Do you like to read the book if you have already seen the movie?
By Porcospino
@Porcospino (31366)
Denmark
May 4, 2011 10:17am CST
Yesterday I borrowed the book behind the movie "Shutter island". I liked the movie a lot and when I discovered that there was a book as well, was excited and decided to read it. I started reading it, and I like the story, but one of the things that I loved about the movie was the twist at the end and when I read the story, I don't get the same experience, because I already know "too much" to get surpriced.
Have you ever had the same experience? If you have seen a great movie do you like to read the book behind that movie? Or do you think it is a little boring to read the book because you already know the story?
7 people like this
45 responses
@Porcospino (31366)
• Denmark
28 Apr 12
Hi xyruz and yeokeehui!
I think it is true that the movie often omits part of the scenes from the book, and sometimes they also change some of the scenes when they make the movie. Sometimes I get disappointed when I watch a movie that is based on a book that I have read, because the movie is different from the book in many ways. On the other hand if I really like the story I often choose to read the book and watch the movie as well, because that gives me the chance to enjoy the story in more than one way.
@ifa225 (14460)
• Indonesia
6 May 11
i like to read it first than to watch it. the book sometimes describe it more than the movie.
just like the twilight saga, i can't figure how Edward or Bela character if i have not read the book first. but just like you too, i don't find any surprising when i watch the movie cause i already know how the end
@Porcospino (31366)
• Denmark
25 Apr 12
When we read the book at first we are able to develop our own pictures of the characters, and I think that is one of the advantages about reading the book first. When we have already seen the movie it is sometimes more difficult to create our own impression of the characters, because we remember what they looked like in the movie. In book we also get more details compared to the movie and sometimes those details make it easier to understand the different aspects of the story like you experienced when you read the Twilight saga. On the hand we lose the surpricing experience when we already know the story, and that is one of the disadvantages.
1 person likes this
@gtdonna (1738)
•
5 May 11
Yes I like to read the books to movies. It matters not whether they are consider greta or not, as long as I know there is a book written as well, I just have to get the book.
I just finished reading the entire Stephanie meyers Twilight books and now reading ehr last book Hots. Can't wait to see the Breaking Dawn movies.
2 people like this
@Porcospino (31366)
• Denmark
22 May 11
I haven't read the Twilight books, but I have heard about them. I would like to read them because they belong the genre of books that I usually read. When I have seen a movie that I really enjoyed I always get really excited when I discover that there is a book as well and immediately decide to read the book. Some weeks ago I was at the library. By coincidence I discovered the book behind a movie that I really liked and I decided to borrow it. Unfortuneately the book was a disappointment, but in most cases I enjoy the books.
@sharra1 (6340)
• Australia
6 May 11
If it is a good story I do. I often find the book better than the movie as movies often change things to suit themselves. I just love reading. I read all the Harry Potter books after seeing the movies and I enjoyed them very much. For me it is not a problem knowing what happens. I suppose it might be a problem if you prefer mysteries but in that case how could you watch a movie twice if you do not like to know the ending.
I prefer to think of a book as a journey to be enjoyed. I am not in a hurry to get to the ending. If I already know the ending then I can enjoy the journey without the stress as I know they all end up ok. The Lord of the Rings is one book I have journey in countless times over the years. So often I know that I used to know it almost word for word but I still enjoyed the journey.
A film is over so quickly and has to cut out a lot to fit the time. A book has all the little bits that the film left out as not necessary to the plot but to the reader they are still enjoyable.
@Porcospino (31366)
• Denmark
25 Apr 12
If I read the book and watch the movie as well I often like the book better than the movie, probably because I get a lot of details in the book that I don't get in the movie. I like the thing you wrote about enjoying a book without stress if you already know the ending. I haven't thought about it that way, but I think that it makes sense. I have never seen the Harry potter movies, but I have read the first book. I want to read the rest of the books and maybe I will watch the movie later on. I love reading, and I have decided to read the books first. I think that it will be interesing to watch the movie when I already know the story.
@macayadann (1235)
• Philippines
6 May 11
I do not want to go over it again since I already seen it and besides watching it again rather than reading is much more exciting.
