Looks like we are running out of good writers...
By Rapuncille
@Rapuncille (597)
Philippines
April 4, 2011 3:23am CST
i have noticed that most shows/telenovelas that are now aired in Philippine television are mostly just reruns of the previous telenovelas aired years back or tagalized (dubbed in tagalog)version of other foreign telenovelas (mostly korean and latin american). Some of those claiming to be original stories are mostly depicted from foreign movies and shows. they would normally just change some details of it but basically, the story is still not "original".
Could it be that we are running out of good writers that is why we are unable to produce quality shows nowadays??
1 person likes this
12 responses
@madp_071983 (228)
• Oman
4 Apr 11
To some extent, YES! Where have the good writers gone then? Oh, I find them abroad in search for greener pastures and brighter opportunities. This is what we call BRAIN DRAIN. However, I for one couldn't blame them for doing so because it is a practical outlook in life! =)
2 people like this
@Rapuncille (597)
• Philippines
4 Apr 11
It's sad we are losing the good ones. Our economy is taking its toll even in the entertainment industry!
@wadabski (761)
• Philippines
4 Apr 11
That seems to be the case. As you guys have noticed that most Filipino writers just copies the plot stories of other foreign films and make them their own, but some twist of their own then consider them a master piece. As much as they encourage us to support our own film movies but how can you watch them or even give your support if the film is really not that good.
1 person likes this
@Rapuncille (597)
• Philippines
4 Apr 11
We'll i'm really am wondering if the viewers are watching them because they find the storyline and the production good or could it be that they have no other option seems it is the trend among local networks? Not everyone in the country has access to cable right?
I myself at times is stucked watching them. I guess some of the current writers we have are not that good with coming up with an original storyline but they are gifted in making the story longer by putting up several twist that at times are not very well thought of.
@chipesterkhan (2925)
• Philippines
4 Apr 11
i believe the issue runs deeper than that
we have become numb because of our financial situation and have depended on tv as comfort food for the soul
thus we watch whatever's on tv just so we forget what ails our society
1 person likes this
@Rapuncille (597)
• Philippines
4 Apr 11
Are we really this poor? Do we really have to settle with recooked leftovers even when it comes to our comfort food for the soul? This look really bad, isn't it?
@flagella08 (5065)
• Philippines
4 Apr 11
i am not against this remaking of telenovelas. in fact i just enjoyed them. they make me realized that time passed by so fast that my age gets unnoticed. with regards to the remake, i don't think the Philippines ran out of writers.these good writers are doing great in putting twists to these stories. i have seen most of them and the changes of the script is apparently far from the original.in general, they're doing great.
@Rapuncille (597)
• Philippines
5 Apr 11
hi! thanks for giving your point of view on this matter. :) i respect your opinion on this and i'm glad that at least you are done good by them (in terms of your age being unnoticed :P). Anyway, i am not totally against of remaking telenovelas of good quality perse. What I am not in agreement of is that we are fed with the same thing over and over again. It has been a trend and it looks like there's no more space and air time for new materials to be shown and introduced.
With regards to the writers, i guess some of those that they've hired are inclined to fictional writing because some of the twist (at least for those that i've seen) are not that logical and more so, that possible in real life.
@LetranKnight25 (33121)
• Philippines
5 Apr 11
Hello Rapuncille,
Well, what's NEW? we've always been imitating a lot of Telenovela's coming from foreign ones, i have seen this in my late 90's though. but now, people are smart and obviously know by many viewers who have been watching too much of these sad tele-novelas. sometimes i get bored and watch a few episodes, but i have never got addicted to these things.
There's no doubt we have run out of ideas. the focus here now i think it's about commercializing and promoting the celebrity instead of the movie. but kudos to their hardwork though, it's not original anymore.
@Rapuncille (597)
• Philippines
5 Apr 11
Hi to the gentleman from Letran (i suppose :P). The current definition i guess of NEW is REHASHED! hehehe. I guess we are seen as viewers who cares more about the celebrity rather than the story.
I remember there's this one soap which story is really that sloppy but i managed several episodes of it because of that characters whose acting is really good. It's really amazing that shows with both sloppy story and the acting remains to be on prime time for a very long time.
@jeanneyvonne (5501)
• Philippines
5 Apr 11
I am a writer, and I think that good writers are just being misplaced not lost. As a response to your discussion, I'll let you in a little industry secret. The writers on a network are on the bottom of the network food chain. Remember the writer's strike in Hollywood. Pretty much that scenario.
In our respective networks, writers have to pitch their ideas to a committee of producers and network bigwigs in order to approve their concept. It has to be marketable and entertaining before it gets the approval. Upon approval, writers do their job bu providing content. A good and sustainable content is the lifeline of a writer's salary. Once the program is axed, so id the writer.
I would agree on previous answers that some networks chose to import, rerun or spin-off content from previous or international show formats. In this industry, imitation is vital and it is not considered a cardinal sin.
Some of the reasons that a network might product a import, rerun or spin-off is due to the previous content's profitability and marketability. As long as the mainstream audience eat up the content, networks don't usually bother with original format of shows (a good reason why I switched to cable TV.
