A small little doubt

@SViswan (12051)
India
March 17, 2011 4:56am CST
10 year old son : Mom, I've been reading my Biology book Mom(very pleased) : Good Son : I have a small little doubt Mom : Yeah? Son : I know that how fertilization takes place and the little foetus is formed. But...sperms are in the male and the egg is in the female. WHERE do they meet to fertilize?????? This mom's always been very honest with her answers but this questions stumps her. HELP!!
11 people like this
19 responses
@dpk262006 (58676)
• Delhi, India
17 Mar 11
Hi! This question can stump smartest of the parents Sandhya . You (you means concerned Mom) can simply tell him that as he would grow older he will automatically come to know or alternatively you can tell him that it could be told to him at a later stage.
1 person likes this
@SViswan (12051)
• India
19 Mar 11
Oh no!! 'Automatically' would probably force him to ask his friends or find other sources. As you know, I've been very honest with him so far. Even when he was around 5 and asked how a baby GETS into amma's tummy, I told him that when parents love each other and then daddy does 'magic' to amma....it happens. I also had to tell him that it doesn't always happen that way because God decided who gets a baby (we had a couple of friends who hadn't had babies after years of being married). We had a talk and he was convinced with all that. Now he's gone the next step. The 'magic' talk is not going to work on a 10 year old.
@SViswan (12051)
• India
22 Mar 11
lol....Deepak...you've crossed this stage. You don't have to solve this problem, do you? :p
@dpk262006 (58676)
• Delhi, India
19 Mar 11
I agree with your explanations to him and all your points, which you used earlier when he was five. I cannot think of an idea off hand. If you come to know how to solve this dalmia, please let me know ....... Lol!
@buenavida (9984)
• Sweden
23 Mar 11
Perhaps you could start with how the animals do it. Fishes do the fertilization outside the body so it is easy to understand. Then go over to how chickens get fertilized. An egg would not produce a chicken - no matter how long you keep it warm, without the rooster giving chicken seeds to the hen. After explaining this, maybe it is easier to go to talking about the human act. You can describe it as an act of love between a mum and dad. The best thing is to show some pictures of the human anatomy - then you don´t need to describe everything with words. And you don´t need to explain more than the child asks as he may not be ready to know all details. The important thing is that the knowledge comes from a responible adult, and not from playmates who can give a wrong picture of the whole thing. Why not repeat that the whole thing is a miracle, and none of us would exist if God had not created us in such a wonderful way so that we can produce children.
@buenavida (9984)
• Sweden
24 Mar 11
Try not to worry in advance, kids are smart, and if you show some good pedagogical pictures and explain a bit, he may get it and if you have a good book, he may read himself. A book about medicine may have good pictures too. He is now at the right age to learn the moral principles and you may find the following article helpful. http://www.watchtower.org/e/20040722a/article_01.htm There are more good articles on the site written for young people, just make a search on the home page.
@SViswan (12051)
• India
23 Mar 11
Yes, Deepak...I need to brace myself for that! No other choice!
1 person likes this
@dpk262006 (58676)
• Delhi, India
23 Mar 11
if you tell about the 'act' .........you are likely to face endless questions ........
• Canada
19 Mar 11
If your son is 10 years old and is studying biology, his book describes the human body and he knows the differences between male and female body parts. You can explain to him in a very factual way, using terms he already knows. We, as adults, sexualize the discussion in our minds and that is what makes it harder to speak to our children. There doesn't have to be anything graphic in what you say. As others have suggested, you might get a book that is specific to this discussion and allow that to guide your conversation. Your son is just looking to you for information... there is nothing sordid to what he is asking. I discussed with my first daughter, at age 9, menstruation to pregnancy and birth control and everything in between. Her younger sister was 6 at that time and her friend's mother was pregnant. She came home and asked me the "where do babies come from" question so, only weeks after the talk with her sister, I did it all again with the 6 year old :) She was actually very interested, even asked intelligent questions, and we got through it. Letting children know that we can be their source of factual and correct information is so important because, as they age, they are going to hear a lot of incorrect things from many sources. I'd encourage you to be honest and open with your son and not make up any stories or use juvenile words. At 10, he's old enough for a basic, frank conversation :) Good luck to you... I know it's uncomfortable but you can do it!
1 person likes this
@SViswan (12051)
• India
23 Mar 11
That's the same impression that my son has of me. But suddenly I feel all funny about this 'little' thing. It's probably because of the gender and that he is growing up too. I'm sure my husband wouldn't take it upon himself to explain this (though he is the one who is handling the biology subject - our son is being homeschooled). I'll just need to brace myself and have a talk *sigh*...hope he doesn't ask me again before I am ready.