2 people like this
@Porcospino (31366)
• Denmark
25 Apr 12
So you prefer to watch the movie one more time instead of reading the book. Sometimes I watch a movie more than once (if I really like the movie) but if there is a book I usually try to find that, because I like to read the story behind the movie.
@runpersist (12)
• China
6 May 11
I have no interest to read a book if I have already seen the movie.As regards to me,the actor in the screen will affect my understanding of the book
2 people like this
@Porcospino (31366)
• Denmark
25 Apr 12
I sometimes experience that. Sometimes the movie affects the way that I interpret the book. It can be difficult to forget the impression that we got in the movie. When I read a book I always try to imagine what the characters look like, but if I have seen the movie first the actors affect the way that I think about the characters. I don't create my own pictures of the characters I automatically see the picture of the actors when I try to imagine what the characters look like. When I read the book first I don't have that problem and it is easy for me to create my own pictures of the characters.
1 person likes this
@sizzle3000 (3036)
• United States
4 May 11
I do sometimes. My daughter onthe other hand, she reads them before. Then when she watches a movie with us she's so aggrivated because they left out a really good part or a funny part. We can't watch the movie in peace until she's gone because of it.
2 people like this
@Porcospino (31366)
• Denmark
5 May 11
When I read the book first I sometimes get disappointed in the movie. Like your daughter I cant help noticing the things that they changed or left out. Sometimes my favourite part of the book has been turned into something completely different. One of my teachers always said that it was best to watch the movie first to avoid that kind of disappointment, but sometimes I still read the book at first.
1 person likes this
@mlhuff12 (797)
• United States
5 May 11
From my experience, books are better than the movies. Books allow the writter to be more creative. In many cases, what is in the book is hard to display in a movie or would cost way too much to re-create. If you read the book before watching the movie, you will be disappointed with the movie almost all the time.
2 people like this
@Porcospino (31366)
• Denmark
14 May 11
I once had a teacher to said the same thing as you. He said that we always had to watch the movie before the read the book so that we didn't get disappointed in the movie. In his lessons we always watched the movie first. Today I don't follow his advice every time. Sometimes I read the book at first and sometimes I watch the movie at first. In most cases I also think that the book is better than the movie because there are more details in the books and we able to stand the story in a different way when we read the book. A few times I have been disappointed in the book, because is wasn't as good as the movie, but in most cases it is the other way around.
@dodo19 (47336)
• Beaconsfield, Quebec
4 May 11
I do usually prefer reading the book before seeing the movie. That's the way that I like to do it. And it's also the way that I've done it a number of times before, when it comes to movies based on books. It's a nice way to do it. At least, the way that I like to do it for the most part.
2 people like this
@Porcospino (31366)
• Denmark
5 May 11
I do both. Sometimes I read the book at first and sometimes I watch the movie at first. When I discover that they are going to turn one of my favourite books into a movie and I always get excited and I look forward to watching it. Sometimes I don't know that that the movie is based on a book and I don't find the book till much later. That was what happened with the book "Shutter island" and "Psycho" as well. When I read "Psycho" I didn't remember all of the details from the movie, because I watched it a long time ago.
1 person likes this
@verabear (796)
• Philippines
5 May 11
I do! I am even excited to see a movie based on a book that I have already read. Sometimes, I buy a book because it's being made into a movie and I want to read it first before seeing it. There are also times when I like a particular movie and learning that it was based on a book i will seek it out just to read it too. It's nice comparing the differences, or how the movie stayed true to the book or not. :)
2 people like this
@Porcospino (31366)
• Denmark
8 May 11
When I discover that I book that I have read has been turned into a movie, I also get excited. If I really enjoyed the book and I look forward to watching the movie. Sometimes I get a disappointed in the movie if they have changed too many things. In some situations I watch the movie before I read the book for instanse if I don't know that the movie is based on a book when I watch the movie. Sometimes I discover by coincidence that there is a book as well.
@allknowing (137771)
• India
5 May 11
There is so much we miss in a movie and by reading the book we get what we have lost specially those lines. It is those strong lines that make a movie and many a time the sound system is such one is not able to catch those words. And having a book one can go through it several times. The description of the place is yet another aspect that we can digest by reading the story even after we have seen the movie. I have read a few books, such as Thorn Birds, Woman of Substance, The Other Side of Midnight, Pigmallion (My Fair Lady),Hotel, etc.
