GF telling to be friends
@Princelierocks (817)
India
July 13, 2011 7:18am CST
hey guys iam in a relationship with a girl for a year, and we have been having some conflicts, and she has health problems too, so what is happening around is my GF is telling that her parents have brought a relationship for her, she is one year elder to me and as iam younger and still learning its becoming difficult for her to wait because i might take lot of time to settle for a job, She doesn't want to leave me depressed because i supported her in health problems, she wants me in every phase of life, she says that she is really confused and wants me to be her close friends, guys iam really pissed out too my GF is asking me to be friends, i understand her problems and i know that its difficult for her to stay with me because of conflicts with family and some personal problems, but i know in matter of time it would be settle. but the issue is time only. Guys this is a stage of sacrifice for me and its really very hard please help me iam need help desperately.
3 people like this
9 responses
@SpikeTheLobster (6403)
•
13 Jul 11
Personally, I'd say "in or out".
If you're "in", she has to be too or you have to be willing to love her and sacrifice for her with nothing in return but her friendship.
If you're "out", then you're just friends and you go out and find yourself a new girlfriend. You don't sacrifice any more for her than you would for any other friend.
Call me a cynic but this is one of the oldest manipulations in the book. She may not mean it badly but she wants you to be her boyfriend and commit everything to her for just friendship in return, so that she won't have any problems.
It doesn't work like that in my book: if she loves you and wants you as a boyfriend, she'll face those difficulties and be willing to sacrifice for you, as you will for her. If not, then she's just a friend and can't expect any more from you than the same kindness you show to any other friend.
She wants everything and isn't willing to give as much in return. That's a no-go, as far as I'm concerned, unless you want to spend years sacrificing and watch her go off with someone else in the future. Someone her parents approve of.
She has to make a choice. Simple as that. Anything else isn't love.
1 person likes this
@Princelierocks (817)
• India
13 Jul 11
okkk quite a hard reply but thanks for suggesting
2 people like this
@thinkingoutloud (6127)
• Canada
13 Jul 11
Spike, I have to say this an awesome, shoot-from-the-hip response and I applaud you for putting it on the table this way I'm female and I have seen exactly what you describe soooo many times. In fact, when I was younger, I was in this kind of situation. My parents didn't approve of the guy I was dating because I was 16 and he was 24. He was also of another ethnic background and, even though they wouldn't admit it, I know that was a factor. I knew that I could never make it work between him and my parents and I ended the relationship. It was not right to string him along and make him think we had a future when I knew that I was not strong enough to go toe to toe with my father on it.
I agree that the Princelierocks' girlfriend wants the best of all worlds for herself here... she doesn't want him to leave her but she doesn't want to disobey her parents. She either has to stand on her own two feet and commit to being in a relationship with him or she needs to let him find someone who is fully free to be with him. It's very easy when someone provides emotional support (especially during health problems) to want to keep them around - but love is about MUCH more than that and if she can't give her all then I agree that he deserves better.
1 person likes this
@SpikeTheLobster (6403)
•
13 Jul 11
I know it's hard but I've been in the situation before. Too often. And it's always the nice guy who gets treated like a third-rate person, usually when the girl meets Mr. Not Right At All and marries him or something equally stupid.
Obviously, I can only speak from personal experience but I know this kind of thing would make me run a mile. I don't see the point in trying to maintain a relationship if it's all one-sided. You (and I) deserve better than that.
1 person likes this
@vivamir (671)
•
13 Jul 11
Maybe a little distance will do you both some good.. I have been separated from my ex (of 4 years) for nearly a year, since our separation- we have both managed to 'grow' a little, understand each other so much more..
Thing is we didnt remain friends.. but we were the best of lovers..
I just hope this helps..its awful when you realize your mistakes and you can only learn through moving on..
If she is 'love' then she wont be going anywhere.. she will know that what you have done for her, and that no other will..
Good luck and best wishes to you Princelierocks..(",)
1 person likes this
@Princelierocks (817)
• India
13 Jul 11
hey thanks for your suggestion my current relationship status is such a thing that we are currently having a break just because of problems and that's killing me too i didnt want to have a break but she insisted me too, and on top of that many family problems and health problems of her. I just want some open communication with her for sometime to sort all these things out, and i think lot of patience is required.
