difficulties understanding british accent

December 7, 2011 6:10am CST
Do native english speakers or american english speakers have trouble understanding british english or british accent, as well? they are both native english speakers (correct me if i am wrong) but the way the american english sound is more intelligible to me. I have a hard time understanding british or australian english. maybe because I am an asian, or because I am not proficient in the language. while british and australian english are correct in grammar, I have to hold my breath and listen attentively to every word, or need to think for some second or replay after a word is spoken,to get the thought of what was said.It is tiresome to listen to an instruction or story when it is narrated in british or australian accent. But when a british music is played, you can't tell the difference whether the one singing is an american or british. why is it so? what is it in the british accent, all people sound the same. There are some who speak clearer than the others. But they are all hard to listen to.
4 responses
@owlwings (43910)
• Cambridge, England
7 Dec 11
English is my mother tongue and I was brought up speaking what is called 'received' British English, sometimes called the 'King's English' or the 'Queen's English' (really a dialect spoken by certain people mostly living in the South-East of England). Nearly every language has regional variations in accent, emphasis pattern (or 'music'), idiomatic usage and vocabulary, and English is no exception. Besides the regional accents of Australia, New Zealand, USA (in which there are several very distinct accents) and Canada, there are also wide variations in regional and local accents in Britain itself and many English speakers have trouble in understanding people from other parts of even our small island! How intelligible a spoken language is to anyone depends on how familiar they are with the accent but mostly on how clearly the words are enunciated and the general rhythm and pitch variations of the speaker. A flat, even tone with little difference in either pitch or speed, with few 'punctuation' pauses is very hard to listen to, even for someone who understands and speaks the language as a native. Popular music from Britain tends to use a slightly 'American' accent (rolled 'r's, in particular) because much of that style of music originated in the States and it has become a sort of 'tradition' for British artists to affect a slightly American accent (which has been referred to as 'mid-Atlantic') when singing. Recently - and especially since the Beatles - there has been a trend for British singers to use a British accent (and British idiom in the lyrics). Listen, for example, to Lily Allen who consciously uses a strong London accent.
@owlwings (43910)
• Cambridge, England
7 Dec 11
As an experiment, I recorded myself reading the above response (not very well, I'm afraid!) and have tried uploading it to share on a free upload service: http://www.wikiupload.com/FLR5MF6735LKCBG I'd appreciate your comments on whether it's easier to understand the written version, above, or the spoken version ... or perhaps both together. No need to be complimentary!
@allknowing (136442)
• India
8 Dec 11
Here is what I have to say http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vGXYPJiOrDc
@owlwings (43910)
• Cambridge, England
8 Dec 11
Thank you allknowing. As you say, your English is good and perfectly clear. I enjoyed the pictures in the slide show while you recorded your message, too! I think I must explore using YouTube to record comments for MyLot. It is sometimes useful to hear what someone has to say as well as to read it. Like Scotland, Ireland and Wales, Indian speakers have a particular way of speaking which is immediately identifiable from the vowels. It is actually a very attractive form of English: many English speakers would call it 'foreign', even those who don't call an Irish or Scots accent 'foreign'! However, I believe that there are many 'Indian' speakers (I use the term in quotes because, in the UK, it is often used to refer to people from Bangladesh, Pakistan and other countries as well) who are far more fluent in English than in their own tongue - which may even be one which is not spoken outside their own village, so it can properly be called a variety or a regional accent of English, just as American, Australian, Scots, Irish and Welsh are thought of as 'accents'. It's interesting that you say I have 'no accent'. Does that mean, I wonder, that you think of my accent as 'standard' or does it mean that you can't immediately identify where I come from? Americans say that I have a 'British accent' (so, to them, I am identifiably 'British').
@jadoixa (1166)
• Philippines
8 Dec 11
me too sometimes it is quite hard to pick up and understand if english were spoken by british because of the way they pronounce it..compare to american english which quite clear..but when british sing in english they sound clear but on talking the words sound different..i don't why? but that's just how it is with them..i wish they could sound clear when spoken like the way i hear it on songs or when they sing,,
@Fortunata (1135)
• United States
7 Dec 11
You have to immerse yourself in it. If you lived in Great Britain, or Australia, you would pick up on it, and wouldn't be thinking about the differences, lol! My husband is from Great Britain, and we have been together for about fifteen years, so I am used to it, I guess. The accents I have problems with are from scotland or Liverpool. Once when we were visiting my husband's Mother, her neighbor came into the house from Liverpool. She spoke to me, and I couldn't understand a word she was saying to me!!! My husband told me after the woman left that sometimes he and his Mother couldn't understand her, either! Sometimes I have problems understanding people from Boston. I had a coworker from Boston, and I had to concentrate when he spoke to me, his accent was so thick, lol! I think it's just a matter of training your ear when you are learning a language.
@Mashnn (4501)
7 Dec 11
If you are used to interact with different people who speak different accent. Iam sure you won't have problem with accent. The problem with you is that you get used to been with those who speak American accent. That is why you find it hard to understand other. British grammar is original and very nice and easy to understand. I have used both the American and British Curriculum and I can tell you knowing British grammar is the best thing you can do to yourself.