will u beat naughty children?

@janey84 (523)
Australia
November 19, 2006 3:59pm CST
In asian countries, beating children is common n they believe children will learn n "grow" faster in a sense of learning fr the punishment. But in western countries, this is considered absurd, n children are well protected. What do u think? Are children ought to be punished by beating them when they do something wrong???
1 person likes this
9 responses
• Pakistan
20 Nov 06
no !
1 person likes this
@janey84 (523)
• Australia
20 Nov 06
u must be really love children,,
• India
20 Nov 06
no.......
@janey84 (523)
• Australia
20 Nov 06
u responded to the comment..so meaning?? u say no to "love children" or no to child abuse??
• Philippines
20 Nov 06
That is true, beating children is the common way of disciplining one's kid. Here in Philippines, the parents has a sole responsibility when it comes to disciplining ur child, no one can argue with that unless u treat ur child in a violent way not only physical but also emotional. As for me, as early as possible try to discipline ur kid while they're young, in that way when they grow up they will know that they're doing right. And also set your disciplinary method, like scolding them or spanking (here, we can beat our kid but u must control ur temper so that u cant hurt ur child to much physically. But as they know how to talk, try to develop the talk and listen method (everytime he done wrong talk to him and he should listen and vice versa), so that ur kid will not be getting some "phobia" with u.
1 person likes this
@janey84 (523)
• Australia
20 Nov 06
that's so so true..disciplining them at a very young age will build their attitude or behaviour to be more respecting to the elders,polite and not so rebellious..discipline is a must but not violently abused them..
@manzician (4727)
• India
20 Nov 06
No... They are so cute...
1 person likes this
@janey84 (523)
• Australia
20 Nov 06
yep...cutest when they r kids..but monstrous when they grow up..(some)
@raisushkr (1398)
• India
20 Nov 06
hmm its not like that its just to control the kid.they might punish them but they love them too
1 person likes this
@janey84 (523)
• Australia
20 Nov 06
some point i agree...but there r ppl thinking dat beating is loving..so.. ppl should really know the meaning of punish n love..
@goblet (155)
• Pakistan
20 Nov 06
first i try to explain them...
1 person likes this
@janey84 (523)
• Australia
20 Nov 06
wat if they still rebel and keep doing the mistakes??
@leanette (3002)
• India
20 Nov 06
i might spank them once a while if they get outta hand but beating them would be terrible..they tend to be naughty, thats why they are called kids.
@janey84 (523)
• Australia
20 Nov 06
ya..there r kids dat really get on ppl's nerve..they really r rebellious and no manners at all..sometimes i wonder if the parents spoilt them too much
• Singapore
20 Nov 06
i'm asian, and i think that children nowadays are very intelligent and matured. the more you beat them, the more they tend to be rebellious. i will choose to explain to them and nag if necessary ;0)
@janey84 (523)
• Australia
20 Nov 06
U hav a point there but i still think if the parents are a little bit strict to the children, i think the children won't really rebel.. at least not too often..n then beating would be spared..
@bishu_sinha (1457)
• India
20 Nov 06
I m against it
1 person likes this
@janey84 (523)
• Australia
20 Nov 06
thanks 4 ur response
@tony2313 (68)
• India
20 Nov 06
i will