there's things in collective bargaining...

United States
March 12, 2011 9:17am CST
There's things in collective bargaining that have to go, not the bargaining rights, but bullying rights, Scott Walker's been in Milwaukee where it's been a mess of abuse for a long time, causing hardship to the people of Milwaukee, including, the schools.. - Are you able to listen concerning political debates, or are you one prone to run with the mob?
4 people like this
9 responses
@debrakcarey (19887)
• United States
12 Mar 11
I just came from a discussion where it was said the republicans who were voted in this past year haven't kept their promise to cut spending. Yet when they do, as in Wisconsin, people go to the streets and protest. Union thugs send emails threatening the very lives of the republicans who are trying to preserve jobs by cutting spending on inflated benefits. What do the liberals really want? That is the question that comes to my mind. Blast them for NOT cutting spending, riot if they try. You're right, they're just a bunch of bullys.
3 people like this
@sam3m1 (190)
• United States
13 Mar 11
the wisconsin gop started their spending cuts by giving large corporations a $113 M tax cut. then declared a fiscal crisis and a plan to resolve it by breaking unions in the state. the unions agreed to the fiscal demands of the governor, but were turned down. in terms of salaries, eg. the average teacher, i believe earns $54K per year, higher than the median salary in the state. but i'm sure it's not higher than the median salary for jobs requiring a master's degree and continuing education after that. the benefits, as in any job, are part of the salary package. the gop has stated clearly that the object here and in as many states as possible, is to cripple the democratic party's support. why so many people have bought into policies which are against their own interests are a mystery to me. teachers' unions typically are targeted by cost cutters and maybe rightly so, but why not demand that the cost cutting be even handed?
@debrakcarey (19887)
• United States
14 Mar 11
I've had this discussion many times in the last week. So I will say no more to you, except that I've had issues that go a long way back with the dirty dealings of the unions. They are NOT for the working man and they have a very liberal and damaging influence on politics. They're out for political power and have a liberal agenda. You want to be a part of that, it's your choice. I'm sick of hearing 'the against your own best interests' slogan..propaganda, I could puke. Sorry, I don't know you and you're getting the frustration of a weeks worth of talking to union drones. I apologize.
1 person likes this
• Pilot Mountain, North Carolina
15 Mar 11
@sam-your argument about the salary of teachers is pretty flawed if you take the time to look at it. For one thing, tell the teachers in North Carolina or many other states that they will ONLY be making $54K/year! They sure wouldn't be complaining. The cost of living in many of the places in North Carolina (where I live) and Wisconsin are not that different yet teachers in Wisconsin are making around $20K/year more than teachers here. Another thing you mention is the cost of the teacher's education. Last time I checked, it's not a requirement to have a Master's degree to teach Kindergarten through 12th grade...and it's not even required in some cases to teach at a Community College. Sure the Master's degree increases your opportunities and salaries, but it's not required like you assume. I'm all for rewarding teachers because they have an incredibly hard and important job, but the things you said were just incorrect. As far as your comments about the GOP in Wisconsin. I understand that you will never (and most Democrats included) admit that the GOP has done anything right or that you agree with what they have done, but you need to get over it already! How much have you complained about the Democrats and the current administration for the unbelievable amount of spending since coming in office? I understand that we weren't in the best position when Obama came into office and that has been argued into the ground, but the fact is this: Obama has done NOTHING to help the situation! When are you going to complain about that? The GOP in Wisconsin (and many of them from throughout the country) have kept their promises to go to extreme lengths to cut spending and deal with the financial mess we are in, but the people standing up complaining about this are the Democrats! It's sickening really!
1 person likes this
• United States
12 Mar 11
Collective bargaining for teachers is the equivilat of "No Teacher Left Behind" It makes it hard for Good teachers to advance and get raises while allowing poor teacher to coast and gain benifits without working for it. As soon as any employee is no longer compensated on individual merit, but rather lumped in with a collective mob, there is no longer an incentive for excellence which is why our kids are getting dumber.
3 people like this
• United States
18 Mar 11
Actually they've been throwing money at the teachers and education for ages now, and many kids are graduating for a loong time now not even knowing how to read. Maybe because they ae too busy teaching some for of [political correctness/ political bias.
@KrauseHome (36447)
• United States
15 Mar 11
When it comes to Political debates I try to listen in and figure out what is really going on there instead of running with the mob and assuming something when I do not really know all of the facts. I know Wisconsin is having a lot of issues when it comes to schools, etc. but they are not the only one. Here in WA state even they keep on cutting back on the funding available for schools, and laying off teachers and closing more schools. It is getting sad everywhere.
1 person likes this
• United States
13 Mar 11
I believe Walker is doing what he said he would do when he was campaigning. I hope he is successful in turning around the poor economy in Wisconsin.
2 people like this
@Rollo1 (16679)
• Boston, Massachusetts
13 Mar 11
Too often people decide important issues based on nothing but emotion. That is the case with much of what is going on in Wisconsin. There are too many people willing to feel that compassion dictates that they side with the unions. Others are repelled by the mob atmosphere and the thuggish behavior and side with the Governor. The truth is that the only way to decide the best course is through facts and logic. It may appear a good thing to put more money into education, after all, that has to lead to better teachers and schools... right? Well, it may seem counter-intuitive but the much increased spending on education since the creation of the Department of Education at the federal level, but test scores have not shown one iota of improvement. They have proved that money does not necessarily equal better education. The rights we all enjoy are spelled out in the Constitution. When it comes to our labor, we are free to sell it for what price we deem it worth. There is no Constitutional right to demand more for our labor than anyone is willing to pay or even to demand more than they have. There is no Constitutional right to collective bargaining. We are a nation of individuals with individual rights, not a nation of labor collectives. I believe in boiling the debate down to the most basic question - does the government owe any group of citizens a "right" to collective bargaining? I see no evidence of this in the Constitution.
2 people like this
@mattic (282)
• United States
13 Mar 11
It is not really "collective bargaining" when the organization is a government enforced monopoly supplying a government required service. Both aspects violate the very heart of liberty. Government employee unions are simply statist tyranny.
2 people like this
@ParaTed2k (22940)
• Sheboygan, Wisconsin
14 Mar 11
When it comes to Wisconsin school boards and local government's incestuous relationship with the public sector unions, there is all sorts of collective, but very little bargaining. The recent clamoring to make sweetheart deals with the unions before Walker's budget repair bill is living proof. The local government officials and school boards are bought and paid for my the unions. There is nothing honest about it.
1 person likes this
@dragon54u (31634)
• United States
12 Mar 11
I don't tend to go along with what anyone says until I do my own research. Those mobs don't even understand the bill that was put together and signed into law, they just say they've lost all their "rights". A job is not a right and does not belong to the worker but to the employer. If they don't like that job, find another. I do agree with treating workers decently and having decent wages but when the workers run roughshod over the employer and put him out of business, that hurts everyone. And the WI budget will be helped. Many unions have made concessions so that workers can keep their jobs and the business continue to prosper. Those are good unions, protecting workers and jobs. But some don't care about anything but dues in their coffers that they can use to wield political influence.
1 person likes this
@kenzie45230 (3560)
• United States
12 Mar 11
I have always listened to all sides and have done my own research on topics. I don't understand people who merely listen to media or to politicians or to union bosses without researching and thinking for themselves.
1 person likes this