2 people like this
@Porcospino (31366)
• Denmark
9 May 11
I also think that we miss something when we watch a movie, and sometimes the book helps us understand the movie better. I have experienced that several times. I like to read the book, because it makes it easier for me to understand the story, the characters' thoughts and experiences, the surroundings etc. Sometimes I watch a movie and I am not quite sure how to understand or interpret everything and in those cases I like to read the book, but it depends on the story. I don't always enjoy the book that much if I have already seen the movie especially if there is a surpricing ending.
@Suzieqmom (2755)
• United States
4 May 11
Not usually--I much prefer to read the book first, and then see the movie, although I am often disappointed even if I follow that order! The only movies that I think I saw first and then read the books afterward was Gone with the Wind, and the Godfather books, but those movies AND books were so well done that the effect was not ruined by seeing the movie first.
2 people like this
@Porcospino (31366)
• Denmark
4 May 11
I haven't seen the movie version of "Gone with the wind" but I have read the book. It could be interesting to see the movie as well. I once had a teacher who said that it was best to see the movie before you read the book, so that you didn't get disappointed in the movie, and in his classes we always saw the movie first. I don't always follow his advice. I often read the book at first, but sometimes I don't know that there is a book when I watch the movie.
1 person likes this
@06MLam (620)
•
5 May 11
I usually prefer to watch the movie than reading a book because I found it tired to read a whole book. However, sometimes I will read a book after I have watched the movie so as to compare what the film has changed from the original story written in the book and try to think about how I will interpret the story from the author and make it into a film. This sounds a bit time wasting but I think this is quite an interesting way of learning language as well as thinking and imagination.
2 people like this
@Porcospino (31366)
• Denmark
22 May 11
I also think that it can be interesting to compare the movie and the book, sometimes there are a lot of differences. I love reading and I often enjoy the book more than the movie, but there are some exceptions. I recently read the book behind a Danish movie that I really liked, but the book was a disappointment and it was very confusing. I like your idea about interpreting the book and imagining which kind of movie that you would have made. I like to use my imagination and play with different ideas.
@oninomar (505)
• Philippines
5 May 11
Many of the movies were taken from books. There are some advantage in reading a version of a movie. Base on my own experience, in the book there are so many scene and emotions that is not shown in the movie. Although you can see the actors as they portrait their character. Also some of the scene in the movies are additives and not really happen in the book version. It is nice to read the book when you really feel the emotions of the characters while reading it. Happy reading.!:)
2 people like this
@Porcospino (31366)
• Denmark
22 May 11
That is true, there are often many differences between the book and the movie. Some parts of the book are hard to show in a movie (for instanse the character's thoughts) and sometimes I understand the story better when I the read the book behind the movie. I am still reading "Shutter island", at first I was a little disappointed in the book, because I already knew the story, but the more I read the more I like the book. It contains some details that weren't a part of the movie, and I actually like the book.
@JoyfulOne (6232)
• United States
4 May 11
For me, I always like to read the book before seeing the movie. The movie version usually almost always deviates from the book some (or a lot.) Like Stephen King's "It", the movie was SO different from the book, and left so much out. Also, when you read the book first, you can get into the mind of the characters and understand their motivation and feelings more. In the movie, they have to show what's going through their minds (through their actions and deeds.) When I read a book before the movie like that, it doesn't matter that I know the outcome of the story, to me, it makes it more interesting.
2 people like this
@Porcospino (31366)
• Denmark
4 May 11
It is also my experience that that the movie version deviates from the book. I remember a Danish movie that I watched some time ago. In the book the main character experiences some supernatural things, but in the movie version they wanted to make a realistic story and they changed a lot of things to create a realistic impression. I had read the book first and it was a little strange to watch the movie, because the story was so different.
One of things that I enjoy when I read the book is the fact that we are able to understand the characters' thoughts in a difference way. In a movie we can watch their actions, but we don't get the same kind of knowledge about their thoughts and intentions.
