Giving money to charity
By la_chique
@la_chique (1498)
July 25, 2011 5:12pm CST
For all my life, I've strongly believed that giving money to charities is a bad idea.
When I was little, my parents used to do concerts, and all the money they raised went towards equipment to keep babies alive.
They bought an incubator for the SCBU where I was born, and they bought several apnea alarms to alert parents if their babies stopped breathing and lent these out to parents who had had children die from cot death.
As I got older and my parents had more kids, they couldnt really keep up with the concerts, but they never stopped their spirit of helping others. We had a very elderly couple who lived next door to us and my mum would sometimes cook a bit more food when she was making our dinner, and we'd take it next door so the neighbours didnt have to cook. When the old lady died, her husband was distraught but too proud to accept help from a carer, even though he was in his 90s. For about 7 years, my mum carried on making him meals that he just needed to pop in his microwave whenever he was hungry. Because my mum would send her own pots round, he'd send them back dirty so he didnt need to wash up.
As I was growing up, I learnt the true meaning of charity. Me and my mum would go to blind society groups, and help the blind people to play games and socialise with each other. When I was 16, I raised money by playing flute concerts and raised enough money to pay for my flights, accomodation and money to go to Lourdes, a holy land in France where people get healed. I didnt do this for me, I did this to volunteer to help others find some peace and feel as though they were being healed. For a whole week, I woke early to help disabled people get ready to go out, then I'd push wheelchairs around in the swealtering heat, in a hilly place, but I didnt mind. I knew it was appreciated.
By the way - my mum was totally blind. She did all these things with no sight. Totally selflessly but because she liked to help people.
I dont throw money at collection boxes. I dont donate $5 a month to whatever.
I would far rather help an old lady cross the street, buy a toy for a disadvantaged kid in the local homeless shelter, donate knitted baby clothes to a premature baby unit or even go to a foreign country to help people right there, where I'm needed.
Its shocking, but things like the link I will paste at the bottom of this post happens all the time. Money for charities often goes to waste. High amounts go to admin costs - greedy paid 'charity' workers. Often help is seen as being offensive. How would you like it if you thought you were living in a quiet traditional community and someone came along and told you that you needed help? That is what can happen in old fasioned, traditional african villages, where mud huts are just a way of life for them. Again, forcing vaccines on people whose culture is scared of western medicine, and are quite happy to stick with their witch doctor. Who is to say who is right or wrong? And then this village, one of many where the African government will not allow it to open even though it will house 40000 people - money gone to waste.
If Africa was my main priority, rather than thowing money at Oxfam, I'd save my money, go to africa myself and help those who actually need it.
As it goes though, there are plenty of people on my doorstep who need my help so that is where my priorities lie. I do what I can when I can. Only the other day, I stopped at the side of the road in the pouring rain to help someone who's car battery had run flat. Gave them a jump start.
So I'm just intrigued to know, do you give money to charity, or do you feel the same way as me?
Here's the link by the way to this ridiculous story! Just one example of many why I feel that giving money to charity is very pointless when you cant control what happens to it:
http://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/africa/famine-victims-refused-access-to-kenyas-showpiece-refugee-camp-2319924.html
3 people like this
7 responses
@mickitiro (26)
• Philippines
26 Jul 11
You and your family is the perfect example of what charity is! I agree with your point of view though I think also that giving to charities depends on which you are giving to. The late Mother Teresa was able to do what she did because of volunteers and donations from everywhere. But let me not take anything away from what you have been doing, you are quite right. Charity really is helping however you can, whatever you can share with, with whoever needs it. You do not need to do grandiose things, you only have to give of yourself anywhere you are needed, whenever you are needed. Charity as you say, is needed right there at our own doorstep, we only need to act. I do whatever I can to help someone who needs my help here and now, but at the same time, I give something to my favorite ministries who care for the aged, the oppressed and the disadvantaged. Thank you for the link, it is an eye-opener!
@la_chique (1498)
•
26 Jul 11
Take the example of Mother Teresa and maybe something that she would need a monetary donation for: money to pay for a poor family's lodgings for a month. I think I would far rather contact a reputable housing agency in a poor area and pay for a tenant's rent for a month. They would not know who had done this for them, but that would be one month where they would not need to find the money to pay their rent. Although I would not know exactly who that person was, or maybe even how many people were living there, I would not have that information anyway if I had given the money to a charity, and at least I would know that it had reached the people the money had been intended for.
@pepperpopper (376)
• Philippines
26 Jul 11
I think that's also a bad idea. You are just giving them the reason to beg for food and become lazy. If they know that someone is helping them, they will not force themselves to find a job and earn money. I think, the government must organize or develop a project that would help poor people in a long run. say, a livelihood where they can earn money. They have to sweat it out. Moreover, i really hate those artist, singers who are organizing a concert and will say that a part of the income will go to the charity. That's so stupid. I think they just wanna make money out of it and showcase their talent. And just using the poor for their own gain.
@la_chique (1498)
•
27 Jul 11
Yes, I agree that we should be teaching people in poorer countries our entrepreneurial skills, and educating them about living. It is pointless giving more and more everyday essentials just because they dont have the skills, or are too lazy to use them.
@KrauseHome (36447)
• United States
29 Jul 11
Personally I am like you. I prefer to help charities that are local where I know need the help and financial support, or who need food donations etc. to help people locally. I think personally if you know you are helping those close to where you live and able to see the benefits there you often feel a little better and usually will be Thanked for it more. Because personally one day it could be you, and you know that if you do unto others they will do unto you.
@AmbiePam (94517)
• United States
26 Jul 11
There are a couple of sites, one sent to me from a mylot friend although I did not bookmark it, that show how much of the money given to each charity goes to over head and how much goes here and there, and how much actually makes it to the people. I like knowing which charities are really dedicated to getting to the base of people's needs. I give 10% of my income to my church. I know where that is going. But I'd like to be more like my dad as well. He gets in the trenches with people who need help. He's there to do things for those who need it. Fixing wiring in their home, taking an elderly lady to the doctor because she has no transportation, literally giving the jacket off of his back to a man on the street who had none. I want to be more like that. He also gives 10% to the church, but he does a lot more than that.
@ebuscat (5935)
• Philippines
26 Jul 11
For me yes it is good keep up the good work because many person who is needed for your money it is good to gave than to receive.
@tiffnkeat (1673)
• Singapore
26 Jul 11
Whatever you give, let it go. Your heart has been extended, no need to chase after it. Your charity may be abused or misused, but if you keep tracking it, it will pull and break you after a while.
Give what you intend, and don't look at it anymore.
@hardworkinggurl (37063)
• United States
26 Jul 11
It is truly sad and terrible to hear that our efforts in charity are being misused. I use to donate quite a bit years ago until I found out a great many were abusing the charitable earnings. I do donate but to trustworthy causes and The Red Cross and The Ronald McDonald's children charities are the two I exclusively trust.
I also donate locally when I can but her we get quarterly reporting's of where are charitable money goes and how it was spent. It is sad to hear that sometimes the organization do take advantage and used the charities wrongly.