Is it okay to have feelings for two different people?

United States
June 2, 2011 2:09pm CST
This is a question I have been asking myself for a long time and it stills bothers me. I have feelings for 2 different girls and this isn't even the first time. But is that kind of thing even okay? Thoughts???
1 person likes this
10 responses
@amaine (2027)
• Philippines
2 Jun 11
Hi, There is one reason why we have been given with one heart - not two. This is because our heart should belong to one person only. I don't want to start a debate here, and I believe that "loving someone" means that your feelings toward that person is loyal, pure and sincere. If you say that you have feelings for two different people, perhaps what you've felt isn't love at all. Because if you love one person, you won't look at other girls. It is possible that you're in love with another, and you care for another. It is also possible that you both admire these two ladies, but you really don't love them. LOVE is tricky - sometimes, it is mistaken by most individuals.
@amaine (2027)
• Philippines
3 Jun 11
Well, it's a relief to know that you're not in love! You know, it may just go away sooner or later. Perhaps you're both attracted to these two wonderful ladies, and you just have to settle your thoughts.
• United States
3 Jun 11
I agree with you, but I know I'm not in love. These are just good 'ole crushes, but an issue nonetheless!
1 person likes this
@maezee (41988)
• United States
3 Jun 11
I don't think it's right, but I also don't think it's uncommon. I'm sort of in the same rut - I have feelings for two different guys right now and I don't know which is worth pursuing. It's hard spot to be in, because once you make a decision you really can't go back on it without hurting anyone's feelings. I mean, two different guys (or girls, however which way you go) can offer two different things and it can be hard to pick and choose. But I think it's important to CHOOSE and stand by your decision.. No regrets.
• United States
3 Jun 11
That's a good point, and as much as I know that I have to pick, I'm also fearful that I might make the wrong decision. I think I'm too meticulous for no regrets :P. Good luck to you though!
@orang13 (723)
• Philippines
2 Jun 11
I guess you are just mistaken of who you truly love. I am torn between two guys too, but I always believe that the other one is better! Ofcourse you love differently, and you want them differently. So the best thing you could do is to weigh things out. Find what is really Love.
• United States
2 Jun 11
Thanks but I don't think it's love per say, that's pretty intense. Hope everything works out for you!
@marie2052 (3691)
• United States
2 Jun 11
As you go through life you will always meet someone that will share your interests and we get excited to share what we like. If you already have a girlfriend, and are looking at another. Make a list. Write down what qualities you like about each. Write down then a list of how YOU feel inside about each. Write down what each of these girls and you have in common. I think if you do this, you will find a common place in your heart in what to do in this situation. I was in high school and had a childhood sweetheart. We were together for 3 years. But then we were seperated by both of us joining the Army. Once I got out of the house and able to have a life of my own I realized he was my very best friend and someone I would love forever in a special way but not one I wanted to share my life with as a husband. We are still friends 40 years later, we still talk occasionally on the phone and internet, but to this day I know I made the right choice. Good Luck and make that list. you may be surprised what you find out about yourself.
• United States
2 Jun 11
Thank you so much! I actually did that kind of thing once before and the result was definitely to my liking. Thank you for reminding me of a method that really works!
@leegumz (15)
• Kenya
2 Jun 11
i don't know if it is right or wrong and i don't want to be the judge of that,all i know is that it is possible and it happens not only to me but to others too.i think you should the second girl a shot because if you really liked the first girl you would not have developed feelings for the second girl.
• United States
2 Jun 11
Thanks for the answer. The whole thing is a mess really. The first girl I have liked for a while and she is just amazing. The second girl is a really good friend of mine that I hung out with a lot and developed feelings for over time. Talk about trouble...
• United States
2 Jun 11
I think that it might just be infatuation or so called crushes in your situation. It is alright to have multiple crushes since they are crushes, but just don't float the boat by going for both of them at the same time. You should really think about it on who you really like more. For example, I have had feelings for my best friend for a while, but after being rejected multiple times, I tried to move on and dated another girl. After a month or so, it just didn't work out because I still had feelings for her. I liked my ex but it was probably because she reminded me of her. But now my best friend is my girlfriend. Best of luck!
• United States
2 Jun 11
That's a good answer and a good story! I try to distinguish between them and sort it out, but I'm sure you'll agree when I say easier said than done!!!
• Philippines
3 Jun 11
If you are in love, your mind will mot entertain other things or other people. So is you are really in love, you will just think of her, no one but her. Maybe, in your situation, you are just physically attracted to one or both of them.
@aerous (13434)
• Philippines
3 Jun 11
Makes sure that feeling is not a lust. Because it is impossible to love someone and love the others. Your being selfish in that way because you want to get more and more to apply your desire which is not okay...
@amyson (3498)
• Philippines
4 Jun 11
you need to decide because if your mind could not stick to one person it could lead to philandering issues and much worst if you already married may lead to adultery. you need to decide which girl you like to focus your solid attention or love the most. some beauty lies but the heart is not blind. so let your heart decides then let your mind do the final decision.
@besthope44 (12123)
• India
3 Jun 11
Hi Mohammed, As you said it yourself, it s no more love. Its just attraction you had on two girls. And wait for sometime as these thoughts will move away like flying clouds and you will no longer find them. Sometimes its age that matters, else you dont have to take it so serious, it will get out in time.