Can love exist without hate?
By Awinds
@Awinds (2468)
United States
August 29, 2011 6:49pm CST
Can the concept of love as we know it exist without its polar opposite hate? If there was no hate could we really define love? Without the opposite emotion, is it possible to have a true understanding of love? If hate did not exist, would love not exist either?
Or is love independent of hate? Can love exist in complete fullness without hate? One defines (or at last helps to clarify) the other. Despite that relationship, can love be separate from hate?
3 people like this
17 responses
@celticeagle (166911)
• Boise, Idaho
30 Aug 11
I think that love could exist if there was not hate. It would be a different kind of love because we wouldn't have hate to measure it by. Without the two extremes one extreme would not be as extreme. It would be muffled and understated. They say there is a thin line between love and hate but with out hate how would we know?
@celticeagle (166911)
• Boise, Idaho
31 Aug 11
Yes, it would be quite different. We need to have our options open and be able to see what different feelings are like. Learning hatred is a horrible thing.
@2008chrys300 (17)
• Philippines
2 Sep 11
I agree with wrkrbe. For the world in general love exists and so does hate, and one is the opposite of the other. They do not necessarily have to be both present in one individual, although they may be applied to one person (sometimes at the same instance).
There are people you love, like your family and friends. There are people whom you would rather hate, like bigots and racists and traitors. Sometimes a person you love dearly, because of something he/she has done (like a betrayal), causes you to hate him/her. In which case, you can find yourself crossing back and forth over that fine line between love and hate.
There was a song way back in the 80's that goes "I love you, hate you, love you, hate you, but I want you 'til the world stops turning..."
@suspenseful (40193)
• Canada
30 Aug 11
I do know that both exists. For instance one, cannot love the devil and love God at the same time, since the devil is evil and God is good.
On a more profane basis, you can love a person and yet hate the things he does - such as keeping the toilet seat up. You can hate evil, although you pray for a person to change his mind. So both do exist.
@suspenseful (40193)
• Canada
31 Aug 11
Actually love did exist in the Universe before Satan disobeyed God and wanted to be the greater power. He then rebelled against God, and brought sin into the world. So now love exists along with hate, but before it was not so. The reason was because in the beginning everything was perfect - God had made it so. But now there is evil and we of course cannot love evil.
1) in the beginning it was perfect and there was love.
2) Satan rebelled against God and did things opposite to what God wanted. such as murderous thoughts, etc.
3) now we have evil in the world.
4) We cannot love evil.
So now love can exist without evil, but now it is impossible. Because the evil is here.
Oh we must not love ev il. or even evil people.
@suspenseful (40193)
• Canada
31 Aug 11
Oh and Satan persuaded Adam and Eve to disobeying God by eating the forbidden fruit that contained the evil virus or whatever you call it and that entered their whole being. So we are sort of stuck fighting against evil all our lives.
@dpk262006 (58676)
• Delhi, India
30 Aug 11
Hi Aw!
I think love and hate should not treated as opposite, as you would treat 'truth' and 'lie'. Do you mean to say that first we need to hate a person then love will grow? I do not think so. Else, we love a person and then we start hating him or her and thereafter again start loving him or her, then there would be more love? As far as am concerned, I do not believe in hating anybody. It could happen that I may not like certain traits in a person, however, that does not mean that I would stop loving that person. Loving someone is a positive trait and I believe in positivity.
@Awinds (2468)
• United States
30 Aug 11
I was actually more along the lines of asking this: can the concept, the feeling of love exist without hate? Could we know in full what love is if the feeling of hate did not exist? I ask because hate and love help to define each other and if one of those feelings was to not exist tomorrow, we might have a harder time understanding love. :)
I do agree though that hating someone should be something we do. Hate is a bitter poison that damages our ability to love and hate overall is just for us.
@Lore2009 (7378)
• United States
6 Sep 11
Interesting... I was with someone who I thought I loved for a long time while never experiencing hate. But once I hated him, I do realized how much I did care for that person yet, I also have a better understanding of what I was lacking in our 'love'.
@tenrajj (911)
• Bhutan
30 Aug 11
You are very right. Without darkness, we would not have been able to identify light. If there is not darkness how would we have identified light as light. So it is same for love and hatred. If there is not hatred, then we would not have been able to recognize love. If there isn't somebody who hates you, then we would not be able to identify who loves you..
