is it okay for the woman to propose?
By asyria51
@asyria51 (2861)
United States
July 10, 2011 9:43pm CST
I know that it is the 21st century and women's rights and all, but I still am old fashioned and think that the man should propose. what would the woman offer in a proposal, especially if the man does not wear jewelry?
I was just curious as to what everyone thought about this topic.
1 person likes this
17 responses
@hardworkinggurl (37063)
• United States
11 Jul 11
Personally I do not see anything wrong with women proposing to their love one, but I can't see me doing so, as I am old fashion as you also. Though there are some women who do it as their boyfriend may be shy and sounds like it can all be okay. I have also heard that some men do no like for the women to propose as they feel offended.
I guess a women would know if the man likes it or not. I would prefer for me that the man proposes if marriage was for me.
@purplealabaster (22091)
• United States
11 Jul 11
I think that if I decided to propose to my man, and he was offended that I asked him to marry me, then I would definitely have my answer ... he would not be the right guy for me. I have never proposed, but it is something that I could see myself doing, and if my guy could not handle that, then I am certain that he could not handle me, especially for the rest of our lives.
@asyria51 (2861)
• United States
11 Jul 11
workinggurl-i agree that I would never do the proposing. Too much fear of rejection, and I really liked my now hubby getting down on a knee in front of all the people we were the closest with (friends wise).
purple-You are right that if he cannot handle you proposing then there is no way he could handle you for a lifetime.
@hardworkinggurl (37063)
• United States
11 Jul 11
Though I doubt I would ever propose myself. But I think it sort of works both ways for a man too, if he proposes and the woman gets offended and or rejected that could be a sign also. I definitely agree that if I was daring and the man was offended, then oh yeah a true sign there.
@ever_purple (522)
• Philippines
11 Jul 11
you know what asyria, i really have plans on proposing to a guy in the future. for me its cool and its fun and its showing your pure and genuine love for your man. i too before was kinda conservative about this matter but i have realized it doesn't matter if the man or the woman who propose...the matter is if the one whose being offered of the proposal say yes. and guys nowadays wears jewelry and on what we can offer for men..of course our everlasting love and care for them. =))
@purplealabaster (22091)
• United States
11 Jul 11
I think it is great that you are confident enough to be able to propose, Ever_Purple. I do not think that it is necessary for a woman to wait for the guy, and I think it is perfectly acceptable for the woman to propose.
@ever_purple (522)
• Philippines
13 Jul 11
im glad u guys agree with me..for me its really not important if the boy or the girl propose as long as u are both happy so be it!!right=))
@dbersales (37)
• Philippines
11 Jul 11
I perfectly agree. The most important thing is to be spontaneous - the freedom to express what you feel in your own way, without the inhibiting influence of social conventions. So as long as you are not hurting yourself or others, I don't think there is anything wrong with sometimes going against social conventions.
1 person likes this
@moneywinner (1864)
• Brazil
11 Jul 11
The worst thing is the fear of be rejected. Seriously, I would not know how I would get over if the guy refuses my propose. Maybe that's why women don't propose, usually they a lot more fear of being rejected than men.
@Rick1950 (1575)
• Lima, Peru
11 Jul 11
I agree with you that the man should propose in a relationship. I think it still is, although women have achieved greater independence. However, there may be exceptions but not usually.
@Awinds (2468)
• United States
11 Jul 11
I have never been able to adjust to this women proposing thing. It just doesn't feel right. I don't have a rational reason for the way I feel either.
Men and women are different. Our bodies and our minds are designed differently. There are just some things that are better suited to men, and some things that are better suited to women. I like the ideals of equal pay, voting rights and all that but I believe a woman is a woman and a man is a man. We have different tendencies. It just feels like proposing is one of those things better left to men. Besides, what could be more embarrassing for a man then to have his girlfriend get down in bended knee with a ring - especially in front of his buddies?
@Awinds (2468)
• United States
11 Jul 11
@asyria51 That seems to be true.
@XxshubhamxX If you really love someone, shouldn't you be willing to be wait for them, despite whatever society may say on the topic? :)
@XxshubhamxX (115)
• India
11 Jul 11
i tottaly agree wid u guyzz..BT dont forget we live in 21st century...here no one waits for anyone...i mean if a person has any feelings for anyone (irrespective of whether the person is he/she) then he or she should tell to that person...b'coz no one knows will ihe oder person will ask u out or not...so its better u express ur feelings ...nd about d women proposing thing,i think dats very sweet and ROMANTIC!
@tuborgbaba (38)
• India
11 Jul 11
its nt abt old fashioned ..... i thk guys should always propose first .
gals are the most sensitive and loving creatures .... i think they deserve to be proposed first ......