@Rapuncille (597)
• Philippines
5 Apr 11
hi yvonne! at least we got one here tracked! :) Thank you for providing us your insight on this and for letting me know that switching to cable TV is beneficial, although a bit costly :p (i'd probably watch via live streaming though). You are an insider and i guess what you have shared with us is extremely helpful for us to understand what is the 'real deal' since the information is coming from an 'insider'.
Indeed, imitation is vital and not a cardinal sin but we all need a break from anything that is 'too much' right?! (at least for me that's the case). this has been a constant cycle that cannot be broken even by the most brilliant but underpaid minds. it's really sad to know that people like you, whose contribution to production remains vital, is placed at the bottom of the network food chain. the people who do most of the thinking to come up with innovative ideas and materials that will stimulate the viewers minds and intellect are not properly recognized and rewarded.
@maunesrockford92078 (305)
• Philippines
4 Apr 11
Nope, not good writers but passionate minds in their field of specialization like writers they do't think that deep anymore all are just a condensed of an another story, it wouldn't be easy too to write now a days there aint no time for serenity and quietness writers need that for a short time before they can sink in ideas and fathom wisdom on their own.
@Rapuncille (597)
• Philippines
4 Apr 11
Hi! I agree with you. Apart from the serenity and quietness, they also need to be better compensated and recognized for going beyond the norm and beyond what is just needed. Those who dare go an extra mile to come up with new and alternative ideas should be supported. I guess it is motivation that is lacking nowadays among the writers and those which work with the production.
@o0jopak0o (6394)
• Philippines
5 Apr 11
Well I really don't watch local shows because its all spanking or shouting. They have the same theme.
main actor just an orphan
main actor got switched from birth
and so on and so on.
@eurekafemme (5877)
• Philippines
5 Apr 11
Hello.
I do not think that we are running of good writers. There are still writers out there who can write so well and have a rich imagination. However, what was being shown on tv right now are basis on the commercialism. These stories are stereotype and yet these are the kinds that are in for the common viewers (the masa). These are the types of shows that generates income to the networks.
Here's what I think about this. Those writers are commissioned by the networks to write or rewrite such telenovelas because those are the current demand of the viewers. The networks are following a so called trending in tv shows. What's in is what's hot. so, they might as well strike the iron while it is hot, so to speak.
Gone are the days of Lino Brocka....
1 person likes this
@eurekafemme (5877)
• Philippines
5 Apr 11
Hello.
I do not think that we are running of good writers. There are still writers out there who can write so well and have a rich imagination. However, what was being shown on tv right now are basis on the commercialism. These stories are stereotype and yet these are the kinds that are in for the common viewers (the masa). These are the types of shows that generates income to the networks.
Here's what I think about this. Those writers are commissioned by the networks to write or rewrite such telenovelas because those are the current demand of the viewers. The networks are following a so called trending in tv shows. What's in is what's hot. so, they might as well strike the iron while it is hot, so to speak.
Gone are the days of Lino Brocka....
@Rapuncille (597)
• Philippines
5 Apr 11
hi eurekafemme! thanks for the reply. What you have said is a saddening truth. the quality movies we have previously are shown only during our humanities class in school and rarely in the philippine television.
I am wondering what is the future in store for the philippine television if this is the case.
@jaypeesol (218)
• Philippines
4 Apr 11
I do not think the problem is in the writers. We have a lot of creative individuals in our country. The problem is that TV networks are probably not paying them enough that writers would want to work hard on their script. Most of the good scriptwriters nowadays tend to work on independent movies. The TV networks would rather spend their money on a star's talent fee than on the story or the director, because people still watch a movie if they know the main actors, even if they don't know anything about the story.
1 person likes this
@Rapuncille (597)
• Philippines
4 Apr 11
I guess so. They would invest their money where they think it would earn more. Perhaps this mirrors their perception of the philippine televiewers maturity. As you have said, they would rather use their money on big stars' talent fee rather than invest on someone who could come up with a very good material. This means to say that Philippine televiewers are lured not by the story and not by the quality of the show/soap, instead we are enticed by who appears in the show no matter how bad the story and the production is. Is this true? Are we really out of alternative that's why we watch or most of us ask for that kind of show that's why it is what is supplied to us?
@toniganzon (72281)
• Philippines
4 Apr 11
It's not that we are running out of good writers but i think it's the tv producers that are subjecting themselves to commercialism, only airing what they think would be bankable or would earn them a lot of money from sponsors. What i don't like about Philippine tv series is that the writers don't do thorough research on facts that could make the story more believable. I always argue about certain things in the series and i feel so disappointed that they only produce these series to cater to C or B market, but never thought of targeting higher markets. So how can we expect the intellectuals to watch these series when there are so many loopholes?
I think tv producers should try and change their attitude in producing tv series.
@Rapuncille (597)
• Philippines
5 Apr 11
Hi toni! i do agree with you. Watching these loopholes and loose ends within the stories of most of these shows could either give you the false impression that you are a lot smarter than what you actually are; or it could lead you to the assumption that your logical and critical thinking is being underestimated.
I hope these tv producers could go beyond what is only profitable. I wish they could also help in empowering and improving the taste of the philippine televiewers by improving also the information and the stories they are feeding them.
@Rapuncille (597)
• Philippines
4 Apr 11
Hi! It is boring. :) you could either watch dvds, read a good book or perhaps just sleep. These will do you good and will spare you of those boring times. :p