I want to ban televison and movies in my house. It corrupts our kids!
By zionsphere
@zionsphere (673)
United States
September 7, 2011 1:30pm CST
I tried to watch two hours of television without getting offended, or seeing something that wouldn't confuse or corrupt my child, and I couldn't do it.
The shows geared for children teach them to disrespect their parents, and date as young as 13??
I rented a Disney movie for my daughter to watch, and she became obsessed with it, wanting to watch it over and over until she memorized it, and then started to act it out. The girl in the movie was oppressed by a woman posing as her mother (the movie was Tangled) and left her tower against her mother's wishes. My daughter started pointing out how the mother in the movie sounded just like me, talking about keeping her safe all the time.
It occurred to me that the movie was convincing my daughter that I was just like the villain! When she started yelling at me when I told her no about going to a friend's house and starting a facebook account, while making faces at me like the girl in movie, I had to tell her she couldn't watch it anymore.
At this point I've decided that going to the movies every once in awhile is OK, but the constant reruns, and replays of all this garbage has to go! The tv is officially off indefinitely.
2 people like this
10 responses
@choybel (5042)
• Philippines
8 Sep 11
I think that it would be better fr you to spend time watching some shows with them so that it becomes a bonding moment and you get to supervise the shows that appear on TV. You could also explain some things afterwards, regarding the shows you've watched. It can become an activity, one that you can spend with your children and at the same time lecturing them. This way, you turned something bad into something very good.
@zionsphere (673)
• United States
10 Sep 11
I used to do that with her as we watched sesame street. Now I would like to spend our bonding time doing more productive things like teaching her to paint, or bake a loaf of bread. The kind of bonding that happens during TV time won't even be remembered when she is grown.
@zionsphere (673)
• United States
12 Sep 11
yes, we have done some planting :) Just chives so far, but maybe some day we will plant a tree too.
Thank you
@stary1 (6612)
• United States
11 Sep 11
Gosh I sympathize with you. I keep hearing those same complaints from mothers of young kids. It has to be harder today to raise kids than a generation ago. I know every generation tends to say theirs is the hardest but honestly I am glad my girls are grown and on their own.
It seems to me society and the media are trying to force kids to grow up way too fast and it can't be good for them.I applaud your efforts to do all you can to raise your kids with values and not let the outside world raise them.
@zionsphere (673)
• United States
12 Sep 11
Thank you! FINALLY someone understands where I am coming from. I just want what's best for me and my daughter in my own home. I really didn't expect everyone to accuse me of being overprotective, and hiding the "real world" from my child just because I don't want her watching the same shows that teach her bad attitudes all the time.
It's sad when you have to defend yourself for defending your own home.
@stary1 (6612)
• United States
12 Sep 11
There are some women who over protect, but I am sure you are not one of them. Like most Moms you want what is best and the only reason you want to take the TV is out of concern.
I restricted some programs from my girls..lol I remember Married with Children was one of them and the girls laugh about it to this day.
Thank you for theBR
@celticeagle (168256)
• Boise, Idaho
8 Sep 11
I think children are developing and growing up more quickly now days than they did when I was a youngster. I agree that television and movies have some disrespectful situations in them But, hiding these from a child can be just as harmful as letting them see it on tv and then discussing it with them. Kids are going to see it out in the world and I think it is better for them to see it at home and then have it explained and discussed rather than surprised by it and not know how to handle it or respond to it.
@zionsphere (673)
• United States
10 Sep 11
I actually think it's better to go out into the world with our children instead of sitting at home watching tv with them all night. I explain things that I see other people doing, saying, and wearing all the time. The difference is, when I talk to her about the real world, her memory isn't full of television clips that made her laugh or made bad behavior look glamorous.
It is true she will see it all in the real world, the difference will be, that it isn't half as entertaining when you're living in it, as it is on the screen.
1 person likes this
@celticeagle (168256)
• Boise, Idaho
10 Sep 11
It is great fun to do that. I just wouldn't hide too much from a child.
@alicia812 (646)
• Australia
8 Sep 11
Hi zionsphere. I believe that what we see on
television and in movies are mere reflection
of the bigger picture in the outside world.
I think you should not ban television or
movies from your kids to see, rather, watch
it with them and explain the things that you
think they should know and learn. But of course
it's a good thing to stick to some limitations
on what type of television shows or movies they
can watch, depending on their age and understanding.
Kids need us, parents, to guide them to better
know what's good and bad. So when it's time for
them to face the world outside 'home', they would
have a good understanding of everything and they
would be able to have a good decision making abilities.
Don't get me wrong though, I sometimes feel the same
way you do especially when I see my daughter acting
out like those characters on television. I just try
my best to explain everything to her, and she does listen.
@knicnax (2233)
• Philippines
9 Sep 11
Aren't we getting a little too protective? There's a reason why your daughter likened you to the mother in tangled, it seems that (based from this post, I'm not judging you entirely) you are like that in more ways than one
I get that you want your daughter to be good and you just want what's best for her, but you have to let her live her life, no matter how young she is. If you protect her too much, she'll be a very weak person. You're robbing her of life's lessons.