1 person likes this
@ladygator (3465)
• United States
7 May 11
I do sometimes. I would rather read the book first since you can then paint the pictures and get your own perceptions of what you think to be the details of the story. Your mind can just be all creative in its own devises. I loved the movie Shutter Island, it was a real tricky one wasnt it!! Thats the fun of it.
1 person likes this
@ladygator (3465)
• United States
28 Apr 12
It does leave several different turns doent it? If the right charaters are selected. As well the setting it can enhance the story.
1 person likes this
@ladygator (3465)
• United States
28 Apr 12
Another one that you might enjoy. (a movie) Is Inception. That also has Leonardo Decaprio in it as well. Its another mind blowing, well written and acted out movie.
@Porcospino (31366)
• Denmark
27 Apr 12
I also loved Shutter island. Someone on Mylot recommended it and I am happy that I decided to watch it. I never guessed the truth, and that is one of the reasons why I liked the movie. I enjoy movies that are able to surprice me It is true that it is easier to create your own pictures of the story when you read the book first. When I watch the movie first I can't just forget the the buildings etc and the way the actors look and that affects my own pictures of the story when I read the book.
1 person likes this
@Lisander (273)
• Armenia
22 May 11
Yes, certainly. I don't like to look the movie after the book, at least not until there is some time passed. That way the small things that they change in the movie don't annoy much. But one thing that makes it impossible to watch the movies after the book is that nearly no personage looks like the one in my head, so i just can't accept them as he part of the story))
2 people like this
@camomile07 (1420)
• Germany
4 May 11
I rather prefer to read the story first. Every person imagine the read story on a different way and has got his/her own experience while he/she reads the book. After, it might be interesting to see the movie to share or compare the experience. When you see the film first and read the book afterwards, during the book while you read it you always (even if you don't want to) remember the different scenes of the movie. So it's not your own imagination any more which is going through your mind. Your thoughts are already manipulated.
@Porcospino (31366)
• Denmark
4 May 11
When we read a story we all have a different experience and imagine things in a different way, that is true. Sometimes it is a strange experience to watch a movie because the actors, the houses and the surroundings look different from the way that I have imagined. One of my friends hates to read novels with pictures, because she isn't able to use her own imagination. I don't mind pictures or movies based on books, but sometimes the movies destroy the pictures that I got after I read the descriptions in the book.
1 person likes this
@abmacasinag (518)
• Philippines
4 May 11
People who loves to read are frequently disappointed by the movie versions. There have been some great films made from books, but typically, movie versions of books tends to aggrieve readers because they are not just like the book. Usually when a film director works off of an adapted screenplay the results are simply not the same as reading the book. One of the things that annoy readers most about movie versions is the deletion of material in the book while adding a new material not created by the writer.
My answer to your question is Yes.
2 people like this
@Porcospino (31366)
• Denmark
4 May 11
Yes, sometimes it is hard to recognize the story in the movie, because it is very different from the book. When I hear about a movie that it based on a book that I like, I usually get excited and look forward to watching the movie, but sometimes I get disappointed in the movie. It has happened to me a couples of times in the past especially if I really liked the book and the movie leaves out too many times and adds things that wasn't a part of the book. I think it is unrealistic to expect the movie and the book to be alike in every way, but I still get disappointed sometimes.
1 person likes this
@SIMPLYD (90721)
• Philippines
5 May 11
After i have watched the movie of The Lord of the Rings, i decided to read the book and the other books of the Trilogy. Hence, when i have watched the movies of the two other sequel , i now fully understood why this and that was so.
For me, i like reading the books, because you can fully understand what are the things that surrounds the mystery, the characters etc. But of course, watching the movie is nicer, though i now know that a movie will be nicer if you have read the book beforehand.
1 person likes this
@Porcospino (31366)
• Denmark
6 May 11
When we read the book we often understand the story better, that is true. Sometimes when I watch a movie there are some things that I don't understand completely and when I read the book I am able to understand the characters and the backgroud of the story in a different way. Whether I enjoy reading the book after seeing the movie depends on the story I think. If the movie has a surpricing ending, I don't get the same experience if I read the book after watching the movie, because I already know what is going to happen.