Do you want to be right or happy?
By scheng1
@scheng1 (24649)
Singapore
August 9, 2011 10:11am CST
All of us have a strong sense of justice.
We like to do things that are right, or more accurately, feel right to us.
Sometimes we carry things too far, in that we hurt the other party when we feel we are right.
We just want to win the argument, and force the other person to admit his mistake.
This kind of self-righteousness always bring unhappiness to ourselves or our friends and family.
Do you think it is better to keep quiet even when we know that we are right?
Do you think that keeping peace is more important than winning argument?
Do you want to be right or happy?
2 people like this
7 responses
@vicereine (451)
• United States
9 Aug 11
I think that you should be able to be happy but also help someone when they are wrong. The point of letting someone know they made a mistake is not simply to hurt them but to show them a new way of looking at things or the correct way of looking at them. I believe that there is a way to let someone know that they are incorrect without hurting their feelings. You don't have to be cruel and obnoxious about letting them know they got something wrong. I think it is like when children are in school, the teachers let them know politely that they have made an error and how they can correct it. So if children can be shown a proper way of doing things or that they have been mistaken so to can adults.
@scheng1 (24649)
• Singapore
10 Aug 11
Hi Vicereine, and Gavrilovich, actually most of the times there are no absolute right or wrong.
I think most of us are too fond of pointing out the opinions of others are wrong, and tell them directly.
Probably keeping quiet is the wise choice in most cases.
Sometimes, when emotions come into picture, no matter how well meaning you are, you cannot change other people.
Try telling someone when she is madly in love that she should not love a guy who would make use of her!
I think many parents have this dilemma.
They cannot keep quiet, because they want the best for their children.
If they nag too much, their kids run away.
@vicereine (451)
• United States
10 Aug 11
First thank you very much Gavrilovich for the compliment and Scheng1 you are right to a certain extent that there is no true right or wrong. As I have stated though I used an example from children in school and for them there is a right and wrong in their studies. I also believe that in your case where your parents are trying to tell you right from wrong because they have been there before. The reason parents are as you say "nagging" is because they want the best for you and want to help you. Grant it some parents go about it the wrong way and are cruel about it but you can help steer your kids in the correct direction when you speak to them on an equal level. Also in some cases you need to not keep quiet because how will the other person learn a correct way of doing things or learn how to handle the same kind of situation? There is a way to be both happy and correct however, being correct is not always the sole reason for being happy.
@tiffnkeat (1673)
• Singapore
10 Aug 11
When I read the question and then your explanation, the first few things that came to my mind are:
1) Is our sense of right really right?
2) whose happiness are we protecting?
I will start with the second. If the happiness is for those around us, I might choose to be happy than to be right. If the happiness does not revolve around the loved ones, then I rather choose to be right. In that case, being right is more important. I cannot be happy knowing I do wrong.
Then again, as I said, would I really be right even then? Well, even if I am not, at least I won't be upset thinking that I did "right". Haha...
@scheng1 (24649)
• Singapore
12 Aug 11
Hi Tiffnkeat, I think you have read too many philosophical books!
Your comment uses so many words, and yet nothing is clear.
I do think it depends on the circumstances.
I doubt you dare to tell your boss that you argue with him whole day just to prove that you are right!
I think you will be out of a job very soon.
I think in this case, you are protecting your job, and the money that comes with it.
Maybe on your last day at work, then you can go around and argue with everyone until they turn purple.
@polaris77 (2039)
• Bacau, Romania
9 Aug 11
I think it depends on the situation,I usually prefer to give up even if I'm quite sure that I'm right rather than cause an argument and disturb the harmony,but there are also moments when I have to stand up and defend my points of view.My attitude also depends on the person I am facing and its character:if I know that it's a strong person who doesn't get upset for being contradicted I do it,if not I give up for the sake of peace.
@scheng1 (24649)
• Singapore
11 Aug 11
Hi Polaris, yes, I would do the same thing too.
If being right is not that important, then I just give up.
Some people are too argumentative, and even if they win the argument, they lose the respect of their friends and colleagues.
I think it is better to maintain good relationship, even if we are right, and everyone else is wrong.
Sometimes it turns out that we are wrong, and we would not be so embarrassed if we stop arguing way before we are proven wrong.
@alquizar (480)
• Philippines
10 Aug 11
I think if people is happy we can be on the right track.It is really a nice feeling to feel happy always despite of the difficulties in life because we will be able to brighten our day even if others can't do it for us.We are always in the mood to accompish things that has to be done.
@scheng1 (24649)
• Singapore
12 Aug 11
Hi Alquizar, yes, I agree with you.
If people are happy, and especially when they are happy with us, it is easier to get them to accept their mistakes or wrong assumptions when we tell them.
I think having a good relationship with people is very important.
We all hate to go home, and then quarrel the whole night with our family members, and we hate to go to work and quarrel with everyone.
Best to keep quiet at times, and enjoy a cordial relationship with everyone.
@scheng1 (24649)
• Singapore
12 Aug 11
Hi Zerd, I think that will depend on circumstances.
Most people do not mind getting wrong or you telling they are wrong in small matters.
But if you insist you are right, and your boss is wrong, then you are asking for trouble.
Even if you are the best worker, you might not get promoted or a higher bonus.
Your boss might even fire you because he does not like you.
@pepperpopper (376)
• Philippines
10 Aug 11
It depends. Actually, I do not stop arguing until the truth reveals. I just wanna hear the truth. Honesty is the key.That is what makes me satisfied.
@scheng1 (24649)
• Singapore
12 Aug 11
Hi Pepperpopper, yes, it all depends.
We can argue all we want in school, and our teachers may even praise us for our creativity and all those good qualities.
But in the workplace, we cannot do that, and still expect our bosses to give us a job.
I think even if we are right, and our bosses are wrong, we should just keep our mouth shut, unless they ask for our contributions.
@Rainbowliselle (498)
• Philippines
9 Aug 11
I don't argue for the sake of arguing but I can't just keep my mouth especially on topics which I know quite well or have read about. The problem sometimes is that when we speak out our mind, we are being labeled as the someone who easily react at almost everything. I might say that it would be better to keep quite and not get into any discussion or argument; however, when you know that what is being discussed is really not true, would you still prefer to the peace you wish for instead of trying to make them see things the right way?
@scheng1 (24649)
• Singapore
10 Aug 11
Hi Rainbowliselle, same here, I tend to talk too much when I know I am right.
Sometimes it takes years for our colleagues or friends to realize that we are right, but then we are labelled wrongly for a long time.
I think if we are older, and can control our tongue better, then we know that keeping quiet is better.
Even if someone wants us to express our opinion, we can do so without making others angry or embarrassed.