My brother's wife
By indahfth
@indahfth (11161)
Indonesia
November 23, 2011 3:15am CST
When I opened facebook, I was very surprised, with a status created by my brother's wife. My brother's wife, saying bad things about my parents, because, my parents, do not give money, which was asked by my brother. I became sad, angry, and finally tears. I really did not expect, my brother's wife, saying bad things.
13 people like this
48 responses
@zandi458 (28102)
• Malaysia
23 Nov 11
How could she do that to your parents in such a public place. She should respect her in-laws. Don't respond to her as it will give her more reasons to verbally abuse your parents when you respond. Just ignore and pretend that she didn't exist in your family.
2 people like this
@adhyz82 (36249)
• Indonesia
24 Nov 11
indah, sometimes i think it`s the function of her husband (your brother) for talking his wife that it`s not good attitude..
your brother must say clear that his wife is not child anymore, when all her action can be forgiven by all people..
it`s rude when talking about the parents ( i always say that mother in law is our mother too) and say bad things about our parents..
yes sometimes we are unhappy with our parents, but how come we can use our parents as topic in our facebook...
i can see many young player use their parents or teacher become topic in their facebook or another social site, because they feel it`s free for them
1 person likes this
@jdyrj777 (6528)
• United States
23 Nov 11
Thats really bad of her to do that. Why are they expecting the parents to give them money? If anything they should be giving your parents money. I know ive helped my daughter out alot even after she was grown up. But now things are not so good for me. My daughter helps me now. I hate asking her because i have always done ok alone and even when i was raising my kids alone. But now times are harder for me. i dont ask unless i dont know what else to do.
2 people like this
@jaiho2009 (39141)
• Philippines
23 Nov 11
Sorry to hear that you are going through many bad things lately.
Better talk with your sister in law.
It is good spreading words like that through internet.
She can face your parents...why let the whole world know the private and family issue...so bad.
@redvakaurvaki (4216)
• Indonesia
23 Nov 11
hi, indahfth, I'm so sorry to hear that..
by now I still wonder why people make facebook as their escape and forgot how to interact each other, how to solve problem together with their family or partner.I'm not a fake, sometime I did it, push my emotion to facebook, but it's only when I have no escape and the problem can not handle anymore.
my suggestion, you, your family and your brother's wife should talk each other about what problem occure.telling facebook won't solve any problem except adding extra problem and make your family shy because it's read by everyone.your problem isn't everyone problem, it should be family secret and solve by family.I believe it can be solve between your sister in law and all of your family
2 people like this
@indahfth (11161)
• Indonesia
24 Nov 11
My brother and his wife, living separately with my parents. I have often, talking to my brother's wife, and invited to become a harmonious family. But, no results. And the family of my brother's wife, blaming me, and I became despised, by the family of my brother's wife. I've given up. Rather, my focus with my mother, who was ill.
@indahfth (11161)
• Indonesia
23 Nov 11
I've been lazy, to talk to my brother's wife. So far, I've often talked to my brother's wife. But there was never any results. Lucky, who knows facebook my brother's wife, just me and my brother. Because, my brother's wife, never wanted to know, my family.
1 person likes this
@redvakaurvaki (4216)
• Indonesia
24 Nov 11
it's almost complicated thing.I understand if you don't want to talk with her again, but it won't solve anything but make everything come to worse.you need to talk to her and your brother to find way out because it've been big family problem.
do your brother and wife separately with your family or collect in one house?? If they life in house, they are better life separately since many unharmony family ( mother in law - daughter in law ) because they live in one house.
@Dassodils (2010)
• India
23 Nov 11
Oh....I don't understand why such people behave like this????If she have any problem with her mother in low,She can share her problems with you as a god sister....
The husband should not support his wife to stand as oppose to the parents....He should think that they are the people who protected him from his child hood....I think there will have some financial problem between your mom and her....When he asked money,May the parents will not have money with them to give....That women can earn money if they need money....I don't like that character....Means blaming other people for their own false....There will have any false form their part....
We should be perfect first.....Then We can blame others....But I don't like that behaviour... Don't worry...... God bless you friend...
2 people like this
@Dassodils (2010)
• India
24 Nov 11
It's very bad..... She will realize the value or the pain of some one in future.....
1 person likes this
@Pose123 (21635)
• Canada
23 Nov 11
Hi indahfth, This is one of the problems with facebook, people post things that should be kept private. While we cannot control how another feels, we do expect family members to be discreet in the things they say, especially in the social media such as facebook. Blessings.
