Are herbals safe?
By w1z111
@w1z111 (985)
United States
May 23, 2011 9:12am CST
If we believe in the concept that the things that grow naturally on our planet are, indeed, for the free use by inhabitants (humans, other animals) of the planet, then I think we must agree that herbs and other plants are probably meant for healing and/or nourishment.
Surely, the hugely profitable pharmaceutical companies and even the medical industry at large do not want us to think that herbals are useful; else they'd lose some of their profits, wouldn't they? And, clearly, herbals might not be capable of some of the things that powerful drugs are capable of, but I'm convinced herbals should be recognized and exploited for what they CAN do; and, people should have free choice regarding their use.
Visit http://www.quing-it.com for product ingredient information, and check out my Google-Squared listing of "Alternative Medicines" at http://www.google.com/squared/table/agQYxUvR7V1mZ0IwcHicwyA.
2 responses
@Fire10 (293)
• United States
6 Jun 11
Hello there - Here's an opinion coming from someone in a traditional, western-health field. The example of willow bark is classic! Another example is the poppy plant/opium/morphine.
So are herbs safer than prescription/man-made medicines? The only true answer is - depends on which prescription and herb you're comparing.
The most dangerous herbs have already been outlawed.
The herbs proven most useful have already had their singular most active ingredient purified and standardized in medications - taking willow bark, poppy plant, and fish oils as prime examples.
It is my opinion that most of the herbs available at US store counters therefore fits into the "hasn't been shown to cause significant harm" and one of these two other groups "little proof of effectiveness" or "a lot of proof that it is mildly-effective-or-mostly-ineffective-so-that-no-pharmaceutical-company-could-profit-from-identifying-and-purifying-its-active-ingredients"
Problems for the herbal industry in the US includes:
Companies that make herbal supplements in the US aren't required to prove that the pills in the bottle are actually the herb or part of the plant written on the label.
Companies aren't required to prove their products are safe.
Companies aren't required to prove their products are effective.
The upside:
Some companies do submit their products to 3rd parties for testing and standardization (like United States Pharmacopeia - USP - that tests herbal products).
Anyway, herbs can be useful for a variety of things and as long as you are getting good herbs, they can work well in mild, non-severe cases. :)
@w1z111 (985)
• United States
6 Jun 11
Thanks for your informed and thorough input. I must say I agree mostly with what you outline here, and I appreciate that you shed light on some of the finer points of how some of these things work, and how many herbs have been tested and tried over the years.
No doubt early uses of plants for healing came quite naturally, since we know many animals do the same thing...so we probably would have known, at some level of unconscious awareness, which things would help which ailments. Indeed, I've read how some cultures would bring all their waste (human) to a central location to be buried; then, when the vegetation grew from the "enriched" soil, they'd use that vegetation to bolster their constitution, under the assumption that nature was producing specialized crops geared to counteract and redirect any "unhealthiness" detected in all the buried waste. Hmmmmm.....sounds a little off-the-wall, but also sounds plausible enough, given the power and wisdom of the forces of nature.
Anyway...I ramble...sorry. Thanks again for your input. "Best Response" for this one.
@babyEj (1522)
• Philippines
23 May 11
True! There are things naturally grow for human benefits. Before, I am not convinced to drink herbal meds when I was sick. Yet , I was in our hometown that time and there was no hospital. I got higher fever, My father boiled something and let me drank it. Then I got relief.
@w1z111 (985)
• United States
23 May 11
Indeed! Mother Nature takes very good care of her own. We know this by looking at the millions of years she has already done it. I think it's when we begin to introduce "man-made-diseases" that we are putting ourselves at odds with her. When we are exposed to health-harming food additives, consumer products, and other similar toxic-to-health substances, we somehow go beyond Mother Nature's realm; and she struggles with how to help, I think. Especially when we're also polluting her with our ignorant behaviors in many arenas. Somehow, I know she will ultimately resolve anything we can throw at her, but I'm not sure we'll be happy with her choice of resolutions. Hmmmm...
Thanks for your response. See also http://www.quing-it.com/ for product ingredient information.