1 person likes this
• Canada
22 Mar 11
LOL you may be right, Sviswan, about getting your husband involved! Men seem to avoid those discussions. I never had a son, only daughters, but I know in some of my friends' families, the mothers have the talk with the girls and the fathers have the talk with the boys. I guess maybe it's easier for some children to ask questions of their same-gender parent. At the time I had those talks with my daughters, I was a single mother... separated from and divorcing their father. So, I had no one to do it for me but I did get through it. It's so funny because, if you were to speak to my daughters today (they are 17 and 20, still living at home and pursuing their educations), they will tell you - "Be sure you really want to know the answer before asking Mom a question... because she is definitely going to give you the answer!" I like it, though, that they realize I will be honest. We have good, open conversations about many things and I find it so beneficial.
@Aussies2007 (5336)
• Australia
17 Mar 11
Serve you right for teaching biology to a 10 year old. lol Sort of like putting the egg before the chicken. lol And yes, the chicken came first, just like Adam and Eve did. lol
1 person likes this
@alottodo (3056)
• Australia
18 Mar 11
Hey Aussies...the egg came first! without egg? no chicken!
• Australia
18 Mar 11
So where did the egg came from? lol
@SViswan (12051)
• India
18 Mar 11
I didn't teach him that chapter in Biology!! We don't have any books here that are X-rated...this was from a Biology text book that he read.
@SHAMRACK (8576)
• India
5 May 11
Dear friend, Dear son you can learn that in coming class, now just score high marks in this class to learn further........ I hope the answers would be able to get much better in other biology books, which could be got from better library, may be the Son could given a book with better elaboration.
@SViswan (12051)
• India
5 May 11
ha ha..thanks Shamrack. He doesn't go to school. He is homeschooled and is some of the subjects he is on a higher level than his peers. He was topping his class when he was at school...but I guess that wasn't enough for him:) I don't know how much I want to elaborate on that point because 'the act' is the only thing left for him to understand.
@SViswan (12051)
• India
8 May 11
Thank you...will pass on your congratulations. He doesn't go to school anymore. He is musically talented and we want him to focus on that...not just as a hobby class. Academics we handle at home. I don't know if any book will help him unless it explains things explicitly. I'm just worried about him knowing at age 10. The exact question he asked me was 'Sperms are found in males and the eggs in the females. The sperms need to meet the egg to fertilize. HOW does it get there!'
@SHAMRACK (8576)
• India
5 May 11
Can those elaborations in books could help him, anyhow it is nice to know he a topper. Wish him my congratulations.....
@sid556 (30960)
• United States
18 Mar 11
Hi SViswan, Just tell him the truth. He is plenty old enough to know. My girls all knew much younger than that. The more honest you are with him, the less he is going to be seeking answers from others who might give him the wrong answers.
1 person likes this
@SViswan (12051)
• India
22 Mar 11
Yes, I'm glad that he is coming to me...I've always told him he can and he comes to me even when he knows he will get into trouble for it. I'll have to check out the library for a book that explains it in an age appropriate way...and I'm sure to have a lot more questions coming my way after that *sigh*
@sid556 (30960)
• United States
19 Mar 11
Yes, I know it is. They actually have some pretty good books that explain it all pretty simple for kids. Maybe you could get one out from the library and let him read it and tell him that you are there for him if he has questions. It's good that he is coming to you for answers so even if you are uncomfortable, you don't want him to pick up on that.
@gabs8513 (48686)
• United Kingdom
19 Mar 11
Lol that is where the birds and bees come in I guess I guess you would have to explain it as best as you can really I can't even remember how I explained it to mine lol
1 person likes this
@SViswan (12051)
• India
22 Mar 11
Yes...no other way around it I guess *sigh*
@drannhh (15219)
• United States
24 Mar 11
I read a book on advice for parents that had a good answer to this one. The author explained that when kids ask that, then the parents usually get uptight and if they are trying to be honest they make a mistake in being too detailed. The author went on to say that children really do not want or need to know a complete answer to that question - it is more just attention they are seeking. So it is ok to just say something like "They meet near the place where the Mom and Dad are married!" Don't we wish...lol.
1 person likes this
@SViswan (12051)
• India
1 Apr 11
lol...I'll probably have to make do with that answer for now. But I do think that he's looking for more information. I think he has an inkling but he isn't sure and I'm glad he is asking me and not his friends. His question is a result of reading too much biology. The exact thing he asked is....'Mom...fertilization occurs when the sperm meets the egg....but the egg is found in the female and sperms in the male....how exactly do they meet?'
@barehugs (8973)
• Canada
17 Mar 11
Don't believe for one minute that your son doesn't already know the answer to that question. He just wants to hear it from his Mom. Its up to you to answer his question truthfully because if you don't tell the truth, he will never forget the lie you told. Kids are always smarter (quicker) than their parents realize. Yes he has already heard the answer and talked extensively about it with his school buddys. I should know, I helped raise 4 boys!
