My daughter fears being left alone even for 5 minutes!

@devijay78 (1573)
India
March 23, 2011 12:43pm CST
My daughter(3 1/2 years old) has been like that since birth. She would never be alone and if left alone, god help me. She always wants me to be beside her or at least in her view. Or if I am in the kitchen doing my work, she would come once in a while and take a look at what I am doing or where I am and then go back to what she was doing. But taking a shower or even using the loo when only both of us are at home, is a real agony! I still keep my bath door slightly open so that she knows that mommy is inside and has not gone somewhere else. And I know for sure she would be there within five minutes of me going in. I would have to keep talking to her and she would be there outside the bath door listening to my voice or chatting with me. What do I do? I am so concerned. Is this normal in all kids or only mine is like that? When she was smaller, she used to cry and bring the whole house down and would keep banging on the bath door till I opened and let her in. But now, she wants reassurance that I am still there and have not gone anywhere. Will it become better when she grows? Any other parent experiencing this?
4 people like this
11 responses
@jaiho2009 (39141)
• Philippines
23 Mar 11
hello devijay, None of my kids ever act like that. But i knew a friend who has same problem like yours. But don't worry,when her daughter reached 4,she enrolled the little girl in a pre-school,but still the girl doesn't want her mom to leave. So,my friend stays outside the room and her daughter keep checking on her every now and then. This goes on for the whole school year. On the second year of school,the girl started to have confidence,but still keep an eye with her mother. But,it gives my friend some free time,when her daughter starts enjoying school. When her daughter is busy with coloring books and drawing objects,animals etc,she sometimes forget her mom. Before the school year end,she can leave her daughter at school and fetch her after class hour. Just give your daughter time to adjust. i am sure she will slowly be confident with you on her side. Try to give her things or works to keep her busy and would attract her interests.
@devijay78 (1573)
• India
23 Mar 11
Hi jaiho. My daughter started playschool when she was one year eleven months old and she cried till the last day of that year to leave me and go to school. This continued even in the next year but only for two or three months. Still she needs reassurance that I will sit outside her school and wait for her till she comes, then only does she go inside her class room. She seems to be such a timid child and I do not know how to motivate her to be on her own and not be afraid. I do not even chide her regarding this knowing what she must be going through. I do give her ample time and am still giving in to her demands sometimes. I give her some colouring work to do or some interesting thing to do and then go into the bath, but in less than five minutes she is there calling out to me through the door and stays in the room where the bath is. Hope she does grow out of this fear. Thanks for the suggestion.
1 person likes this
@jaiho2009 (39141)
• Philippines
23 Mar 11
Kids differ from each other dear. Don't worry ,i am sure your little one will grow up and changed. She will soon grow up a little lady,and i am sure you will be missing those days when she's like a scared kitten clinging to your skirt My kids are now grown ups and i do missed those days when they are babies/toddlers whom i can cuddle and love it seeing them giggle. I wonder where those days gone/passed by... have a great day
@devijay78 (1573)
• India
25 Mar 11
I do miss the days when she would allow me to cuddle her. Now she has grown so much that cuddling, kissing and hugging is only once or twice a day. And that too, only for about 2 to 3 seconds. No more than that. She immediately wriggles away to run and play or just plain get away from the place! But i do have to stay within her sight otherwise, all hell would break loose. I know I would miss her clinging to me when she does grow up.
• India
30 Mar 11
It is normal devijay My three years young grand daughter behaves exactly similar manner, her mom keeps the bathroom door little open.. Thanks for sharing in details Cheers. BE HAPPY ALWAYS. Professor ‘Bhuwan’. .
@devijay78 (1573)
• India
31 Mar 11
I know that now Professor. She has improved in the past few years. But she still feels a little insecure and is scared of the dark too. Now I do know that she will be okay when she grows up.
@kalav56 (11464)
• India
24 Mar 11
You say she is 3and a half years old. Talk to her daily about this. Tell her that she is a big girl, soon she is going to be responsible for her baby brother or sister and she has to start practicing from now on. When you go to bathe, tell her beforehand that you are going in and give her a game to play, a target . Tell her you will be out within the short time she finishes the game and keep your word. Keep singing loudly to reinforce ehr.She is very small but now she will start understanding things. She would also be going to school; is it not? Just talk to her everyday about this and she will be ok.. I don’t think it is cause for concern. She has been with you throughout the day and also at night and is bound to feel insecure.
@devijay78 (1573)
• India
25 Mar 11
She has been going to school for the past two years kala. First playschool and now she is in Lower Nursery. But she still does not like to leave me and go to school. And if she is at home, I should always be with her. I cannot even talk to somebody over the phone when she is here. And I do give her work or things to play with and then go inside the bath but it is of no use. She brings that plaything too to the bath door. I just hope it does not develop into anything serious in later life.
@cream97 (29086)
• United States
25 Mar 11
Hi. devijay78. I have an three year old daughter. She will be four in June. And she can be away from me for a while. When I am taking an shower if she is awake she will want to come into the bathroom with me. And my other kids were like this too, when they were younger. I had to break them out of this too. My kids will all get upset with each other, like your daughter is doing with you. My youngest daughter wants to come into her brother's bedroom. She loves falling asleep in there now. When my other daughter was four years old, she would holler and scream to be let into her brother's bedroom. My youngest daughter does the same thing now too. It is really stressful, they all can't be away from each other for a minute! My son is nine years old and sometimes he wants his bedroom to himself to play and to relax in, but his sister's want to come into his room with him. If they can't get into his room, they will holler and scream. They also will even bang on the door really loudly. Or my daughter will hit the wall. It is terrible! My kids still love being under me, but I have to tell them that they can't always come into the same room that I am in all of the time. I need my space, mommy needs her space. When my husband is home, I will tell him to come and get our daughter if she is crying. Two weeks ago, my youngest daughter was banging on the bathroom door. She was screaming because she wanted to come in while I was washing my hair. I told my husband to come and get her. I mean she was just hollering and going on. With me, my kids eventually our grew this attachment. It will take time, that is all that I can say. My oldest daughter is five years old, I can at least take a shower without her wanting to come into the bathroom. I know that she is learning to give mommy some personal space. So is my son. My youngest daughter is mostly the one that does not want anyone to have their space. She even wants to come into the bathroom when her sister or brother is taking a bath too. They usually want her out, but she refuse to leave. She will throw tantrums and cry like crazy. I believe that it will get better for you too. I can't really tell you what you should do, but I know that your daughter will eventually grow out of this strong attachment as you gets older. Take care.