@Sanitary (3968)
• Singapore
14 Jul 11
IT's not easy for a relationship for parents are objecting to it. Though relationship is supposed to be between both of u, however u have to consider about her feelings, she's being sandwiched between u and her parents. She's facing greater stress than u do, on top of her health issues. If u really love her, u should make her happy. Though u can't be there for her as a bf, u can be there as a friend too. Let her family members see how much she means to u. Let actions do all the talking and time prove your love for her.
@Princelierocks (817)
• India
14 Jul 11
hey sanitary thanks, that's such an awesome thing you said, you know what my mind was telling me to move on but regarding her stress and depression i knew she couldn't go further that's why she needs me, i guess i have to listen to my heart after all actions work fine rather thank words, thanks once again, i will sacrifice my love for her benefit.
1 person likes this
@lilbabycatapillar (497)
• United States
13 Jul 11
I could never understand why people want to make buddies out of their relationships, especially the serious ones. I don't like the sound of it. It' just that, my brother had a girlfriend for a long time, a few years, and she became part of the family, and my illegitimate sister. Maybe about a year ago they started having problems, and right now she's sometimes at our house, but they're just friends. I know she doesn't want it to be that way, but there's not much she can do other than stay around him.
If you think you can survive being friends with her, by all means you should. But if you think that you'll just be hanging on to something that will never be love again, maybe it's best that you just let go. I'm not sure how old you are, but if you're young, maybe you shouldn't tie yourself down with a relationship if it has so many problems that you have to try to just be friends.
Will everything really be okay later? How long will it be? Things change in time, and odds are you'll never have your relationship back. Are you going to date other people, in the meantime? Will she?
I don't think it is worth it, if after all of that, you're going to be just a friend to her. I don't think it's fair.
1 person likes this
@Princelierocks (817)
• India
13 Jul 11
hie lilababy i too can't say about things what will happen later on, she is really depressed, and has lot of health problems, sometime thoughts come to my mind that she is just using me for her own benefit, but in actual when i see her problems my heart says not to leave her i think being friends is ok if that's what she wants, instead of having nothing at least i will have a close friend. Its hard but i think in matter of time things will be ok.
@llooll519 (108)
• Portugal
13 Jul 11
In my opinion, you must support her in her decisions and try to help her with her family conflicts, it's the only way for your relationship settle.
I know that things like that make a guy piss*d out, but try to "ignore" your feelings and help her first... She will see that she was wrong when she said that she just wanted you to be close friends at the moment :)
1 person likes this
@Princelierocks (817)
• India
13 Jul 11
okkk thanks for the motivation, i guess i should just keep love aside and help her in her decisions. I think its only way i can go through
1 person likes this
@strawberrychocodahi (4818)
• Philippines
13 Jul 11
I guess you will have more problems if you continue since you said the parents interfere. You are from Mumbai, so I assumed that you're Indian( just correct me if I am wrong) and in India most of what is happening is parental arrangement, I just don't know about your status.
Anyway since the girl said that you should be friends, then accept it now and move on with life. It is important to establish your own self first so that you can prove something to the person you will love in the future. It will be hard for you, but it will be worth it as you don't realize it for now.
@Princelierocks (817)
• India
14 Jul 11
yes you said it right our main problem is because of the parental agreement and most of the relationships have issues because of this, its not like her parents are not agreeing but since iam a college going guy she can't even tell her parents, after all on what basis will her parents except me with no job, So i think it will be hard but i guess i have to move on and stand on my own feet first. thanks for suggestion
@readandtell (31)
• India
14 Jul 11
u need to tell her that the way of love is hard. She cant juz expect that everything would be rosy. I understand that her parents are pressing her, but she needs to take a staand in front of them for u.
If she cant do it, then she aint worth it. Trust me.
@Princelierocks (817)
• India
14 Jul 11
Yeah i totally agree with you and she is ready to stand in front of me, but the only thing is iam not on a job iam still a student and in our Indian culture parents are very possessive about this, they always find a boy for a girl who will support her through life financially and mentally, and for me getting on a job is gonna take few years.
@omarfw (50)
• United States
13 Jul 11
A relationship should always be based around want, not need. You shouldn't ever need someone to get through your life, but there's nothing wrong with wanting someone to be there.
If you find yourself depending on someone too much, chances are you are actually better off separating yourself from that person in the long run. You have been given a good opportunity here.
@Princelierocks (817)
• India
14 Jul 11
I guess iam too dependent on my partner because the first fact is i can't live without her and if she lives i will just be depressed through life so i have to build myself first thanks for the response and giving the true meaning of relationship.