1 person likes this
@nikramos (698)
• Philippines
18 Mar 11
i believe so too. it can be really surprising that my 10 year old brother has too much malice to know about these stuff. and i really wonder where, how has he gotten such information?
@Sreekala (34312)
• India
18 Mar 11
Hi SV, Lol, you trapped here? I faced the same question from my five year old son when I was pregnant with my second son (my elder son was five years old that time). He asked differently, how the baby gets into your womb. I said God put the baby into my womb, else what I can say to a five year old. Then how you deal with it dear?
@SViswan (12051)
• India
19 Mar 11
When he was 5 and we were planning our second child...we discussed a lot of things with him (make that 'I'...my husband always stayed away from awkward topics). At the time, he also knew that he was a normal deliver and that he 'jumped' out. He asked me HOW the baby got inside my stomach and also why some people didn't get babies soon after they are married(we had a few friends who didn't have kids). I told him that when daddy and mommy love each other...daddy does 'magic' to mummy and if it works, God decides that a baby comes to mummy's tummy and God also decides who it is going to be. He has been quite satisfied with this answer till he started studying biology.
@paula27661 (15811)
• Australia
17 Mar 11
Lol! I’ve been through this very recently when my nine year old girl asked me about periods. I knew I had to tell her the truth so I took an age appropriate book about the subject out of the library, let her read it and made myself available for questions which she had plenty of! I kept it simple and answered everything the way she would understand. She thanked me for the information and never questioned me about the ‘birds and the bees’ again!
1 person likes this
@SViswan (12051)
• India
18 Mar 11
Good for you! My son's known the general idea of 'birds and bees' for a few years now...the REAL thing is what he wants to know!
1 person likes this
@adnileb (5276)
• Philippines
17 Mar 11
LOL.. VERY CURIOUS SON.. I think it will be okay if you will explain him the details (um, not actually the FULL details. LOL) Anyways, he's already 10 and he will learn it soon.. As lilaclady said, better to learn it from you than school grounds or any other people. =)
1 person likes this
@SViswan (12051)
• India
19 Mar 11
Well, there's no school ground (he is homeschooled). He knows the other details. I've always been honest with him. It's the 'act' that I'm uncomfortable telling him about. I don't want him going 'ewwww' either.
@liumirror (138)
• China
17 Mar 11
He is ten years old, maybe can tell him something about how a baby come to the world. In my country ,and in my time ,people think it is shame to tell the thing so that I can't understood it until I was 20,it really made me shame
1 person likes this
@SViswan (12051)
• India
18 Mar 11
He knows all the other technical part....he just wants to know HOW and WHERE the sperm and egg meet. I think he knows WHERE...he is confused how the sperm gets there!
@annapplez (208)
• Australia
18 Mar 11
Oh my gosh, I am so glad that this discussion is still a while away for me. My son is only two and my daughter only a few months, so I think I will be reading these answers very carefully and try to remember them for when the time comes. I'm dreading it already lol.
1 person likes this
@SViswan (12051)
• India
19 Mar 11
EAch child is different and the ages they ask these questions are different. My older son started asking at around age 4...and my younger one at 4 now is not bothered at all. A few of the responses have been helpful.You can read them:)
@lilaclady (28207)
• Australia
17 Mar 11
hahaha, it must be hard when this time comes along, I always think a nice tasteful book and sit down and talk about it and not just leave the book around hoping it will be picked and read...better to hear the truth from Mum than hear it the school ground like I did..
@CatsandDogs (13963)
• United States
1 Apr 11
Sweetie, it's time for that talk with your son. If you don't tell him, he'll find out from his friends eventually and you don't want that to happen. He needs to hear it from either you or his dad or even both of you to sit down with him and explain how it all works. He's old enough to be told about the birds and the bees. Good luck!
1 person likes this
@alottodo (3056)
• Australia
18 Mar 11
It is a difficult question I agree! but at the same time you don't want to lie to your young son it's important for him to trust you...so may be you can say...sperm and egg meet when mum's and dad's make love, he may ask about the love making issue...and you can say...for today you got your answer...in another year or so when you are more mature I may be able to answer your question in more details...but for today? we will leave it at that.
1 person likes this
@voldrox (7191)
• India
18 Mar 11
Hello SViswan, That depends upon how much your son already knows. He might as well have a few more doubts if he watches more of hollywood movies. Anyways, assuming he doesn't know much, I would have told him he doesn't need a PhD in biology right now, he had better concentrate on physics..!
1 person likes this
@edb225112 (124)
• United States
17 Mar 11
If your son is asking the question, he needs an honest answer. The question is just how much information does he need right now. That is what you will need to determine. Even a 5 year old can know that a baby develops inside the mother. That could be all he really needs to know. Never avoid the truth with a child. Just don't bombard them with all the details when all they need to know is the simple basic facts.