@devijay78 (1573)
• India
26 Mar 11
Hi cream. It would have been so difficult for you to handle so many kids on your own especially when they are throwing tantrums. I really am thinking that my case might be better after all. Behaving like that with the mother is something I can understand. But even with brother and sister is troubling and it would be very difficult for the other kids too! Thanks for the support. I know from all the other responses as well that she will outgrow this habit of hers. And hugs to all your sweet kids too.
• United States
24 Mar 11
It really sounds like she`s getting better. She`s only 3 right? She should out grow this. She`ll get use to things. If it`s still like this a few years from now, you should really go see someone. But I`m sure it`s normal. I use to be really afraid of the dark for a while. Long while, but I got over it. I think..... JK!
@devijay78 (1573)
• India
25 Mar 11
She is getting better. She is almost four. When I see other kids of her age not being so clingy, it bothers me. But now reading all the responses, I guess it will be okay once she grows.
• Philippines
24 Mar 11
yeah, when she grows up she will overcome that fear. It's normal for kids or babies.
@devijay78 (1573)
• India
25 Mar 11
Hi. I know that now. She is the first grandchild in our family and my first born. So I was a bit concerned as I did not know much about babies and how they behave.
@cher913 (25782)
• Canada
23 Mar 11
it is normal but you have to start slowly seperating yourself from her. You have make it clear that you will be back to pick her up or whatever or that you are near by but that she needs to be away from you. even if she cries, we all have hard lessons to learn through life.
@devijay78 (1573)
• India
23 Mar 11
Hi cher. I know it is difficult for me as well as her. But she is so scared that I do not know what to do. I have started telling her that god stays by her side always and would not allow anything bad to happen to her. She is a little reassured by that but still is scared. And I am finding it heart wrenching to leave a scared kid like that.
@mermaidivy (15394)
• United States
23 Mar 11
My friend's daughter has the same issue, she siad the pediatrician said she is going through the fear of being seperated with the parents, she won't sleep in her own room and always want to sleep with her parents.
@devijay78 (1573)
• India
25 Mar 11
Hi mermaidivy. She does sleep with us in our room even though there is a spare room with her bed which she can use. And there was a time when she was seperated from her father. But she has been like that since birth and I do not understand how to get her rid of the fear and make her understand that we are not leaving her and going anywhere.
@junrapmian (2169)
• Philippines
24 Mar 11
Children especially babies love to cling to their parents more so to their mothers. They are still young and I think it's only normal because they are not yet familiar with their surrounding and they are only used to the company of their mother. I remember when my children were still young, I can't go to the bathroom all by myself, they will still go with me inside, and I just let them. I savour those times when my children wants me by their sides. Now that they are all grown ups, I can't even find them at home, they are all busy with work and their friends. It's lonely at home during the day, I miss the cries and tantrums of my little babies.
@devijay78 (1573)
• India
25 Mar 11
Hi junrapmian. I used to take a bath or go to the loo with my daughter in there with me. But now for the past 6 months or so, she does not throw so much tantrums. So it is ok if I just keep the bath door slightly open and keep talking to her. I know how you feel about your grown up children. I guess I will miss her clinging ways too after a few years.
• United States
24 Mar 11
It does sound like separation anxiety. Some kids actually have this fear and nothing really contributes to it outside of a bit of insecurity. My son went through something similar and I tried to make it where when he got home it was a very exciting time for the both of us. It took time but he slowly begin to realize that I was not going to leave him. I did several playdates with other kids so that he could socialize and play and not be so fearful of not having me constantly by his side. Mine to was in preschool but I felt the extra play dates helped.
@devijay78 (1573)
• India
25 Mar 11
Hi HWG. She is not as bad as she was earlier. When she was small she used to cry and scream and bang on the bath door till I let her in or I came out. Then I would have to hug her and pacify her and only after all that will she calm down. And this happened every day! But now she knows that I am inside and have not gone anywhere else, but still needs reassurance and I would have to keep talking from the bath. And she would not leave the room till I come out. She does have a lot of friends at school and a playmate in our neighbour's house. She does play with the other little girl but this behaviour does bother me. Judging from the responses, I guess she would become better as she grows.
• United States
24 Mar 11
i went thru the same thing with my son hes now three and now hes ok, it just depends who hes bein left with, he loves his grand parents and aunts i had to just break it by leaving and letting him realize that mommy cant be next to him 24/7. he cried for an hour and sat next to my mom and was ok for the rest of the day, it was harder on me i think than it was on him
@devijay78 (1573)
• India
25 Mar 11
Hi kahanuola. It is always harder on the parent than on the kid isn't it? Even as I type this reply, I keep thinking about her in the back of my mind and what she would be doing at school etc. She is okay when left with my parents but only for some time. She would never stay overnight with them or for a long time. She would start asking for me and slowly would start missing me badly. So I always make it a point to tell her that I will be back for her in some time and then only go anywhere. She knows when I do that, I will come back for her.