@Triple0 (1904)
• Australia
30 Aug 11
That's a great way to put it! It's isn't complete without the other. The world works in opposite ways. When we have one thing, there will always be another which will oppose it. We're all human and we're all vulnerable. We have our flaws, we just got to learn and try our best to spread the love.
@voracious (624)
• Philippines
30 Aug 11
Biblicaly speaking love should exist without hate because there's no such thing as love is hate.
@Awinds (2468)
• United States
30 Aug 11
Following that train of thought, isn't it possible that love can not exist without hate? The Bible says God is love. It also says that Satan is thoroughly evil - which would mean he is hate or at least has it in him. Two extremes. Could God's love or Satan's hate be clearly understood without the other extreme? :)
@voracious (624)
• Philippines
31 Aug 11
Yes it's possible that love can exist without hate if we are in heaven which is free from sorrow and hate ^^
@sarahruthbeth22 (43143)
• United States
30 Aug 11
Yes I think so. Because there are many who only have love in their life and others only hate. It isn't like the G-d and Devil battle.Where one Must be there to keep the balance. In fact many don't see them as polar opposites. The true opposite of love is indifference. So yes love can and does exist without hate.
@sarahruthbeth22 (43143)
• United States
30 Aug 11
And that is why indifference is the opposite of both. That is why they say there is a thin line between love and hate.
@dandan07 (1906)
• China
1 Sep 11
I think love and hate is like two sides on a coin, if you have one, it seems impossible for you do not have another. But you can choose which one on the table.
When you love some one, the one who hurt him/her will be the one you hate.
Do not try to keep the hate away, but think less about it is ok enough.
@unique16 (1531)
• United States
30 Aug 11
Very interesting question. Are born loving or do learn to hate as our brains watch and observe others hating? I think as children we are loving creaters. I think hate is learned emotions and helps to clarify what love is... We all strive to love people but mental probrlems and environmental issues create hate... the same with sadness. Were we born to be sad.. I do not think so.
Thanks Unique16
@jeanneyvonne (5501)
• Philippines
30 Aug 11
I think the two emotions are very related to each other and it will not be easily for a person (especially if there are in love) to feel a pang of hate every now and then. Love, like every other emotion, can change is the quickest of time and depending on the intensity of the emotion, it can turn for the best or the worst.
Though hate isn't exactly the antithesis of love, it is usually the the common emotion associated with love as its counterpart. I guess intensity is something that love and hate have in similar. But they definitely reside within borders of each other.
I don't really know (never a psychologist) but I believe that there are times and situations when love and hate don't and do mix. I think aiming for perfect love (love without hate or any other emotion) is not achievable unless you are a believer in perfect love stories or fairy tales. Humans are very complex creatures (that would an understatement) and are very capable of changing emotions within seconds. And even if they do experience love or hate, it is almost always not with a particualr single emotions.
@Rick1950 (1576)
• Lima, Peru
1 Sep 11
I think love and hate are together. They can't be separated. If you feel so much love there is always a little bit of hate. But love is so huge that hate can't be noticed. Maybe this is like as the relation between body and spirit. Sometimes things of the body are dominating over the spirit and vice versa.
@flowerfest08 (1677)
•
30 Aug 11
hi:)
as they always says "love is the nearest thing to hate" if you really think about this you will be able to realize that it make sense, because in reality it is only the one you love so much, that can turn you to hate them so much.
@jm0405 (10)
• United States
30 Aug 11
No. You need an opposite to occur in everything so you know love when you see it, and also so you have something to compare it to. If everybody had one mood - happy (never mad), only love (no hate), laughter (never tears), they wouldn't appreciate what they have, would take it all for granted, and never build real character. It's the good and the bad in our lives that creates inner strength, to fix faults/flaws in our personalities, learn to truly appreciate things because we know things could be worse. Life with limited emotions/thoughts/moods would be extremely monotone and would become very boring at a rapid pace.
@kingparker (9673)
• United States
30 Aug 11
I never thought about this. I guess you are right, maybe right, our human emotion can't have love without hate. We hate when our love turn around a corner. When our love just betray us, we develop hate. Just like love enshrouded with darkness all of sudden, and that is hate suddenly control our emotion toward another person. So, it just in a fleeting moment of it.
@TwiKnight (107)
• Malaysia
30 Aug 11
I suppose anyone would be able to comprehend love in such a circumstance, though one probably would say that should one cease to exist, the other shall follow suit, leaving only a sort of impassiveness you'd normally perceive from strangers on the street. Without hate, you'd probably still be able to appreciate someone else's virtues, which could still constitute as love. So, yeah, why not?