Random Hattred from loved ones

@sam2424 (110)
United States
June 20, 2011 9:07pm CST
OK this happened a wile back now but its always bothered the crap out of me and I'm still not sure what to think. Someone very very close to me in my immediate family and I were out for the day. We were at walmart and just slowly walking around, when two females of Muslim decent ( also dressed in burquaa's ) were approaching us. So "SHE" ( my family member ) stopped, turned to me and said " eghh Why don't they just go back from where they came." Now if it had been ANYBODY else I would have said something along the lines of Are You Fuc***g Kidding me, What The Hell is your Problem....as Ive done on other occasions. However I was so dumbfounded that these words came out of HER mouth, I couldn't even make a sound. She is the absolute last person in the history of Ever I would have expected this racist bull crap from. I mean Ive never heard her say anything remotely rude about anyone. She's super Churchy ( I'm not ) she's always saying nice things and to treat others well and god loves everyone.....I just don't get it. So I was just wondering if this has happened to anyone of you, if so what did you think, Did you say anything? Right Then....Thanks
2 people like this
6 responses
• United States
21 Jun 11
My sister's boyfriend said something similar. Not to anyone specific but we were on the subject at church... I'm not entirely sure how it even came up... but I think we were talking about muslim/racial profiling in airport security and he snarked that it was completely justified and he wouldn't let a muslim on a plane. At first I stared at him like I thought he was crazy and then I told him straight what I thought of that. He hasn't said anything of the sort since. People aren't perfect, and they can exhibit all the right behaviors and still say things that aren't right.
@sam2424 (110)
• United States
21 Jun 11
Wow, yeah I guess so. I never did collect my bearings enough to confront her on the subject. Although she did look at me right after she said it so she had to have seen the disgusted look on my face. Like I said, If it had been anyone else Id of easily cut them out of my life completely.
1 person likes this
@sid556 (30959)
• United States
21 Jun 11
I'm not a prejudiced person. I love the different cultures and people so I am glad that the US is the "melting pot" so to speak. I have met some wonderful people from all over. Still, I've made comments that I think could have been misconstrued. I really don't like that our government gives really cheap interest rate loans to foreign people to come over here and take over our convenience stores. They fire all the help and hire their family members and jack up all the prices. We, who are natives, could never get such a good deal. I hate how they help the other countries more than they help our own. I hate how when I call for help on a product or credit card that I get people who can't speak clear English! I hate how hard it is to find American-Made products and when you finally do...they are way out of your price range. I sometimes will make comments that could possibly be misunderstood. My animosity is not at all towards these people. It's towards our government that treats them way better than they do us. It is towards our government that gives them benefits that compromise ours. My daughter who has a little baby just got her hours cut at Wendy's. Why? because they are training foreigners and so her hours got cut from full time to 6 hours a week ...yes that makes me angry....she has a son to support! It's not them...who can blame them for taking the opportunity? It's our government for compromising our livlihood for foreign people. I think you should talk to your cousin. I 'll bet her anger is along these lines. Its not the people...it's our government.
2 people like this
• United States
21 Jun 11
Sam, if it happens again then you should let her know that it really bothers you and you think that saying such things is extremely hateful. If she really believes what she says and isn't just lashing out in a moment of weakness, then it'll be pretty clear in a heartbeat. Sid, I don't think it's fair to blame the government either. I'm pretty sure the government didn't make Wendy's cut your daughter's hours, and it doesn't require that all commerce be taken outside the US. Sometimes I feel like foreigners get special treatment too, but I don't really think that's the case. There's lots of things that our government gives us that they don't give to non-citizens... and immigrating here legally is actually very difficult for people just looking for new opportunity.
• Southend-On-Sea, England
21 Jun 11
Yes it's happened to me on a couple of occasions, although the two people concerned weren't members of my family. Both of these people, like the lady you speak of, have strong religious convictions (whereas I personally don't have), but I did take it upon myself to remind them that perhaps it would be a good idea to put their Christian philosophy of life into practice. I did try to say it as nicely as I could. Not sure if it worked or not though, either time.
