Pia Toscano out of American Idol.
@chocl8starfish (113)
Philippines
April 8, 2011 6:09am CST
Wow! what a shocker on tonight's American Idol results. Pia Toscano, arguably one of the best if not the best vocals in the contest was booted out by America tonight. The judges where kinda dismayed with the turn out, also the fans.
What do you think? Was it the right choice for America to eliminate her?
2 people like this
6 responses
@KrauseHome (36448)
• United States
22 Apr 11
Yes, it was definately a shocker when she was let go and voted off before some of the others, but I think she will still be a Star everyone will be talking about for a long time. They are already having her perform on Dancing with the Stars, etc. so we have far from heard from the last of her.
@LadyMarissa (12148)
• United States
9 Apr 11
WELCOME TO MYLOT!!! 
I was soooo upset last night when Pia's name was called to go!!! Every year I get frustrated with Idol & swear I'm going to stop watching. Then after a break & a new season starts I forget why I was so mad the last season!!! Now that Simon thinks Idol can't survive without him, I don't want to leave as I want to support the fact that Simon left!!! 
I have been saying for years that Idol is rigged just to rile up people in order to get them to watch even more. I'm beginning to get tired of being jerked around!!!! The ONLY reason I watch Idol is because I can't discuss my opinion with people at work if I haven't seen it. PLUS I can't give my opinion here if I haven't seen it!!! Much like you can't win the lottery if you don't have a ticket, I can't discuss how I feel about Idol if I haven't seen it yet!!! I just really, really hope that somebody in a position to guide Pia's fame has been watching & is willing to make her an offer she can't refuse & she becomes even MORE popular than Idol could have taken her!!!! 
I was soooo upset last night when Pia's name was called to go!!! Every year I get frustrated with Idol & swear I'm going to stop watching. Then after a break & a new season starts I forget why I was so mad the last season!!! Now that Simon thinks Idol can't survive without him, I don't want to leave as I want to support the fact that Simon left!!! I have been saying for years that Idol is rigged just to rile up people in order to get them to watch even more. I'm beginning to get tired of being jerked around!!!! The ONLY reason I watch Idol is because I can't discuss my opinion with people at work if I haven't seen it. PLUS I can't give my opinion here if I haven't seen it!!! Much like you can't win the lottery if you don't have a ticket, I can't discuss how I feel about Idol if I haven't seen it yet!!! I just really, really hope that somebody in a position to guide Pia's fame has been watching & is willing to make her an offer she can't refuse & she becomes even MORE popular than Idol could have taken her!!!! 
@momof3kids (1894)
• Singapore
9 Apr 11
I dun care much about Pia. I like Naima and she is already out last week. I like Naima because she has had a difficult life. Although I should base my likes on talent, I cant help but feel that Naima should be the one to stay.
She was a stand out every single week, why would they even put her in the bottom 3? Even the judges were disappointed..I hope they bring her back though..
@omgmewmewcat (20)
• Netherlands
8 Apr 11
I think it's rigged. It's a television show afterall, and they do it only for the money. They'll do some things that will seem surprising to us, but is nothing more than just a marketing scheme to actually earn MORE money out of people. :3
