Will You Only Marry Someone From Your Religion, Caste or Faith
By angelsword
@angelsword (73)
India
June 9, 2011 2:45am CST
What is your take on it, if you say a yes or no or i dont care with reasons..we will have a heated debate here. The best response will be awarded as the best response. My woman belongs to a different religion and we haven't had any issues from it in the last 6 years. Please share your experiences and opinions here.
3 people like this
14 responses
@weirdo55 (77)
• Philippines
9 Jun 11
i think it's great that you and your partner haven't had any problems with that. but for me, i still think it's better if you believe in the same things (beliefs) so as to prevent any problems in the future. this is only my opinion, but in your case, i don't see any problem because you were doing fine. anyway, i'm only saying this because as per experience with some people i know, it usually caused some problems along the way because of contradicting beliefs. another would be when it comes to raising the children. if you have conflicting beliefs in how to raise up your kids, that'll probably pose a problem, unless you agree beforehand on how to do so. but then again, it's all in how you handle your relationship. if you love each other too much, then you should be willing to work things out no matter what. besides, when you get married, part of your vows would be for better or for worse, right? so you guys can figure it out together :) and you can make it work if you want to.
@angelsword (73)
• India
9 Jun 11
What problems can belief cause? Are these problems caused by the community we live amongst or us?
@weirdo55 (77)
• Philippines
9 Jun 11
not necessarily the community but it could arise from personal beliefs. if you have two contradicting beliefs, it would be a problem.. but i agree with youless that it's very important to respect each other's own beliefs and individuality. but let's say if you were to have kids, how will you teach them? which one will you let your kids follow? that's just my opinion. but for me, see that you've been together for 6 years and not having any problems with that, i'm sure you will be able to get through any difficulty or trial. best wishes to you and your future wife.. :)
@arnouardian (286)
• United States
9 Jun 11
yes, i will marry a woman from the same religion. i want to do it because the same religion will give us the same vision and direction to build a happy marriage life and to not confuse our children about what religion they should choose. i will not force them to choose the same religion as mine. but since their birth until 18 years old at least, they need guidance from parents about religion. so, i believe the same-religion marriage will make our marriage life easier and make our family more united.
@arnouardian (286)
• United States
9 Jun 11
what other member said in number 5 is totally right. of course there are some examples of successful marriage of people with different religion, and there are also some examples of unsuccessful marriage of people with the same religion. but just like every other case, we give opinion based on the general thing that happens.
for this marriage case, the general thing that happens is: people with same religion are most likely successful in marriage and people with different religion are most likely unsuccessful in marriage life.
however, this generalization is only valid when the couple is really religious or just a little bit religious. if the couple is not religious at all (only mention the same religion in their identity card for technical reasons), then it means the same or different religion will not matter to them. they still can have happy or sad marriage life regardless of what their religion is.
@angelsword (73)
• India
9 Jun 11
I totally respect your views, but problems can also happen if you are from the same religion, look at response no 5, what say huh??
@Galena (9110)
•
10 Jun 11
I'm Pagan. and more specifically (as that's a very broad umbrella) I'm Polytheistic, Pantheistic, and have heavy influences from Louisiana Voodoo and hold the Nine Noble Virtues as seen in Asatru to be of great importance in living a good life. I honour the Gods, the Lwa and the ancestors.
my husband. well he's not sure where he stands on religious matters, and is not that interested. he's a bit interested in Buddhism. but not greatly so.
and we're fine together.
I'm quite happy to be with someone that doesn't beleive in the same things I do, as long as they respect the things I beleive in. because my spiritual path is a very large part of my life. so if someone wasn't capable of respecting that, then they do not respect ME.
if you love someone, you need to respect their spiritual ways, as that is a part of them that goes right down to their very soul.
@angelsword (73)
• India
10 Jun 11
Hi Galena, from what you said it is clear and crystal that understanding and caring is what brings respect for each other. People like you and your husband are ideal role models for future generations. Happy views!
@youless (112586)
• Guangzhou, China
9 Jun 11
I don't think that couples should have the same religion. It is fine that we will believe in something different. We shall respect each other's choice rather than forcing another part to be the same. Many people say that I love him/her and I can do anything for her/him. But sometimes due to some reasons, such as the different religion, they will have a conflict. If they love each other so much, why not they respect to each other's religion?
I love China
@angelsword (73)
• India
9 Jun 11
I am a person who think like you. I totally respect the broad mindedness, but as we see in this discussion we have a lot of opinions here. This world is filled with so many communities and i think religion is what makes people stay as a community, other than that there are some spiritual side to it as well. Now keeping this in head what i want to know is the importance of religion in a marriage and how it is going to help. In future i dont think religion will influence marriages as people wont give religion much importance. So is religion to be counted or not while marrying someone. You can also contradict to the other responses as well if anyone disagree with him or her:)
@Graceekwenx (3160)
• Philippines
9 Jun 11
Welcome to Mylot Angelsword!
I prefer to marry someone who shares the same religion as I.
@Graceekwenx (3160)
• Philippines
11 Jun 11
Marrying someone from the same religion would mean there wont be any adjustments or compromises from both side on faith. One of the challenges in married life is the differences and surprises that you have to cope with. Since, both of you share the same ideals and beliefs, it wont be too hard.
@angelsword (73)
• India
9 Jun 11
Thank you Grace, can you tell me if you dont mind that what is the pros of marrying from same religion?