@sam2424 (110)
• United States
23 Jun 11
I don't like to pry but did either of the people say anything back to you....and do you think you would have said something different if it were a close family member or would you have said anything at all....Thanks for the response.
• Southend-On-Sea, England
23 Jun 11
Hi and thanks for the reply. Both of these people reacted in a similar way, in that they each insisted they always follow their Christian values to the letter, and neither would back down. One of them broke off the friendship with me which was OK because if someone is unable to practice their convictions, then they probably don't make a good friend for me. The other one remained a friend, and after a period of coolness, we began to get on well together again. We now don't discuss things which could cause a huge difference of opinion. If ever we accidentally edge around doing so, one of us will say out loud that we're closing the conversation, and to move onto something else, as we're hitting controversial ground. As for the thought of if I'd have said something different were it have been a family member, I think I would have said the same thing. As none of my family are in any way religious, it's difficult to guess what response I'd get in that situation, but I doubt if I'd feel any kind of hostility towards such a family member - maybe I'd try to keep out of their way though if we were coming from and going to completely different places as people. I'd attempt to strike up a mutual tolerance situation I suppose. Hope that answers your questions....and thanks again for the reply. Have a good day!
@sid556 (30959)
• United States
21 Jun 11
That sounds really out of character. Either that or she covers up how she Really feels and let her guard down for a moment. I don't know. You say she is really close. I think I'd talk to her and ask just peacefully and out of curiosity. I would have to know so I'd talk to her.
@sam2424 (110)
• United States
23 Jun 11
It was definitely out of character, I'm now starting to think maybe I should bring it back up and just ask her strait out. Still not sure though, Id be lying if i said I wasn't afraid of her response. I don't know what id do if she confirmed my suspicions that she really felt that way. Anyway thanks thanks for the advise.
@Masihi (4413)
• Canada
21 Jun 11
I'll be honest, I personally have an issue with Islam and the actions of its followers, but on the other hand, I think it's downright rude to say stuff out loud in public. As an optimistic person I try to relax around them because I know they're not all bad people. My husband will openly open his yap about Muslims - he has a hatred towards them all. He sits there in public and make fun of how they talk and say as they're passing by that he'd like to put a bomb on them, it's crazy. Do as I did, speak to your relative about her feelings and get her side, and why she believes the way she does. Most reasonable people will open up and discuss their fears. I know I try to talk to my husband but unfortunately he has a one-track mind, so it's not much help reasoning with him.
• Philippines
22 Jun 11
So sad that you felt that way. You must settle it with your relative. If she had done nothing wrong, then forget about her lapses and weaknesses. You must understand that we don't always have the same thinking... Just allow her to express herself and you too...
@sam2424 (110)
• United States
23 Jun 11
Sound advice and very much appreciated. Its not very easy for me to just forget things especially something like this. I guess all the more reason for me to hear her reasoning I suppose.
• Philippines
21 Jun 11
It has happened to me before. A friend, who I also thought would not be able to utter those words said it to me when we saw two muslims at the mall. He said that Osama Bin Laden's people are about to approach us. I told him not to say things like that as it is considered as streotyping people. He said that it was just a joke,but still I did not think it was a good joke. Although we cannot dictate how they would think, I just hope that they realize that recism has a lot of form and is not a joke.
@sam2424 (110)
• United States
23 Jun 11
Absolutely, it would be awesome if nobody ever said such things or probably even more importantly if nobody ever even thought in such a way. I guess with so many people in the world and so many different view points and personality's that's nothing but an unreachable dream anymore. That's terrible what he said, so many people talk like that in a joking manner ( supposedly joking ) I guess its hard to truly know the feeling behind it but either way its hurtful and in return wrong. I think so anyway. Just curious did that in anyway affect your friendship are y'all still friends?