Protecting your child of course is good, just don't over-do it. give her some slack every once in a while. Also, explain why you're doing. If you don't explain and just stop her everytime, she'll start to rebel, and it will definitely break your heart. Trust me, I have seen this happen to a lot of my friends
@zionsphere (673)
• United States
10 Sep 11
LOL! anyone that knows me knows better. I'm one of the most laid back people on the planet...
except... I don't let my daughter continue exposing herself to anything that will hurt her now, or in the long run.
I gave birth to my daughter, I didn't steal her from a palace so I could use her magic hair. She's not locked in a tower...as a matter of fact, she's spending the night at a friend's house right now.
I know she will be exposed. Almost every child has an ipod that they are more than happy to expose her with, but I don't have to let her watch the same movie 10 times in one week in order to let her "live"
I wouldn't say I'm robbing her of any life lessons at all. I simply want to her be more exposed to REALITY than Disney's perception of fairy tale angst.
What you and many others have missed is that I explain things, and talk to my daughter every day. She respects me for the most part, which is probably why I feel so strongly about her yelling at me, and saying that I was acting like the villian in the movie. I know that isn't like her at all.
We also disagree about facebook, because her friends have accounts, and I want her to wait till she is 16 (which I don't feel is unreasonable for the reason of computer viruses alone) but since she wanted one so bad, I brought it up to her doctor at her appointment, and the doctor pointed out that there is a setting for children younger that 16, so I told my daughter I would check it out, and give it some thought.
If that's not enough slack, that's just tough. Bottom line is, I love her. Everything I let her do and don't let her do is because I love her.
But tv has nothing to do with my love for her, or being a good parent. I don't watch it myself for the same reasons I don't want her to watch, so really, I'm just loving her the same way I would love myself. I told her that, and even though she doesn't want tv banned in our house, she understands.
1 person likes this
@FarahJane1011 (180)
• Philippines
8 Sep 11
I also want to ban television in our house because our household help can no longer do their task properly because they kept on watching television. They cannot focus on their work. And am already tired repeating instructions over and over again. Sometimes, i intentionally unplug our television, but all they do was just o plug it again. I don't want to sound so strict but what's the use of paying them to work when i am the one doing their supposedly task? I prefer to do it instead of telling them because am already tired instructing them. As in they really can't focus. That's my reason why i really wanted to ban television in our house. Wish i could put a password on our tv!
@Keola12 (823)
• United States
8 Sep 11
The best thing for you to do is to fire those people, because it doesn't make any sense for you to pay them when they aren't doing any of the work they were hired to do. Especially, since you end up doing the work yourself anyway. I don't think it's fair for you to have to throw away your money on help who are nothing but useless in the first place.
@apsara60 (6610)
• Israel
8 Sep 11
hello zionsphere, I can understand how you feel. My thinking was like yours but now I think, that someday ,time will come when you and me will not be there to help and guide our children. World outside our homes is very harsh and cruel and our children have to learn to face this and to live with it. So let them see the world and be strong. You can tell them what is wrong and what is right, but don't stop them from seeing the reality because then they will be innocent and ignorant and many people can abuse them if they will know about this drawback. I hope you are understanding what I want to say. The whole world is corrupt today, so we have to teach our children how to remain good while living between all bad and ugly and I am sure they will learn it.
@zionsphere (673)
• United States
10 Sep 11
That's the problem. Tv is NOT reality. Far from it. The parents on the disney channel behave as though they don't know anything. So do the parents on nickelodian. In many scenes, they parents are nowhere to be found, and 13 year olds are going on dates unchaperoned, and making out all the time.
That isn't nor ever should be anything close to reality. I want to teach my child to respect her elders and her future boss, and to do things that don't involve designer clothes, boys that also have no respect, and getting into a bunch of trouble just because it's cool to be a rebel.
I've explained to my daughter that tv is nothing like reality, but she still tries to act like those characters.
@zionsphere (673)
• United States
10 Sep 11
Thank you for your compliment :) no, there aren't many wholesome shows, and more and more people try to become the characters they see on tv or listen to on the radio. What they miss is that the people who act and sing had to live lives instead of watching other artists on television or listening to them on the radio. If my daughter whats to be a princess, great! That means she has to go to college and get a career so that she can afford all of those nice dresses, and glittering jewelry. But hopefully... once she grows up and get an education, she will see how empty those things really are, and choose to spend her money doing something that will better herself, or the rest of the world.
@bounce58 (17385)
• Canada
10 Sep 11
I wish I could shield my kids from the unnecessary by-product of today's television. Aside from getting the idea of being disrespectful, most programs teach kids to be materialistic.
But, I chose to expose my children to this. Not just because of convenience, but also to get them acclimated to what it is in the real world.
I wish you luck!
@mommytam (17)
•
11 Sep 11
first. trying to ban somting that crorupts kids well everything does. and you cant always keep things from your kids . but teach them about things. the good and the bad. My daughter also loves the movie tangled and she watches it every night before bed. but she knows the difference. she is 2 1/2 . she knows that the women who kept the girl in tower was a bad guy. she also understood that her real mom was the queen. but you cant keep your kids safe all the time. the only way to really keep your kid safe is not by hiding from everything. but walking with them threw things. tell them why things are . why not to touch the stove. not because i said so but that it hot and can burn you.