Book Piracy
@allyoftherain (7208)
United States
April 7, 2011 2:53pm CST
This issue has been hanging over my head for awhile, and I'd like to discuss it with fellow readers. The ebook (something I have all sorts of other problems with, but we'll not talk about that now) has made a previous unheard crime possible... book piracy.
I'm pretty passionate about the issue of piracy in general. I believe that every creator has full right to distribute their work as they please. If you can't afford or don't want to buy, then don't get it or look for a legal alternative. Book piracy REALLY makes me mad because they are so many libraries across the nation that would offer the books for free, 100% legal. But no... instead people choose to share books through peer to peer file sharers and torrents, allowing unlimited and unpaid for distribution of someone else's work.
Some authors on book piracy:
http://cindachima.blogspot.com/2010/02/aaaaargh-please-dont-steal-books.html
http://anywherebeyond.livejournal.com/342581.html?view=1728821#t1728821
http://halseanderson.livejournal.com/281573.html
http://marypearson.livejournal.com/114363.html
http://www.kimberlypauley.com/2011/01/12/and-furthermore-why-illegal-downloads-suck-i-e-status-of-a-third-mina-book/
What do you readers think?
2 people like this
3 responses
@carmelanirel (20942)
• United States
8 Apr 11
As a writer you know how I feel, it's wrong and people who pirate others work should be accountable and punished for their actions. Ironically in my class right now, I am learning about citations, where one can use lines from another article as long as they give the credit to the author..It's a lot harder than it looks, but I am pushing to learn to do this so I don't accidentally take something I shouldn't..
@allyoftherain (7208)
• United States
8 Apr 11
Yes, I know most writers/aspiring writers are on my side! lol There is a difference between a few stray lines and the entire book available for download.
Another reason for me to hate eBooks.
2 people like this
@carmelanirel (20942)
• United States
8 Apr 11
Yes, and I think this is another reason why I am choosing not to put my book online, I feel it is safer if I publish it the old fashion way..
2 people like this
@allyoftherain (7208)
• United States
9 Apr 11
Good move. Though I think most traditional publishers are choosing a print and eBook route. I don't know how much control debut authors would have over blocking an eBook release. Have you researched that?
2 people like this
@Alnitak (423)
• Italy
9 Apr 11
I'm against piracy when it's considered the only way to get books, music, etc... there are too many kids that thinks that's how they get music (and now books) withouth having the notion of the damage they're doing to the musicians/authors but I can't deny that in the music market piracy played a role accelerating the process from old CDs to single tracks sold on iTunes at a fairer price.
Now I see that many e-books have even a higher price compared to paper books and it's simply unacceptable. There's no excuse for that. Editors are blind about e-books potentiality and someway they are making the same mistakes that labels did.
And not mentioning all the DRM nonsense. They think they can stop piracy locking their files when 5 minutes after a new DRM it's already been hacked (with much amusement by all the piracy nerds) and they are only creating tecnological obstacles for the honest people that just would like to be able to read the book they've bought wherever they'd like to.
This kind of blindness just drives me mad, so I think piracy is like stealing, but I also think it's a consequence of bad marketing choices made by editors.
2 people like this
@Alnitak (423)
• Italy
9 Apr 11
Not all books are entertainment, but that's a different matter, and I agree with you that the creator should have the right to choose the price.
It is also true, though, that for years they had the power to raise the price little by little without improving the quality of their books and readers had no decisional power at all because when there is no alternative you can't simply choose not to buy. But with e-books there is this piracy "sword of Damocles" and they are not allowed anymore to raise the price little by little without people noticing.
Getting tracks online was a natural evolution, but when they needed to choose how to sell music by the internet I think they also took under consideration the behaviour people were having with piracy. They must have, just like I think they're monitoring what people think about e-books prices and DRM protections right now. If they want to develop a marketing strategy, they need to know what people think.
If piracy wouldn't be technically possible I don't think they would have dropped so much the price of a single song. It was a market competitor, an illegal and totally not fair one, but it was and it influenced the business.
So, that's why I think it plays a role. I'm not saying it's right but I'm not really sure ther is an alternative to what's happening.
2 people like this
@allyoftherain (7208)
• United States
10 Apr 11
Well, I'm not in agreement with you on some minor points... but at least we both agree that it's wrong. I think that's one of the only things that we can do to combat piracy, is to increase awareness about what it does to the industry and raise the level of respect for created content.
1 person likes this
@allyoftherain (7208)
• United States
9 Apr 11
I don't think it's ever right to point the finger back to the content creators. This is entertainment. There is no reason that anyone needs to have the latest book, movie, or song. Therefore, I think it's completely within the rights of content creators to distribute how they please. If they overcharge, don't buy and don't indulge. If they really want their content seen, then they'll make a better distribution plan happen.
I don't think piracy played any role in getting single tracks available on iTunes. That was a natural evolution of the digital age, along with piracy becoming more prevalent. Ultimately piracy just makes the creators more angry, not willing to make compromises. I think it's absurd and extremely selfish of people to think they're entitled to what others create. And I think that it's considerably more selfish than content creators putting money over the love of fans.
1 person likes this
@leafygreens08 (754)
• United States
12 Apr 11
I am very new as an writer. I have my own book on the last stages of editing with a co-writer. I have been doing some research about book piracy and I even read a couple of the links you posted here. I am glad I looked them up and I think I am sticking to the decision I have made: self publish.
It's my first book and while I am learning, I want as much control over its creation, design and sales. It also looks like I am going to avoid going the ebook route and Kindle. It's just way too easy for someone to copy and email or distribute illegal copies on the Internet these days. If any of my friends argue that they "need" a kindle copy or ebook, I will explain why I only sell soft cover copies and tell them about ebook piracy.
@leafygreens08 (754)
• United States
12 Apr 11
I looked into a few places and liked Createspace.com the best. I spoke with their customer service and liked how they set up their website. I know right up front how much one of my soft cover novels will cost to print and how much I will get to keep from sales and it will be done in just a day or two from when I upload my manuscript. Lulu.com is another good place but I am going with Createspace.
@allyoftherain (7208)
• United States
12 Apr 11
Where are you self-publishing? Are you doing it with a company, a print on demand site, or through your own funds?
There's no reason anyone needs an ebook, so go ahead and stand your ground. I wish more authors were taking a stand against eBooks. I have loads of problems with them... lol.
1 person likes this