@XxshubhamxX (115)
• India
11 Jul 11
there are sum good and bad ones ..dats not only about d boys ..it's d whole damn world...even in a person there is said to exist an evil side and good side...so it depends from person to person ... and not all boys or girls are alike. amd no ane takes advantage of anyone ..bcoz when u r in a relationship ..everything happens regarding the mutual interst.
@XxshubhamxX (115)
• India
11 Jul 11
i agree wid u ..bt what if a girl has some feelings about a boy who is unaware of dat...so unless and untill a girrl wud giv him any clue or take the initiative..its gonna b the end of a story which cud hv been a romantic love story.
@tuborgbaba (38)
• India
11 Jul 11
dude boys r the most meanest creatures .... they cn take this bloody advantage and do horrible and horrid thgs you can nt even imagine.
never trust the boys on the love and romance factor , if ur proposing first .
@purplealabaster (22091)
• United States
11 Jul 11
I think that it is perfectly acceptable for a woman to propose to a man. Of course, the other way around is more "traditional", but everyone is not traditional, and I think that if it feels right, then there should not be a question. I really think that is the most important thing in any relationship ... that it feels "right" and not forced or rushed or anything.
@thatgirl13 (7294)
• South Korea
11 Jul 11
I am a girl and I would gladly propose if the guy was being a chicken hehe yes actually I would. I think it's perfectly okay for a girl to move the first step and it isn't a rule either, for a guy to propose. So yeah I would gladly do it if it were some guy I truley loved but I don't know what the guy would have thought about it
@alquizar (480)
• Philippines
12 Jul 11
I think it is not okay that the woman will propose to a man and it's awkward to see that way because we are all used to see that man is the one proposing and not woman.Man should be the one to propose to a woman because He will be the one responsible for the family or shall I say will be the head of the family.
@youaremylush (479)
• United States
11 Jul 11
I agree with you. I'm old fashioned about that as well. I would never propose to a guy or ask him out on a date. But I'm really strange :/
@asyria51 (2861)
• United States
11 Jul 11
I know that there are women out there, who made the first move when it came to going out with a guy. I kind of did with my husband. I told him to shut up (we were in college and he was being annoying), he (continuing this annoying behavior) told me to come over there and make him. So I did. I kissed him. we were both coming off of long distance relationships. There were obvious sparks, but he officially asked me out a few weeks later. He did the proposing, getting down on a knee and everything.
@bouncybug (614)
• South Africa
11 Jul 11
I'm also a little old fashioned and personally I would prefer it if the man proposed to me! But I don't think there is anything wrong with a woman proposing. I guess it just won't be a traditional proposal with a ring or anything, maybe it would just be more of a promise that the couple is going to get married that isn't sealed with anything tangible like a ring.
• United States
11 Jul 11
Asyria51 I thinks ok for the woman to propose but I would not recommend it and here is why. Its in a mans nature to pursue a woman and win her. Especially if he wants her bad enough. My aunt told me that a man that adores you should be the one who you give your love to if you love him back. I tell women everyday do not chase after a man because he will eventually loose interest in you after he gets what he wants, then leave! I don't need to explain what I mean do I? So in my opinion leave the proposing to the man.
@chayannejaye (136)
• Philippines
11 Jul 11
In this modern age, i think its okay for a woman to propose. however since weddings and proposals are so full of old traditions its a bit tricky on what to give. try giving him something manly like engagement watch maybe.
@gianni123 (25)
• United States
12 Jul 11
Although i'm young, i'd want to be proposed to not be the proposer... But i guess if the woman would WANT to propose, then she would first have to propose the IDEA of marriage. Then proceed with caution :)
@moneywinner (1864)
• Brazil
11 Jul 11
I think if the woman is secure enough, she can propose a guy to marry her. Just like what happened on Friends with Monica and Chandler, she was going to propose to him, but in the end, he did the request.
For me, I still think is pretty weird to imagine myself proposing to someone. I probably would prefer to wait for the guy do that, but I never really like someone, maybe I will change my mind.
@nurseclare (2209)
• Philippines
11 Jul 11
hahaha, funny thing asyria51, I will never propose to a man. That's so cheap and disgusting! Whatever will happen to the relationship the girl got the blame!Oh gosh, that's unimaginable!
@jdex_143 (1093)
• Philippines
11 Jul 11
Hi, asyria!
I don't know if it feels right if a woman proposes to a man. I think it's awkward. As I've known, it's always the guy who proposes a marriage for a woman. But, I've heard stories of a woman proposing to a man. If my memory serves me well, the woman gave a ring to the man. It's funny though but you will see that the woman is really into the guy. :)