Classics or comtemporary?
By albto_568
@albto_568 (1268)
Costa Rica
September 23, 2011 9:44pm CST
What do you prefer to read?, classic writers, or the contemporary?, I have always have enjoyed reading the classics better, specially the russian ones, Chejov, Gogol, Tolstoy, Dostoyevsky are among my favourites, I also love to read the Latin American Borges, Cortázar, Márquez, just to name a few, of the most known ones. I have to admit that I spare too little time in searching for new material, but, when I do, I find so nice surprises too, yet, I think that I prefer to read the classic writers. What is your case?, Do you prefer reading classic books or material from new writers?
2 people like this
4 responses
@allyoftherain (7208)
• United States
24 Sep 11
I'm an avid reader, but haven't really enjoyed too many books considered classics. Probably the only classics I've really loved and enjoyed have been J.R.R. Tolkien's The Lord of the Rings and The Hobbit. I had to read To Kill a Mockingbird by Harper Lee and Pride and Prejudice by Jane Austen for school, and out of the dozens of classics that we had to read those were the only ones I even remotely liked.
So I guess I'm almost completely more contemporary, but I'm not always looking for brand-new stuff. I read books from different eras that may not be considered classics or the latest bestsellers. My favorite genre is high fantasy.
@albto_568 (1268)
• Costa Rica
25 Sep 11
I guess that being your favourite genre the fantasy, the most interesting material for you is the modern one, besides, when we are forced to read a book, specially in high school, it is a lot less funny. I remember that I had to read The Quijote in high school, and I hate it, years later, I start to read it again, with bore at the beginning, but I finally like it. I read Pride and Prejudice once, and I really didn´t like it that much, although, being fair, I read a spanish translation, to be able to judge, I would have to try the original.
1 person likes this
@allyoftherain (7208)
• United States
25 Sep 11
Well there aren't too many fantasies that have achieved classic status, though there have been a number of them written all across time. Fantasy gets shunned by loads of literary critics. I never read a single fantasy novel in school, so there was nothing to hate for being forced to read. The fantasy classics that I've read, I've read outside of school.
And the point of fantasy is hardly to be "funny" for me, though maybe that's not really the word you meant to use...? I like fantasy because I like good vs. evil, hero's journey, epic quest to save the world, mythological creatures, mythological worlds... that kind of thing. Humor really isn't essential.
You know, I don't think I disliked many of the books I was forced to in school cause I was forced to read them. I remember many of the books I was bored by, depressed by, and offended by. I don't really think anything would change should I read them now.
And I said I remotely liked Pride and Prejudice, but that was cause it was a largely sweet and pretty straightforward story in a parade of books with unhappy endings, unlikable characters, unlikable plots, and symbolic hoo-ha. I don't expect everyone would like it, but if you want to try the original and see if you enjoy it any better then I'd say go for it.
@cowgirl03051979 (918)
• United States
25 Sep 11
well i dont really like to read between work and taking care of my small farm i just do not have enough time for it but i remember when i was in school and i had to read something because my grade depended on it i always liked reading the classics better than the contemperory in my opinion nothing can beat the classics i never really paid any attention to the authors of books so i dont really know any authors but i remember the titles my favorite classic book of all time is where the red fern grows followed by black beauty and lonesome dove
@albto_568 (1268)
• Costa Rica
25 Sep 11
Thanks for the reply, I guess that your work leave you tired at the end of the day, sometimes, I feel the same, but I always like to spare some time to read on the weekends, if I have had a rough week. As you, I like the classics better, and I did not like to read while in school, maybe it was that I didn´t read for fun, but because someone tell me to do so.
@ram_cv (16513)
• India
24 Sep 11
I would say that it all depends on the my mood. I tend to like contemporary authors more as I like sci-fi and fantasy fiction. But then I have also read a lot of classics by authors such as Arthur Conan Doyle and Isaac Asimov which I have simply loved. So I think it is more a question of what mood I am in at that moment.
Cheers!
Ram
@albto_568 (1268)
• Costa Rica
25 Sep 11
Indeed the mood we have in a particular time will make us pick either one or another, classics or contemporary, still, most of the time we will have preferences for either one or another, I believe. In your case, that you enjoy sci-fi, and fantasy, I guess that the most interesting material is the modern one, yet, reading classics can be interesting, specially to find out that, what they call science fiction, a hundred years ago,or so, is our everyday life, some material of Julio Verne is a good example of that. Thank you for your reply.
@oXAquaXo (607)
• United States
24 Sep 11
I enjoy contemporary writers' work. I feel as though I can connect with them better, because life has changed much in the hundreds of years, and many people have different perspectives, now.
But that doesn't mean I don't read the classics. I take many classes on literature in school, and read many classics every month. I enjoy some of them, and abhor others. But for some reason, I always feel a slight detachment from them, as though I can't truly connect with those authors. Maybe it's the writing style, maybe it's the anachronism, but in the end, I just don't enjoy them as much as contemporary pieces.
Happy mylotting everyone!
@albto_568 (1268)
• Costa Rica
25 Sep 11
I understand your feelings, and thanks for the reply. Although life has change, and the perspectives of live and expectations, has change 180º, I believe that the human experience, is basically the same, I mean, we all love, hate, have the same basic fears on loneliness, we all have the desire to success and to strugle in order to achieve our dreams, and, this is the same, regardless the time, all the good writers, ancient or new, treat this same topics, of course, styles are diferent, and the way of seeing live too, I guess is just a matter of tastes.