Geithner - the average man in the street to blame for financial crisis
By bobmnu
@bobmnu (8157)
United States
May 20, 2011 8:32am CST
Treasury Scet. Giethner places the blame on the American people for the financial meltdown for taking on too much debt. Speaking at the screening of the new HBO movie “Too Big to Fail” Geithner is clearly blaming the American people for the problem and states that to resolve the Debt Ceiling Crisis there needs to be tax increases on the Wealthy. (my note any time we tax the rich sooner or later it becomes a tax on everyone who is working for a living).
http://www.newsmax.com/Headline/TimothyGeithner-DebtCrisis-TARP-TooBigtoFail/2011/05/18/id/396840?s=al&promo_code=C494-1
Is Geithner trying to position himself for a big job with the financial world after he is done at Treasury?
It should be noted that Geithner was one of the first in the Obama Administration to be exposed as a tax cheat for failing to pay taxes on money he signed a statement saying that he would pay taxes on the money he earned.
3 responses
@thegreatdebater (7316)
• United States
22 May 11
Bob, Giethner is technically correct, if no one applied for these loans, then these bad loans wouldn't have been made. But, the institutions have blame here, along with the investors, regulators, and many others.
I do agree that we need to raise taxes on EVERYONE, not just the rich. Need I remind you that both Ronald Reagan and Bill Clinton both raised taxes, and had record growth. Bush Jr. and Obama didn't raise taxes, and look where that got us.
I still have yet to see where "Trickle down" economics has ever worked.
@bobmnu (8157)
• United States
22 May 11
Trickle down does work. Have you every worked for or been paid by a poor person?
Right now our tax system is a mess. When you have 10% of the income earners paying 80%m of the taxes and 47% either paying no taxes or receiving a paycheck from the government something is wrong. When you look at the lowest income earners they receive more back in refunds than was withheld in taxes. Right now our tax system seems to reward those who do very little or nothing at all and punish those who work hard.
We need a tax system where everyone pays something into the general fund.
The problem I have with the statement made by Giethner is that once again you place the blame on one group and there by pitting one group against another and ignoring the elected and unelected people who make the rules but don't have to live by all of them.
@thegreatdebater (7316)
• United States
22 May 11
Bob, I don't make more when my employers taxes go down, I make more when I make them more money. If you raise the taxes on my employer than we pass those prices on to the consumer, but if you lower our taxes we just pocket that money.
AGAIN, please show me one example of where "trickle down" economics has worked!!!!!
I agree that our tax system is a mess, but how much of this is brought on by right wing conservatives? I am married, have three kids, and make $50,000 a year. Before I was married I paid about 30% of my income in taxes, today I don't pay a dime. Why? Because our tax system gives me a tax break for having kids and getting married. Sound fair to you?
I am sure you remember when Steve Forbes ran for office an wanted a flat tax rate. All of his republican opponents bashed him for because many of them knew that even the top tax rate doesn't pay 10% in their taxes. All of know that rich have high power accountants that make sure that they pay as little as possible in taxes. Your numbers are right, but look at D!ck Cheney's 2008 tax returns, and realize that he paid a lower percentage of his income than I did when I was single. The difference is that he is a multi-millionaire, and I didn't make a percentage of the INTEREST he makes per year.
Please explain to me how it is that a multi-millionaire who should be taxed in the 30% range is paying 9%?
If you look at the facts Bob, you will realize that when you raise taxes to pay down debt, than lower than the economy grows. When you just cut taxes, and increase debt, you have a lost decade. Just ask George W. Bush!!!!!!
@Taskr36 (13963)
• United States
20 May 11
In fairness to Geithner, he's not entirely wrong.
The root cause of this was that people bought houses they couldn't afford and failed to pay their mortgages. Now we can blame the banks for giving loans to these people, congress and ACORN for bullying these banks into giving these loans, and we can blame Bush just because he's Bush, but in the end, the crash wouldn't have happened if people hadn't taken on so much debt and failed to make their payments.
Raising taxes on the wealthy won't fix anything. All that does is take money out of the economy and punish people for success. After all, the wealthy weren't the ones who didn't pay their debts.
Aside from that I'm not fond of a tax cheat who wants to raise other people's taxes. A man who doesn't pay his own taxes has no right to tell others they must pay more.
@maria__simova (38)
• Bulgaria
20 May 11
The finansial crisis has taken all sides!America can not all parties to help!Each party must emerge from the crisis according to their cash!