, pretty, and popular. Not lonely at all. Plus, he has also told me that he used to make her earn her allowance and privileges, and she's turned out great, with a nice and close relationship with mom and dad. It's these type of people that has kept me to my wife and my original decision to only have one child.
1 person likes this
@SIMPLYD (90721)
• Philippines
18 Jan 11
I guess, before having a second child you have to consider the earning capacity of the family. What's the use of having another child if you will not be able to provide good food, shelter and clothing much more time to take good care of her? Maybe you should talk to your wife and explain the situation well. She will understand.
1 person likes this
• Canada
18 Jan 11
Unfortunately, money isn't always the easiest thing to talk about. It usually stresses me out a bit, and my frustration with money issues makes her upset that I'm not happy. lol This was one of my New Year's Resolutions...to stop stressing so much about money issues. I'm just going to keep working as hard as I can (as I'm typing this at work lol) and eventually things will get paid off and some savings can start to accumulate.
1 person likes this
@fizzer (73)
• Pakistan
18 Jan 11
i think if you can not manage more than 1 child no one need to bother you to plan a child,it is totally upon the person who is looking after for that child,if you dont want a second baby then go to your spouse and try to convince them that they should agree with your idea.
1 person likes this
• Canada
18 Jan 11
I thought she was convinced for a while, but recently has changed her mind, which is fine, I'm not trying to control the way she thinks, but this subject is brought up once or twice every 2 or 3 days. This should be my decision, and I've told them that too, that they aren't the once that will have to wake every couple of hours or buy a new vehicle just so that I can fit another car seat in (have an Aveo and it's very tiny). My wife and I are the ones looking after the baby, for at least the next 18 years, so they need to back off. They just don't listen. I can understand why they would want another baby crawling around here, they are amazing and cute, but sooooo much work. I don't remember the last time I was actually able to just relax...physically and emotionally.
1 person likes this
@DLMiller (12)
• United States
18 Jan 11
Families should have a number of children equal to the total number of fists possessed by the adult population of the household. Have more children than fists and you won't be able to have any nice things in your house. Have more fists than children and someone will call Child Protective Services to correct your fist/child ratio. It's a fine balance and everyone in the home should be in agreement on how to keep it stable, or else.
• Canada
18 Jan 11
Hahaha...fist/child ratio. That's funny! In a disturbing kind of way. lol
@androbot (89)
• India
18 Jan 11
I am unmarried and just turned 22. In my opinion, the mother should be the one who decides how many children she wants. Most of us men have no brains when it comes to raising children, moreover, after the 'act', we are done with our part. It is the woman (mother) who has to go through all the pain and suffering to give birth to the child and even after that, the mother is the most involved in raising the child. If given a choice, I would prefer to have only one child but like I said, I'll let my girl decide what is best for her. If she wants more than one child, I won't meddle with her decision.
• Canada
18 Jan 11
Just because us guys are involved in the act of making a baby, which is great in it's own unique ways, I'd have to disagree that our part is over after that. You wait until you have your first baby...the experience is amazing, but it gets very exhausting after a while, especially working separate shifts, where you don't have the help from your spouse for the majority of the week. I'm so involved! I wanted and still want to do all that I can to ensure that my wife knows how much I appreciate how she went through the pregnancy and 7 HOURS straight of pushing. She's amazing and deserves to make that decision if she wants to go through it again, but why so soon? Why when we are the most financially strapped that we've ever been in our lives? She loves our daughter so much and doesn't want to see her grow up lonely, I get that. But, me being a guy, I look at the money situation, how much more work I'll need to do to pay for things, and where I can find that extra money.
1 person likes this
@cutepenguin (6431)
• Canada
18 Jan 11
This is tricky. But you should both want another child before you have a second...or it's not fair to either of your children. That being said, maybe you should wait a little while before making a final decision. It's an important decision.
• Canada
18 Jan 11
A mutual decision would definitely be the most fair thing to have, but that's easier said than done.
@shaggin (72234)
• United States
25 Jan 11
Its nice to have more then one child but I cant imagine someone saying that being an only child is a cruel thing to do to your child. I know quite a few people who were only children and they turned out just fine. Hopefully they will have lots of cousins and friends to play with and then they wont be missing out on having play mates. If anything all my sister and I did was fight until we were about 15.
@shaggin (72234)
• United States
26 Jan 11
My sister was a lot bigger then I was. I dont recall being able to wear all that many of her clothes. Especially in teen years no way she was a lot bigger then me. I have a daughter and a son so my son cannot wear my daughters hand me downs lol. I understand what you are saying there.
• Canada
25 Jan 11
I could definitely see 2 girls fighting, but at least you were probably able to share clothes...where as with brothers and sisters, the sharing of clothes is probably not the best thing for the kid's self-esteem. lol
@sid556 (30959)
• United States
1 Feb 11
Hi Pennie, It's not ok to have a 2nd child if even one of you doesn't want one. The spouse that wants another one should just accept that and enjoy the child you already have. Down the road, the spouse that doesn't want one may or may not change their mind but if one gives in just to please the spouse....there is no turning back. As for it not being fair to your child....that's just not true. You can ask a lot of only children and they would probably tell you that they would have loved to have a brother or sister. Then again if you ask many of those that do have siblings, they'd probably gladly donate their sibling to your child.
• Canada
3 Feb 11
There's definitely no turning back after the wife is pregnant a second time. lol You can really only keep them in there for 9 months...after that reality kicks in. I like what you said about the sibling donating theirs to us. I'm pretty sure that if someone asked my older sister that, she definitely would have given me up.
@katie0 (5203)
• Japan
18 Jan 11
on how economy is lately it's a wise decision, if the couple can't take more than one kid to college, maybe the best is having just one son/daughter
• Canada
18 Jan 11
Thanks, that's the way I look at it too. I don't want to feel even more financially unstable than I do right now. I know that it's a very difficult situation that really can't be "saved" for, but perhaps if I could get some bills paid down and loan/credit cards paid off, I would be in a different mind-set.
• Philippines
22 Jan 11
Hi! I really can relate to this discussion. I do have the same situation as yours having only our little girl. My husband is the only child in their family & i've seen how he as the only son experience the sadness of being alone especially if problems arise he is the one handling all of it. I also consider most of the times if our daughter would be in her dad's position, i think she would also become lonely in the future. There is no final decision in my part yet but my husband doesn't want one child. He says two is better. I don't pressure myself now and just think of it as another blessing. If another angel would come soon i'll thank God. I know what you feel right now, just think of the many blessings that will still come to your family with or without the second child. Relax and enjoy each other for a moment.
@mark98 (567)
• China
18 Jan 11
I've been married,but now no child. I intend to have only one child in the future.
• Canada
18 Jan 11
LOL That's what you think! Be prepared for the onslaught of people that will try to convince you otherwise. And believe me...there's a lot of them out there. Heck, I was talking to one of my friends that I haven't talked to for ages, and that was one of the first topics she brought up. Come on...give me a break, already. lol