Repeating Kindergarten

United States
June 21, 2011 11:28am CST
Hello Again, boy it's been a while... but I hope to see some old friends are still around... and of course, new friends are welcome! So, it's a week before school lets out - we have a long year since we had so many snow days! I just had the big IEP meeting for my son, and it's been strongly suggested he repeat K. Quick update: DS will be 6 in Aug, so he started K about 2 weeks after he turned 5. On IEP for mild delays in academics - seems he's about 6 months behind in the material... Went head to head with school this year because they insisted he was ADD/ADHD. Secured a sp.ed. advocate to assist with IEP/evals/tests etc. Long and short of it: He's very immature for his age! He's not behind; he knows the material, he just doesn't do it consistantly. REALLY! So, because he was initially in sp.ed, he was out of district. We pulled him out of sp.ed. and put him in reg. class with a 45 min pull-out session daily. Now, in Sept, he's going to new school (district) and repeating Kindergarten. Not 100% surprised, not sad or anything, but still worrying about decision. Logically, I'm good with the decision; emotionally, I just don't know... Anyone?
2 people like this
7 responses
• United States
21 Jun 11
I don't think it's really necessary to repeat Kindergarten, and your son really shouldn't have to. If you know that he knows the material, then that should be enough. Talk to the principal or the school district about allowing him to move on, because you are going to be wasting so much time and money with the repetition of a grade. And it's probably best to get your soon as quick as he can to college with this unstable economy. And plus, Kindergarten isn't really a big deal. I don't know about you, but all we did in Kindergarten was learn how to write the alphabet and learn the basic skills of reading. I remember I was so confused with what the heck 1995 meant, when it was actually just the year. I think holding back should just wait until beginning with the 1st grade, as that is a crucial time for children. Kindergarten is just a taste of what is to come, and I don't think it really is that important. In first grade and on, you learn important writing skills and basic math skills that become the foundation for everything and anything you are going to learn in the future. Kindergarten? That's where you learn to color inside the box and where the fountain and the playground are. But ultimately it is up to you, and you should really think about it before deciding.
1 person likes this
• United States
22 Jun 11
Actually, these days pre-school is where you learn the alphabet and "coloring inside the box" and counting, etc. In Kindergarten you are already learning to read, write and do basic math - grouping, sorting, addition and subtraction. Plus, it does not cost to repeat a grade, and pushing a child through to get him or her to college sooner is really not a good idea, because you have to be able to have good grades and pass certain tests to be accepted to college. If a child is just pushed through school, then he or she most likely will not be able to pass the tests required to get into college.
• United States
23 Jun 11
Hello, thanks for the responses! Although you are right in that he should not 'have to' repeat K, as it's not required to enter 1st grade, the decision isn't about 'have to' or 'not have to'. It's about what is right for him, now and in the future. Also, you are correct about when we were in Kindergarten, although I was in K quite a number of years before you, the focus was on friends, sharings, coloring, playing and socializing. NOW - it's incredible what these little ones are expected to learn! As Purple stated, they are in fact already writing, reading, adding and subtracting! They have tests! REALLY - spelling tests on sight words. To us, it's natural to sound out and write a word... but we are so ingrained with every letter and its sound, we don't have to go thru "Rrr, "R" "Eee" "E" "Dee" D... then remember how do I make an R-E-D?? It's scary, but in todays educational world, it's actually preschool that the foundation is started, and they get right down to business in Kindergarten. I have to say, at this point, I'm not to focused on college... the extent of that worry stops at the savings account! It's so far away... I don't want to rush his school years. I want him to enjoy them, as I did. So, the long and short of it is, I have decided, and I'm pretty comfortable with my decision... NOW. Just a side thought: talking about foundations, if his brain is not completely ready to accept all this stuff, we can't force it. Filling anything up without the shell being stable will only lead to crumbled walls. Just an analogy someone made to me to see this for what it is. A parental decision made for the benefit of our child. Thank Again!
@Shellyann36 (11384)
• United States
21 Jun 11
My 20 year old had to repeat kindergarten as well. He just barely made the cut off to join the class for the year and the teacher felt he was immature socially. I did not like the idea and I did try to fight it. It did not end up in my favor with the exception that I requested a different teacher for him the following school year. In some ways I think the teacher just did not like him. It ended up turning out alright for him. The next year his teacher was better and his behavior during school was also better. I think in these situations alot depends on the teacher and on the environment of the classroom. The best way to look at is that he will have more time to really learn the information being presented to him and it will help him advance.
