what would you do if.

Malaysia
October 30, 2011 8:00am CST
your girlfriend wants to be engaged to you, but you refused because these reasons: a) you don't have savings b) you don't have a stable job. c) you feel forced to do so. d) she is the super social type, a night-life type of girl. e) you are not sure if your family approves it. f) her father has three wives and sell illegal cigarettes for a living. g) you find it hard to really trust her. but, she is really caring and is a CHEF!... this is the dilemma...... what would we do about it?
3 people like this
12 responses
• United States
30 Oct 11
If there's NO trust....It's not gonna work. It sounds as if, there's no trust and communication in this relationship. Has it always been her way or no way in this relationship? That's not good. Ya need to sit her down and set her straight. Let her know ALL the things that are bothering ya. Once you're done talking, allow her to speak. If she isn't okay with your feelings....I would say it's deff time to move on - without her. Ya shouldn't be forced into anything.
1 person likes this
• Malaysia
30 Oct 11
we broke up several times but continued our relationship again.. maybe i should migrate to somewhere far from her and then only i could move on.. but for the time being, our problem is just a bit too messy to be resolved.. maybe i should give it more time..
1 person likes this
• United States
30 Oct 11
I've been there and done that for "26" years. I thought for sure, he would change. How much more time are ya willing to give? Always remember.....Ya can't get those years back. Everyone deserves to be happy, including yourself.
1 person likes this
• Malaysia
30 Oct 11
well, i hope ample time will give me the strength to do so..
1 person likes this
• India
30 Oct 11
Hi soulpatrol84. Can I be a little straight, based on how I see your situation? First of all there are too many uncomfortable factors to contend with. Second, I think the girl appears to me to be too overbearing although you perceive that she is very caring. Third, I don't get a feeling that you seem to be playing a passive role in the whole matter. I'm not sure even whether you love the girl wholeheartedly. If any of my assessments are incorrect, that is if the girl is overwhelmingly caring, she is not imposing too much of expectation on you, you really love her, then too you must be able to talk it out in detail with her and even with your people. There is no virtue in blinding oneself to an enormous degree merely because of one emotion. As you go along in life, in any case, many emotions will have to be balanced with logical reasoning. Especially the more material issues. So, whatever you may do, do it after extensive weighing of all pros & cons and never do things because your were forced to do. Good Luck.
1 person likes this
• Malaysia
4 Nov 11
that's why love can make us blind.. people can do crazy stuff just because of love.. thanks for the good advice.. :)
@sid556 (30959)
• United States
31 Oct 11
Hi Soulpatrol, Welcome to MyLot! Actually this is a pretty easy question to answer. DON'T DO IT!! No one should ever get engaged or married for the the sole reason that someone else wants them to or out of fear of losing that person if they don't. What the family thinks would be the least of my concerns. If you find it hard to trust her then why would you marry her? What her dad does for a living should not reflect on her as a person. You should not marry a person unless you love that person and are ready to spend your life with them without wondering about any of the above. There should be no question in your mind or your heart that you are doing the right thing.
@sid556 (30959)
• United States
1 Nov 11
Hi Soulpatrol, I think you should listen to your own advice because it's good!
• Malaysia
1 Nov 11
im facing the right time in making the right decision.. maybe i haven't found my perfect soulmate yet.. maybe god guide me in doing the right thing..
@WakeUpKitty (8694)
• Netherlands
30 Oct 11
Read back the list you gave about the reasons why you don't want to be engaged. Are the reasons really written in the right order? I think the real reason is that she is not super, it's a night life type of girl, really hard to trust and you are not able to give her what she will need. Since you have a big lack of self esteem and I have not heard you say once she is the girl of your dreams and you feel forced the answer is clear. It's a big NO. If you feel forced to this engagement this relationship won't last long. If she really is the right person for you she will wait till love, trust and savings are there so you both can have a great start together.
