Do You Think Cats Need Other Cats

By Joni
@joni1215 (394)
United States
October 12, 2011 1:44pm CST
I had a kitty for 16 yrs and she was my life. After about a year I decided I had to have another baby to love. So, I rescued Fancy from a local rescue. Now, I see she sleeps a lot and plays a little but I can't help but feel like she could use a friend of her own kind. My husband disagrees . He says, She is our baby and we are all she needs." He really has her spoiled. I so much want to get her a friend and I could use more kitty love too. Thing is, that if Fancy gets upset she pees on things. And I don't want that. I had thought of trying to get a kitty from someone who will let me bring it back if it doe snot work. But, my husband says he does not want to stress her out or make her think she has been replaced. What to do :(
3 people like this
7 responses
@ElicBxn (63594)
• United States
12 Oct 11
4 years as an only might really cause a few problems, I know that bringing in pairs that were only used to each other has caused stress in the past - Tuti and Nef adapted really well, but Mo and Diva aren't. I blame it on their being declawed. Tuti took a lot longer to adapt than Nef did, but Nef was so busy that she was happy to have playmates! I would wait because Fancy isn't used to having another cat around, but you might try to find ways to get her to play more... Now - I've had cats that I thought were feral, but after I got my hands on them, they remembered being pets and were very tame - that might be what happened to Fancy - that she became a scared cat and was thought to be feral, but was actually put out when she became "inconvenient" or went into heat...
1 person likes this
@GardenGerty (160624)
• United States
12 Oct 11
I can see with her funny attitude about food she might get over run by a more dominant cat, but I am not sure, I know that Elic has a lot more experience than many of us.
1 person likes this
@TheCatLady (4691)
• Israel
12 Oct 11
How old is Fancy? What information do you have about her? Does the rescue know her history? Some cats love having another feline around, yet some hate it. I have a few cats who would prefer being an an only cat. Unfortunately that will never happen. I have a house full of fur faces. 7 of my cats plus 7 fosters. 2 dogs and one foster. The numbers are always changing so they just have to deal with it.
1 person likes this
@joni1215 (394)
• United States
12 Oct 11
Good for you and all the furbabies. Makes me smile. Fancy is about 5 yrs old now. She was one yr when I got her. I think she spent most of her life in a cage. She does not seem to have real cat instincts. She has to be walked to her food as she will not go on her own. Like she has to ask permission or was used to her food being brought to her. I was told she was picked up as a ferrel cat. And they snipped her ear in case she was put outdoors again. They(the pound) will not pick up ferrels if they have been fixed. But, my vet says she is far too gentle to have been a ferrel.
1 person likes this
@GardenGerty (160624)
• United States
12 Oct 11
Did your other cat die? I am not clear from your discussion. Fancy may be peeing on things because of an underlying issue with her food having too much ash, or she could be lonely, or she could just be triggered by some smells of things. My experience is that female cats are not as accepting of new family members as male (neutered) cats, generally speaking. On the other hand, if she is fairly playful, she might enjoy company. Are you home during the day or not? I would ask the vet for an opinion. My older male cats usually have been happy and very loving if I brought home younger cats and did not replace their position as top cat. Maybe a younger cat would be a good choice, especially a young male.
@joni1215 (394)
• United States
13 Oct 11
yes, she passed away. She had thyroid trouble and had to take a pill everyday. I miss her so very much. I think I am just gonna leave things as they are. Fancy is too touchy it seems.
@jennybianca (12912)
• Australia
18 Oct 11
A lot of cats love company, particularly if you get kittens together or close together. They play so much, and they cuddle up. I have had cats that are very close companions. On the other hand, I have to report thqat my older cat, a dark tortie, hates all other cats. She can't bond with them at all. when we got our second cat, two years after getting our first, she hissed and carried on and would never be friends, despite the new cats efforts. This cat bonds with people , not cats. So it is hard for me to suggest what would work for you. As your ktten is very young, the chances are very high that she would bond to another kitten.
@joni1215 (394)
• United States
26 Oct 11
I guess I should have mentioned that Fancy is about 5 yrs old now. So, I don't think I should get her a playmate now. Had some time to think about it and she gets stressed real easy. So, I guess I am her playmate lol
@jaiho2009 (39141)
• Philippines
12 Oct 11
My daughter just came home with a kitten and she is so cute but sometimes mean. Maybe because she was not treated well by her owner before, that is the reason why my daughter adopted her. Now, we are trying to tame her, since she's still a baby,she's around 4 months old and still small. My youngest son loves to play with her but she's not that playful too. have a good day
• United States
17 Oct 11
How old is your youngest son? "mean" may simply be normal kitten play. Young children sometimes don't know how to play with a kitten or a cat. A four month old will settle down eventually. Set aside certain times of day for "play" - interactive toys are wonderful with kittens - the kind with a wand and something for the kitty to jump after. Ten minutes of intensive play will wear the kitten out. Too much handling can be rough for a kitten - they can get overstimulated, much like a human baby. If she was mistreated, she may have trust issues and it will take some time to gain her trust. Is she fixed? Sometimes having a kitten spayed (by four months, the kitten is old enough) or neutered helps. good luck, and don't give up. The last thing she needs is another rejection.
• United States
26 Oct 11
Fancy has been doing well on her own so there is no need to add a new kitty to your home. Giving Fancy play time with kitty toys every now and then will keep her happy. If not much on play, sprinkle a little catnip on toys to encourage play. I have 10 cats of various ages (oldest is 16 yrs...youngest 4 months). One totally hates not being an only cat and one has always been gentle/accepting of any new arrivals. It was never a goal to have so many cats, but it just happened with all the kitties in our area and no homes. We have spay/neutered them all. Luv them all, but wish people would spay/neuter and give kitties a forever home. :)
• United States
26 Oct 11
P.S. While most young cats cuddle together and play together as they grow older they normally get more independent. Grown cats usually are very self-absorbed and don't really care if they have a fellow cat buddy.
@gothtini (219)
• United States
12 Oct 11
I'm not sure if that would be a good idea or not. I think the best thing to do is if you have a friend in the area who doesn't mind other cats, have them bring it over and see how your cat reacts to it. Both times I've tried to have two cats, it didn't end well and the younger had to go back. All cats are different though, I would say it would be worth a shot since she had been around other cats before. Though the thing to keep in mind about her small amount of playing, she's a bit old from what you said in a response and may be past her playing stages. Some cats play their whole lives others prefer to lay around and sleep. So if she doesn't take well to another cat, I wouldn't worry about her amount of activity.