• United States
23 Jun 11
Hi Shelly, thanks for the response. I could fight it, and I would win, as K is not required to enter first grade in my state. But I did have to fight with his initial placement, as they placed him in a class with children with significant, serious behavioural issues... so I know what you mean about the environment. Also, he will do some things with one teacher, but refuses with another and vice versa, so neither teacher can get an accurate reading on his readiness! I do feel that the extra year will help his confidence and we have lots of adventures scheduled for the summer that are geared towards fun learning, gaining responsibilities, and stuff like that. I think come sept, he will realize it's not so strange or hard because he's already had a year of the material! Thanks again!
@deebomb (15304)
• United States
22 Jun 11
When my granddaughter was 4 years old we got her the program "hooked on phonics". She was eager to learn to read and had an easy time of it. But when her brother was about the same age he just ha a real hard time. When he was 5 and his 6th birthday fell in Nov. We were going to register him in kindergarten The teacher offered to test the kids for maturity for learning. Not all kids are ready to learn just because they reach a certain age. We had him tested and because of the results we waited a year. It really made a difference with his learning and his whole school experience. Just waiting that year gave him a big advantage that he wouldn't have had, had we sent him to school just because he was the right age. I think all kids should be given this test before they start school. It's a case of one situation fits all. They don't all learn to walk at the exact same age so why do we think they are all ready to learn at the same age? You did the right thing in sending your son to a different school and having him repeat kindergarten.
• United States
22 Jun 11
I think that it is definitely best to hold him back if he is not mature enough, especially since you said that he knows the material but does not do it consistently. If you push him through, then it might make him even more frustrated and less likely to be able to do the work not to mention that it might hurt his self-esteem if he is way behind the other children. If you give him the extra year, though, then he will have more time to mature. In addition, he has already done this work before, so he will be more confident about it and it will bolster his self-esteem, especially when he is able to do with work consistently. He might even be able to help out the other students, and that is a great way to help socialization.
@asyria51 (2861)
• United States
21 Jun 11
My cousin struggled with this same issue when her daughter was finishing kindergarten. (The daughter is now almost 17 and in all honors and AP classes). They did decide to have her repeat kindergarten mostly because she was so immature. She was still requesting naps at the end of kindergarten, she knew the names and sounds of letters but had some fine motor skill defecits. One thing about holding a child back at this age is that there is not a stigma among the children if he repeats Kindergarten, they do not understand the significance of it. When a child is held back/repeats a grade at older grade levels, there is more of a social stigma associated with it. See if your school has summer school as an option to work on skills and have possibly a different teacher to work on the some of the maturity/immaturity issues. The decision to put a child in a certain grade can happen as late as the day before school starts (at least in my school district).
1 person likes this
• United States
21 Jun 11
I think it's ok for him to repeat kindergarten. My mom taught kindergarten for 20 years and so often she's seen younger kids that were immature and just not as developed as the rest. It may not seem like a problem now, but being younger and immature than the rest can lead to problems later on schooling. I don't think it's that big of a deal to repeat kindergarten. The school isn't doing it because your son isn't smart, they're doing it for developmental purposes. In the long run, it'll be better for him because he'll be with kids more his own age and he'll mature more over the summer and develop new skills and improve the ones he already has.
1 person likes this
• United States
23 Jun 11
Hey there, thanks for the response! Sorry for the delay in getting back to you! You know, I do feel better with the decision. I know it's not because he's not smart, but his brain isn't ready for all that stuff! Developmentally, he's just not there, and it's not his fault, and it's not my fault... So I am hoping that the summer gives him the little extra time to settle down and mature. Thanks!
@shaggin (72141)
• United States
22 Jun 11
If he is not emtionally ready to go on to first grade then I think having him repeat kindergarten for another year is the best thing to do. I understand why you are worried about it and questioning if you are making the right decision but I really do feel that you are. I was young for my grade and it affected me right up until I graduated. I think if they had held me back a year I may have done a lot better.