do you think Scotty deserves to win American Idol season 10?

Personally, i'm not really a fan of Scotty. It's not that i don't like country, i do actually like country singers like rascal flats. It's the style of Scotty; his singing, performance, eyebrow wiggling and smirking; that i'm not a fan of. I really don't think he deserves to win AI. I mean he could be a country star but not win AI this year. I would bet James or Casey will take the crown.

Admittedly his voice reminds of the late Elvis Prestley, although his forte is country music. His smile is captivating with his boyish looks, and the i guess the fans especially the girls are going "gaga" over him. overall, in my opinion is a good contender, but not enough to win American Idol.

Personally the further the competition goes each week, and knowing who the Final 3 are... I am going Scottie all the way. He knows how to perform and play to the Crowd, and I am ready to go buy his CD right now. If he wins he is going to be BIG mark my words, and if he does not he will still be a BIG star for Country Music for many yrs. to come.

In my own opinion, everybody in the contest deserves to win but we can't deny the fact that Scotty isn't that good. I mean Scotty has many things to show and prove before he get that title. We all know that Scotty can really sing but he is far compare to other contestants. I'm not against Scotty but that's what I see. This is a talent show, we must vote for the talent not for the looks. I'm sad when Pia has to leave because I know she got that talent and she can show us for more. She was voted out because she doesn't have enough votes to stay. After all we are looking for a talent that is why it is called American Idol.

I'm a HUGE Scotty fan, but I don't think he is ready to win Idol this season!!! I see a GREAT future for him, but just don't think he is ready just yet!!! Because a lot of votes goes to Scotty Do you have an insider at Idol or are you just making a personal observation??? I'm old enough to be his Grandmother & it's even possible I could be his Great Grandmother...so I'm NOT a fan because he's cute!!! I'm a fan because he reminds me of many Country Music stars who are no longer with us!!! When I hear him sing, it's almost like Johnny Cash has come back to life!!! He also reminds me of Conway Twitty singing Hello Darling which was considered one of the sexiest songs ever recorded back when I was entering my adulthood!!! I'd LOVE to hear Scotty sing that song!!!! Scotty is just a little too laid back for what the younger generation likes, but is just PERFECT for what this old woman prefers!!!

I think no..although he is a really nice kid and he is improving these past few weeks, I just see other contestants who are really more talented than him.. and who deserve to win more. I'm sure he'll get a career after Ai.

In my opinion, I don't think he deserve to win and I don't want him to win at all. Now that my favorite Pia is out, I am placing my bet on either Lauren or James. I personally would prefer Lauren because I can see and feel the x-factor in her and I think she has a little advantage over James, but then, I feel that whoever gonna win this season, Pia will still be the most successful of all for this season.

I don't think that he is also good enough to win.. His voice can only sing country, no variety at all. No offense to fans. How do you know that he gets most the votes anyway?

...and your winner... and the new American Idol season 10 is.... Haley Reinhart (period) :-)

I like Scotty and frankly at this point I like them all. I would be ok with anyone of them winning.