Labrador vs Boxer
By kamarlow
@kamarlow (65)
United States
March 3, 2011 11:20pm CST
I have the opportunity to purchase a dog (have not had one in 3 years!!) and I am tossing the idea between the higher weight/height breeds like a Black Labrador and a Boxer. Both have the protective, playful, and "always seem young at heart" attitudes. The only difference I really see in them is their hair. Both their hair types gets stuck in things I didn't even know dog hair could get to, but it seems easier to hide boxer hair than lab hair. What are your thoughts on purchasing a dog based on their hair type? Is one better than the other in your eyes? Do I have this idea backwards maybe?
Thanks for your help!!
1 person likes this
6 responses
@inu1711 (5285)
• Romania
4 Mar 11
Hello Kamarlow and welcome to myLot!
I read the previous responses you got and all the comments, and I'd suggest you to think twice before bringing home a dog. If your husband is allergic there may be a bad chance that he won't be able to cope with the allergy having a dog around, and you might need to give the dog away. This must be heartbreaking for both you and the puppy.
Before bringing home the dog, try to have your husband live near a dog for some time, to see how he deals with the allergy. Maybe you have some friend or family member who owns a dog and you can "borrow" the dog for a while, to see if medecine help your husband or not.
I have some friends that decided to bring home a Hungarian Vijla despite the husband's allergy. They thought the medecine will help. But no, after a month they were forced to give up on the puppy. You can imagine how much they cried because of that. They had become attached to the dog and the love was mutual.
@inu1711 (5285)
• Romania
4 Mar 11
You said you don't want to consider other breed for a dog, but if you won't be able to own a Boxer or a Labrador, you must know that there are breeds that don't shed, like wire haired terriers. With proper grooming, they make good pets for people with allergies.
As far as I know short haired dogs like Boxers shed all over the year. I performed a search and here's what I found:
"Boxers shed moderately. But, you have usually more than one coat color to adjust your wardrobe to! Boxers usually shed more in fall, and in spring, but do lightly shed all year round." http://dogs.about.com/od/dogbreeds/a/Boxer_2.htm
Labradors are even worse at this:
"Labrador Retrievers shed much more than you might think – definitely on the high side of average. Just be ready for this." http://www.yourpurebredpuppy.com/reviews/labradorretrievers.html
1 person likes this
@vjohnson08 (71)
• United States
4 Mar 11
I have owned both breeds in the past. Their hair is certainly a huge difference! But from my experience their temperament is also vastly different. My experience is that a Labrador is more laid back than a boxer. The Boxers I have had were extremely hyper and required a lot of attention. That may not always be the case but it certainly my experience. Both were very intelligent and playful but the Boxer had the energy to play a lot longer!
Good luck on your search! I am a huge dog lover. I currently have 5, all rescue dogs and I wouldn't trade any of them for all the money in the world!
@kamarlow (65)
• United States
4 Mar 11
I have met both a calm and not so calm Lab and Boxer so this is where my WHAT DO I DO craziness comes from. I adore both breeds with my whole heart but due to allergy sensitivities my husband has, we believe just one dog is all he will be able to handle with how much medicine he will already have to take. Now do you believe the more hands on one has with either breed the better, or is it just their genetics that take over to an extent with their behavior?
@innocents_lost (1026)
• Canada
4 Mar 11
if allergies are an issue I would consider a breed that dosn't shed such as a poodle, or poodle cross or a Portuguese water dog both of which are extramly smart dogs. although i do know someone who is allergic to dogs extreamly and yet a boxer does not bother them nearly as much as any other shedding breed
@mermaidivy (15394)
• United States
4 Mar 11
I have a Labrador and the reason why we picked it is because we wanted a big, kid friendly dog and he is very much like that but if you are picking a dog based on the hair type... you might want to think about it, I'm telling you that my yellow labrador sheds like CRAZY throught out the year pretty much, of course, spring and fall are the worst, although he has short hair, it is EVERYWHERE; when he shakes...hair flies. I have to vacuum everyday to keep the house look somewhat not hairy. I was suprised that he sheds even more than my long hair colie that I had before. I don't know about Boxer though, I have never had one.
@timhinyy (1653)
• United States
5 Mar 11
I have not had the pleasure of owning either of those types of dogs, but my sister had two of the lightly colored labrador retrievers and they were very friendly and maybe a bit too friendly at times as they really like to jump up when they hadn't seen you for a while and they can be quite heavy when fully grown and they seem to get their hair on everything.
Her dogs seems to like to bark at every noise too especially late at night when everyone was sleeping that could be a bit annoying, but overall they are really good dogs and very loveable just make a bit of a mess with their hair everywhere, but you won't find a friendlier breed then that one not sure what one of them cost now, but I'm sure it is not cheap.
@innocents_lost (1026)
• Canada
4 Mar 11
coat is something you should consider when picking out a breed but also health concerns, energy levels (labs have higher energy levels), life expectancy, feeding requirements (as both these breeds are prone to bloat)how much time you can allot to training everyday or will you go to training classes as labs are one of the breeds of dogs most likley to bite and this is mainly from lack of training on the owners behalf
@innocents_lost (1026)
• Canada
4 Mar 11
a boxer would require the very minimal of a puppy training class for training and at least some work done at home as well. heart disease is common in labs as well as cancer and hip displasia is common in both labs and boxers
@kamarlow (65)
• United States
4 Mar 11
it is pretty crappy what these dogs can be struck with health wise and the idea of having all that happen to someone (the dog) I love makes me feel useless because when it comes to it, only part of what you do helps, never all of it. So it comes down to a boxer I believe.
Thanks for your help.