1 person likes this
@bellis716 (4799)
• United States
26 Nov 11
Do you that people will actually believe what your sister-in-law wrote? Are there certain untrue states for which you feel the need to give a rebuttal? It is sad that she does not feel that she is a part of your family and, therefore want to protect the family's reputation.
1 person likes this
@indahfth (11161)
• Indonesia
23 Nov 11
It seems, would be futile to talk to my brother's wife. My patience has run out. I do not care, the wife of my brother again. Just let my brother's wife, who was mad, I do not want to go crazy. Responding to my brother's wife, just makes me mad.
1 person likes this
@sijabatnaburjut (2171)
• Indonesia
23 Nov 11
It was very sad. Was she not ashamed to bring family problems to the outside world? I recommend that you be not too concerned about her speech and more importantly, you should take care of the mother than you are dealing with him. It's good you're not too concerned with what she said. It is most important, keep harmony with your husband and do not easily get provoked by her. Okay.
@sijabatnaburjut (2171)
• Indonesia
23 Nov 11
It would be nice to communicate with her again.
1 person likes this
@sjvg1976 (41290)
• Delhi, India
23 Nov 11
Hello indahfth,
Its sad to see people in the world who are so greedy for money and just forget about anything if they don't get it.
You must warn her and your brother not to be so greedy i hope if she don't understand it your brother surely will understand it as afterall they are his parents also.
2 people like this
@ranilo70 (177)
•
30 Nov 11
try to talk to her and ask her why is she talking like that. . . let her remember that once you are married already you can stand on your own feet and that you should not ask something from your parents for parents only guides us not that they are going to give us once we are married already.
1 person likes this
@enelym001 (8322)
• Philippines
23 Nov 11
Oh my issue should be within your family only. I can't believe how she can tell all her friends or maybe your common family friends about these things. In fact your parents should not support or give money to any of you who are already having your own family. They both should work for their own family they started!
2 people like this
@chiyosan (30183)
• Philippines
29 Nov 11
i am sorry to hear about your brother's wife telling bad things about your parents and all for money! i mean your brother should be capable fo giving his family's needs and it is not your parents responsibility. i think you should talk to your brother about this especially that she has even posted a status in facebook - which i think is a very sensitive matter - it is personal because it pertains to your parents, and your family as a whole.
1 person likes this
@aprilsong (1884)
• China
30 Nov 11
Hi,first, i am sorry for what you said, and you know, i think one of the toughest relationships is the relationship between daughter-in-law and mother-in-law. I think your brother's wife doesn't say it openly, so you feel surprised when you see what she says in facebook.
I think maybe it is not a bad thing, because it let you know what is on her heart. if you have not read these, you won't know what is on her heart. i think you should talk with your parents, to make sure how much of her words are completely fake, and how much of her words is just misunderstanding between she and your parents. Well, why your brother ask money from your parents, is it because he has something urgent to do,while your parents have the ability to help, but refuse to help them? Or your brother just want to take money from your parents and will never return? does your brother know what his wife says on facebook? does he agree with her? if your brother will be with this woman in the rest of his life, i think it is better to treat this problem carefully, you know, lots of things are induced by misunderstanding.
1 person likes this
@indahfth (11161)
• Indonesia
2 Dec 11
From the beginning, my sister-in-law, always making trouble. Since the wedding, my sister-in-law always makes trouble. My sister-in-law, like spree Spree, and spend money, for something that should not need to be purchased. I did not tell this problem, to my parents, because my mother was sick, I do not want my mother getting sick, think about this.
@UmiNoor (4522)
• Malaysia
25 Nov 11
These people who say bad things about other people in cyber space is really stupid. Don't they know that what they put online will be there forever? And everyone is able to see what they've written. I'm sorry about your situation. I can understand how you must feel. Your sister-in-law was probably just venting her anger because as you say your parents refused to lend money to your brother. But that is really irresponsible of her to broadcast her personal problems for all the world to see. She's so shameless.
1 person likes this
@aeiou78 (3445)
• Malaysia
24 Nov 11
This is more about the personality and the morality.
In a Chinese family, we never want to disclose family matters to other parties unless we need some helps.
It is shameful to the family inclusive herself to disclose such matter in the facebook.
Shall we respect to someone who talks something bad about her own family?
Of course no.
As a sister-in-law as you, you should arrange a chat with her nicely.
Everyone in the family has the responsibility to support the financial problem.
1 person likes this
@indahfth (11161)
• Indonesia
2 Dec 11
Yes. It's very embarrassing. But lucky, my other family, no one knows, facebook my sister-in-law. So, this does not become something of an embarrassment.
I do not know, what I should do. But, for now, I leave this matter to my brother, to advise his wife.