@amitgune (877)
• India
10 Jun 11
I think that love and marriage has got nothing to do with caste, religion or faith. Love is a bonding between two people. Marriage is merely an attestation of that love. I would rather marry a girl of another religion if I love her rather than marrying somone from my caste. Reason to go to a religious place is to worship, reason to go to a doctor is good medicine. Similarly reason to marry is love, nothing else.
@angelsword (73)
• India
11 Jun 11
Bravo! Now as someone mentioned in this discussion about what would be the situation of kids of such two different religious couples, how shall be these future community issues addressed by these couples when they are a minority community among the BIG LEAGUE couples...??
@angelsword (73)
• India
10 Jun 11
I respect you for your broadminded views on this topic. According to you love is what should end in marriage and after marriage there should be love, and religion got nothing to do there. But many people are not that way, they marry without love based on religion and various other caste factors. And in some cases parents are particular about what religion your partner should be. What is your opinion about such people?
@chiyosan (30183)
• Philippines
24 Jun 11
i think having the same faith, and belief would matter. i mean when both of you believes in two different things, i think it would always be the start of somethign taht can confuse your children. eventually it may pose as a problem... especially if the religion is really far of from each other.
@anurag3786 (6267)
• India
9 Jun 11
Yes I will marry with a girl who is of my religion. Because I am a Hindu religious person. So in my religion and in my caste there are no allow for marry with an out of religion girls. And I also want to marry with a girl who will be from my religion. And I always respect to my religion and follow their rules and regulations. So if my parents allow me for marrying with a girl who are not from my caste or religions then I can. Otherwise I will marry only from my religions.
@angelsword (73)
• India
9 Jun 11
So basically what you are trying to say is that your parents can influence your thoughts and your concept is that you will marry only from your faith. Why do you think being religious will do good to you and your partner?
@madteaparty (2748)
• Japan
9 Jun 11
I'm an atheist, so I don't have the problem of having to choose someone form my same "faith" . I prefer to date atheists too, as one of the qualities I want in my partner is for him or her to be an intelligent person
I suppose that when you're a religious person it might be a problem being with a person who doesn't believe exactly the things you do, but I can't really talk about that from experience.
@angelsword (73)
• India
9 Jun 11
Helloo, you are not just an atheist you are funny too. However i did not get what you meant by having a him or her as a partner. Are you an atheist who actually defies the law of nature as well? I guess i should put a crazy discussion on atheism as well.
@pogi253 (1596)
• Philippines
9 Jun 11
I think marriages are already tough. It only further confuses matters when two people have opposing beliefs about something as vital as religion. While there are some couples of different religions who successfully stay married, they are the exemption and not the rule.
It does have more to do with how sincere that person is in their religion of choice. For example, if someone calls themselves a Christian, but doesn't necessarily go to church or really is not involved in their religion, then it would not make much of a variance if they are married to someone of another religion.
There are people married of the similar religion who still disagree about some issues. Two Christians, where one partner is very sincere and the other partner is not, have difficulties to deal with. The sincere partner is disappointed that the other does not seem interested in something they hold so dear, and the other partner is irritated because the other person is too "in" to the religion and feels they are being preached to. So if two people of the same religion can disagree so much, marrying two people of dissimilar religions could only be harder. Still, as mentioned, there are some who make it work.
@angelsword (73)
• India
9 Jun 11
Man, that was some experienced talk out there. I totally accept to whatever you wrote and that is what we see these days and you gave us a big picture here. So what should i take this as, religion matters to you or it doesnt?
@ravisivan (14079)
• India
24 Jun 11
I would recommend marrying a person within the same religion. Many beliefs, ideas, expectations differ from one religion to another and causes embarrassment. I am happy to know that this has not caused any problem between you two--husband and wife--but that cannot the rule of the law.
The common rule is birds of the same feather flock together. Similarly people of the same religion will marry. Exceptions can be where you like the other person too much for money, status. It is because beauty fades away with time. opinions differ.
People marrying within the same religion also have problems. But this percentage is less.
@szz1990602 (188)
• China
9 Jun 11
Hello angelsword: from my perspective there will be some divergences if your better half has diffrent religion from you. My parents have the same religion and it would be better if my future wife can have the same faith with me. But religion shuolden't be the critical factor that affects our marriage. If you truly love your better half, you should accept and understand his or her religion.
@angelsword (73)
• India
9 Jun 11
You said divergences right, what can those be. And will it be there if there is proper understanding? I have seen issues that are severe arising from couples of the same faith due to lack of understanding, what is your take on it?
@frept83 (20)
• Philippines
9 Jun 11
To some religion is of importance. But for me, LOVE KNOWS NO BOUNDARIES. It simply conquers all. But of course, having the same religion also is good. Putting your religion and faith at the center of your relationship helps both of you to grow spiritually. A relationship that is faith-centered is a strong relationship too.
But then again, having the same religion or belief is NOT A MUST. You don't love a person just because of religion. You love the person for what he/she is.
@angelsword (73)
• India
9 Jun 11
You just broke it down plain and simple, but many over here dont agree with you as you can read from some responses here:)
@ellainepalma (37)
• Philippines
9 Jun 11
It's important for me to have the same outlook in life as my partner, not necessarily religion. If you are in love and don't have issues then I don't see that being a hindrance to both of you, I say go for it :) People from your own religion may not approve of it but it's your life and I think that if you are happy and can make it work then there's no reason to not pursue a relationship just because you have different religions.
@angelsword (73)
• India
9 Jun 11
You kept it short and simple and you did speak your heart out. I think from this discussion what I am starting to get is that people don't really care about religion if there is love. Let us see if someone is going to come up with a complete contradiction.