1 person likes this
@shanemae (1025)
• Philippines
30 Oct 11
hi there soul! er, there are a lot of hindrances that you have listed out. i think the best thing that you can do is to explain to her your reasons if that didn't turn out good then tell her these things that you have listed out here also add these things like. you do not want to let go of her but there are some things that keep you from doing those and tell her all these things. you can also add that you want to have a better life for her but with your status now you can't give it to her but in time if she would give you enough time then you can give the life you want for her.(whoa! seemed like a tongue twister but i hope you get the gist of it) also if she would insist to be the bread winner then tell her you don't want that since you are the boy and you feel emasculation if she do that. i hope this helps. God bless you.
@shanemae (1025)
• Philippines
31 Oct 11
yeah, i get your point. i believe you would see light if you pray for it. no worries friend.
1 person likes this
• Malaysia
30 Oct 11
being the bread winner is the main reason why im not ready to be engaged.. it needs a lot of reasoning, dedication, trust and the list goes on.. and the major problem here is, MONEY.. i just wonder, how people manage to get free from these problems when i cant seem to see the light at the other side of the tunnel? maybe someone who has dealt with these situations in real life might shed a bit of light on this matter.. but anyway, thnks for the opinion..
1 person likes this
@airkulet (2700)
• Philippines
30 Oct 11
Explain to her in a good manner that you wont hurt her feelings because you are not ready to. Tell her that you need to save more so that you can give her a good future. I'm sure that she will understand it
• Malaysia
30 Oct 11
i tried a few times to explain, but only ended up in a teribble fight..
1 person likes this
@airkulet (2700)
• Philippines
30 Oct 11
hmmn looks like that the two of you are not compatible, do you really love her? or you are forcing yourself to love her?
• Malaysia
30 Oct 11
sincerely, i not really sure myself.. its kinda of like this mixed feeling that you have in which you your self is unsured of what it is.. its almost indescribebable..
1 person likes this
@Hatley (163776)
• Garden Grove, California
31 Oct 11
hi soulpatrol you in your lineup have given your own suggestion as to what to do. If she really loves you she will understand you need some time to figure things out, but if she is stressing you out this does not sound like love but more like controlling.Do you really want to be engaged to a girl whom you find hard to trust,to one who has a whole different idea of life style , to one you yourself realize is controlling you? What the heck does her being a c hef have to do with anything? If she were really all that caring she would not be pushing you and she would be trust worthy too.Neither one of you should be engaged to the other if you are made uncomfortable now as once married you are stuck. You do not get engaged and you start dating other women again. you need someone who is compatible with you and your own life style. a trustworthy girl and on who does not control you.
@mods196621 (3652)
• Philippines
31 Oct 11
Remind of you these things... ;love has no reasons.. It is a feelings but if you take a consideration well think more times before you go into it. Both of you has feelings to consider also you might be hurt if you do not think better.. try to examine which one is the best under those reasons you see. It is a big challenge.
• Malaysia
4 Nov 11
love is a blind feeling.. u cannot see it, just feel it...
@adhyz82 (36249)
• Indonesia
31 Oct 11
i think it`s dillema i think.. my simple question is do you love her?? what is your feeling when you are far away than her?? do you miss her??
• India
30 Oct 11
Hi friend..Just see whether she loves you and you love her. Don't take all these things into consideration and loose her. If she really cares, love you more you can trust her. Think positively and all the best for your life...
• Malaysia
30 Oct 11
she is really the that that likes to force you into doing something you dont like. and i find this really stressfull..
• Malaysia
30 Oct 11
*correction: she is really the type that likes to force you into doing something that you dont like. and i find this really stressfull.
• Philippines
2 Nov 11
explain to her in a nice way the reasons behind why you refused,im sure she well understand it. .but if not, well maybe you're not meant to be and find a girl that will understand the situation. . Good luck and God bless
• Malaysia
4 Nov 11
true.. hopefully i will find the right girl.. but for the time being, i'll just hold on.. (~.^)
• United States
31 Oct 11
There is nothing that you can say that wont hurt her feelings, Why are y'all together? I just going to say this spare yourself the heartache and pain and don't get married that would only make life more difficult and if things arent perfect now, marraige is not the magic fairy dust that would solve all your problems, hope this helps.